I'm 100% with you, Dunk.
Counterpoint, inquiry: where does the Get In Early approach fit, for you? Examples being the Lee Bros from Indy. Did they improve their chances to reach their goals by committing in 10th & 11th grade and abdicating their HSSR years to move & train? Put another way, with your & my view toward consuming all the free visits, is it possible they would have experienced lost opportunity cost at Penn State if they had not verbal'd so early and if they had maxed out the recruiting game to postpone a decision until after 5 official visits? Might they have irrevocably lost the inside track at a PSU lineup spot, or worse: a scholarship oppty?
Thanks for taking my call, I'll now hang up & listen.