Listen to Borelli. Bad losses are not considered part of the criteria. So Boyle's bad losses didn't impact his seeding score at all and explains why he is ranked above Gilman. And Wanzek's head-to-head victory over Hammond counts for more than Hammonds Coaches Ranking and Winning Percentage combined.
Hammond gets RPI, CR, and Winning Percentage for 30% of his score.
Wanzek's head-to-head win gives him 25%.
That leaves:
Quality Wins 20%.............................................................Wanzek (Thomas, Friesth, Stafford), Hammond( Moore, Robinson)
They each get some percentage, it's not winner take all
Common Opponents 10%................................................................?
Qualifying Tourny Placement 10%......................................................neither
# matches at weight class 5% ......................................................Hammond