ADVERTISEMENT

Next National Champ.

I find all this discussion of where all the lucky losers, you know the ones who didn't win there conference, get seeded for the national championship "playoff". It's just a nice, entertaining, money producing tournament.

Why should team A who beat team B to win there conference have to play and beat team B again?

I'll watch it and enjoy the games but I'll never think the lucky losers should ever get the opportunity to win a championship.

Case in point, the NY Mets this year who came in third but could advance to the WS. Not likely but possible they could beat LA who had the best record in the NL.

Why Wisconsin terrifies me (trap game)

And a #3, a #8 and a #9 finish. Despite being screwed out of several games against the B2G mafia.
Great seasons in '05 and '08 that left us wondering what could have been. The '05 loss to Michigan was brutal as was the Iowa loss in '08. We should have gone to the BCS title game in '08, no way we should have lost to Iowa. One of the top "bad" or heartbreaking losses in Paterno's career.
We then got exposed in the Rose Bowl as USC passed all over us. I wonder if we would have fared better versus Florida in the BCS title game since they did not have the passing game USC had.

In '05, even if we had beaten Michigan I am pretty sure Joe would have again, incredibly, been aced out of playing for the NC despite an undefeated season.

Recruiting other team's commits

Have got a general recollection based upon reading various newspaper articles at the time, that Marsteller had been quietly experiencing some rather significant, ongoing family issues prior to his official visit to PSU, issues which may well have been the primary drivers for, or possibly early results of, a now-well-documented alcohol and drug addiction. Presuming Cael made a personal family visit when initially extending a grant-in-aid offer to one of the country's top prospects, apparently nothing he saw or sensed at the time was enough to cause a change of mind.

Did the staff, based upon subsequently-received information, quietly suggest to Marstellar that he might find a better fit elsewhere? Did Marstellar simply decide on his own that he wanted to put a good chunk of distance between himself and family issues which were just not going away? Are both of these possibilities true?

Whatever.

What is certainly true is that no useful purpose could possibly have been served for the program, and certainly not for Marstellar, by anyone on the staff publicly or privately implying he might've been asked to move on. And, flip or no flip, Marstellar's experience and results in John Smith's program are now a well-documented matter of public record.
Some of everything and more.

Marsteller's family situation was the kind of thing you wouldn't wish on anyone. He seems determined to raise a better family than he experienced. Enough said there.

I don't recall if the home visit were at his home or on neutral territory (such as at the school). In any case, lots of people can hold it together for a few hours. And IIRC his self-destructive behavior grew in his SR year, at some point after schools visited him.

Marsteller has said that he felt enormous pressure to go to PSU, both external and self-imposed, and gave into that pressure. With an opportunity to reconsider, he did.

Leaving the family was a factor, but his decision was more about escaping the shadow of own legend. OKST made a ton of sense -- he'd be far from PA, it was a top program with a great coach.

OTOH, the party culture at OKST was the worst possible environment for him. But there probably was no good program for him until he bottomed out.

Why Wisconsin terrifies me (trap game)

Good post--we do tend to come out slow in a bye week so hopefully that's not the case
I'm not sure how good Wisconsin is. They weren't dominant in their first two games. Hard to speak about the Bama game as Van Dyke got hurt on the opening drive. Purdue and Rutgers are just bad teams.
The USC game--they looked good early then USC's talent just took over. Wisconsin's second half in that game was horrific.
I'd actually be more worried if we were playing an awful team this week with Ohio State following because we may overlook them but I think Wisconsin's a big enough name that it will be fine.
USC had some early game turnovers in their own end and I believe there was a defensive score that got Wisconsin up by multiple scores but once USC got settled in they took control of the game and won going away. Wisconsin on the road at night will be a challenge but it we think we are final four material then taking care of business in this one should not be a concern. That said, I expect close physcial battle and we'll need to play clean with our A effort to stay on track.

Recruiting other team's commits

This might be the wrong post to comment on but do the heavyweights right now seem like a fickle group? Why is Neves at OSU when he’ll never start? Why is Mullen trying to be a backup on VT’s football team when he can’t beat Catka? Why is Kueter messing around with football? Why is Gable doing everything except wrestle? Why are guys turning down full scholly’s and podium spots to play lower levels of football? Maybe it’s always been this difficult to keep heavyweights in wrestling but each one sucks for a fan.
Mullen quit football and has been focusing on wrestling only since last season ended

Why Wisconsin terrifies me (trap game)

If PSU loses to Wisky they don't deserve to be in the playoff if they also lose to Uh-high-ya.

Every team has injuries. PSU has recruited pretty well and needs to have had a plan to get younger players the experience and coaching to fill in with the other seasoned players ready to pick up some slack. And getting players such as Lane at Safety and Nelson and Robinson at LB ready shows just that.

No excuses, particulary with a bye week to prepare.
  • Like
Reactions: RickinDayton

Recruiting other team's commits

In order
Penn State offered.
Marstellar made a verbal commitment.
Marstellar came for an official.
Post visit the guys on the team who hosted expressed to Cael they did not believe Marstellar would be a good fit.
Cael suggested Marstellar might find a more favorable fit at a different school.
Oklahoma State announced Marstellar would be a Cowboy.
Nobody associated with the program ever challenged the narrative that Oklahoma State had effectively flipped Marstellar.
Have got a general recollection based upon reading various newspaper articles at the time, that Marsteller had been quietly experiencing some rather significant, ongoing family issues prior to his official visit to PSU, issues which may well have been the primary drivers for, or possibly early results of, a now-well-documented alcohol and drug addiction. Presuming Cael made a personal family visit when initially extending a grant-in-aid offer to one of the country's top prospects, apparently nothing he saw or sensed at the time was enough to cause a change of mind.

Did the staff, based upon subsequently-received information, quietly suggest to Marstellar that he might find a better fit elsewhere? Did Marstellar simply decide on his own that he wanted to put a good chunk of distance between himself and family issues which were just not going away? Are both of these possibilities true?

Whatever.

What is certainly true is that no useful purpose could possibly have been served for the program, and certainly not for Marstellar, by anyone on the staff publicly or privately implying he might've been asked to move on. And, flip or no flip, Marstellar's subsequent experience and results in John Smith's program are now a well-documented matter of public record.
  • Like
Reactions: Ski

FLO Must Go

Which brings up the observation that the quality of advertising seems to range between “clever and entertaining” to “I’d like to take a Louisville Slugger to the store and smash their product.”
The early Flo commercials were terrible. But now they have an entire ensemble with some funny story lines.

The one with the guy that quits football because he wants to be an insurance agent is pretty good.

It’s a Penn State World

I’ll never forget something that happened way back in summer of 1979. I was hiking with some friends way up in Rocky Mountain National Park and we were on a trail that was coming to the top of a small hill. We were almost to the top when a guy came towards us from the other side of the hill. It was an old friend who I knew from Harrisburg who also went to Penn State! We recognized each other almost immediately and talked for some time about what we each had been doing since graduating. Think about the odds of that happening considering both the time and distance involved.

PS - this happened long before WE ARE got started.
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT