To be fair he in on par with a title a decade in the BT with Joe from 1999 on. Joe didn't dominate anything his last decade plus, but people forget that. Was his toughness there in 2000-2004 or in 1999 when they folded with 3 straight losses with the top 2 picks in the NFL draft, followed by 4 losing seasons in 5 years? In fact the problem with PSU is an older Joe thought PSU was above recruiting using technology like emails or skype. Hell it was a big deal when Joe skyped with Pryor and everyone else was already doing this. He was too big to do visits and stopped. Joe didn't want to invest in the program anymore and it fell behind. It's as if people don't want to admit that here. So while the young Paterno was in incredible, he left the program behind others instead of at the top. OB and Franklin didn't inherit PSU of 1986, far from it. Joe is a GOAT, but somehow plenty of people forget OSU, Iowa, and UM owning Joe for that last decade.
My issue with Franklin is the (hopefully was) the annual flirtation with any top school that had an opening. You can say it wasn't a distraction, but it seems like it was. Yes the most current teams lacked some toughness and the OL in particular seems to be the annual issue, but he also went to 3 NYD top 6 bowl games in 4 years.....so I won't sit here and say he's a failure as Joe wasn't doing that from 1999 on either. This post will rub some the wrong way, but PSU in this millennium isn't really any different with Joe or anyone else at the wheel. Joe had a great run in 05, Franklin did in 2016. Some decent years in between, but the program overall hopefully can and should do better. Let's hope last years class is the start of something good.