I don't see the big deal with landing any D11 guys, or even having the well poisoned a bit. I'm born/raised/graduated from D11 Northampton. Pretty decent history of wrestling at our school. It was part of Gym Class about 50% of the time it seemed. I was hoping that PSU would go after Julian Chlebove or Condomitti, just to have a Koncrete Kid on the team. But I wouldn't trade any of our starters for them. Mikey Labriola? We got much better. Sammy Sasso? Possibly, but we wouldn't have Van Ness then. Darian Cruz at 125? Nope as that overlapped with Nico I believe. And Jordon Oliver was pre Cael as well. Not certain if I'm missing anyone in the Cael era that had better credentials over 2-4 years.
As you mentioned, Oliver pre-dated Cael. Sunderland recruited him, and his mom wanted him to attend PSU, but getting far away from his extended family (and its drug issues) was absolutely the correct decision.
Here are all D11 state champs since Cael came to PSU:
PIAA State Champions from District XI (through 2020)
lehighvalleywrestlinghistory.com
You're right, Nico dominated Cruz in college. Chlebove was never a consideration after his year-long HS suspension.
A few others not on your list:
- Josh Kindig (OKST): supposedly wanted to attend PSU, but same weight as the Altons; landed in Smith's doghouse for partying
- Mike Racciato (Pitt): recruited by PSU; off-the-mat issues in college and died way too young
- Ethan Lizak (Goofers): recruited by PSU; same weight as Nico; involved in the Xanax scandal
- Aaron Bradley (Iowa): recruited by PSU; never wrestled in college, quit the sport after Mormon mission
- Ryan Anderson (Iowa State): academic issues, transferred to D3
- Ryan Crookham (Lehigh): recruited by PSU