Best PSU WR….Hands Only
- Thread starter grinagrin
- Start date
Kirk Bowman gets no love?
Dotson’s gonna be a pro. But I still see Engram as the standard.
Dotson’s gonna be a pro. But I still see Engram as the standard.
Been thinking about this as well. Went with engram over Dotson but that could change as the season goes on.
Shouldn’t Allen Robinson at least be in consideration?
McDuffie was my 1st thought…also Jackson. Of the guys mentioned, I’d say Engram (that catch he made against tosu defies physics).
I remember all of the ones listed, but Allen Robinson was on a different level. He just isn't remembered because it was the O'Brien years and he was not ever on a great team.
Guys in the pre-tacky glove era were pure pass catchers.
Ted Kwalick had hands so big he couldn't find gloves to fit. Best TE we ever had and that includes the excellent Kyle Brady.
My earliest memories of Penn State football all feature OJ McDuffie. Of the current crop, Dotson reminds me of a cross between Deon Butler and OJ. Not quite as good as either player though.
Hard disagree. Dotson is better than Deon and OJ. Big fan of all three of them.
Jack Curry was a good one; caught 117 passes with 15.7 yd/catch. This back in 1965-67.
Kenny Jackson, Bobby Engram, Allen Robinson, Chris Godwin -- some excellent receivers; Dotson is as good or better IMO.
I've been comparing Dotson to a combination of Bobby Engram and Chris Godwin. Faster than Bobby but with his positioning and body control. High points the football well like Godwin. Derek Moye had great hands and made some great catches. Good list from everyone so far.
