OT: Best Female Rock Singer (before music was obviously forever ruined)
- Thread starter MtNittany
- Start date
Darlene Love.Stevie Nicks:
Pat Benatar:
Ann Wilson:
Linda Rondstadt:
Janis Joplin:
Debbie Harry:
Joan Jett:
Tina Turner:
Ann Wilson in a runaway. Range, timbre and power. GOAT.
In her prime . . . .
In her prime . . . .
Last edited:
My vote is for Linda.....
Stevie Nicks:
Pat Benatar:
Ann Wilson:
Linda Rondstadt:
Janis Joplin:
Debbie Harry:
Joan Jett:
Tina Turner:
Stevie Nicks:
Pat Benatar:
Ann Wilson:
Linda Rondstadt:
Janis Joplin:
Debbie Harry:
Joan Jett:
Tina Turner:
Carole King and Joni Mitchell are uber talented, but by no means are hard rockers. Cyndi Lauper had a lot of ability, somewhat overshadowed by her being so off-the-wall.
As a young woman Ann Wilson was gorgeous. She took a LOT of abuse through her career because of her weight, which was a damn shame. She's a musician, not a fashion model. Just appreciate her awesome talent.
Ann Wilson- she does so many covers and does them well ,Stairway To Heaven is just as good as Led Zeppelin's.
Best outfit goes to Debbie Harry. She also has 2 songs in Rolling Stone Mag's top 500 songs of all time. Hmm...
Those who fail to vote for Ann Wilson - silly, silly fools
Love that track - great guitar and drums
Linda Ronstadt sold out arenas when no other female solo act could come close. Best female voice of the last 50 years.Stevie Nicks:
Pat Benatar:
Ann Wilson:
Linda Rondstadt:
Janis Joplin:
Debbie Harry:
Joan Jett:
Tina Turner:
Last edited:
It's tough. Linda Ronstadt had the best voice, but she was very country. If it was just about voice, I'd have included Cass Elliot, and she was very pop. Ann Wilson is the best rock singer, imo, and it's pretty hard to argue otherwise (maybe Stevie Nicks - but...). Those voting for Joan Jett realize this is about singing right?
That's the thing. What is Rock and Roll? A Rap group just got elected to the R&R HOF. Linda ran the gamut of music. She did rock, country, big band, soul, sang in Spanish, the American Song Book, Musicals, plus she's bat shit crazy, like most rockers.
Karen Carpenter was not a "rock" singer, but when anyone asks me(and I am a former touring guitarist and vocalist) I tell them the truth: Karen Carpenter was the greatest PURE SINGER, in the history of popular music, hands down. Absolute perfect pitch, tone, vibrato, breath control, phrasing, chest voice and head voice.
Another great, great singer that nobody is mentioning here is Laura Nyro. What an incredible singer AND songwriter.
Stevie Nicks:
Pat Benatar:
Ann Wilson:
Linda Rondstadt:
Janis Joplin:
Debbie Harry:
Joan Jett:
Tina Turner:
Grace Slick in her prime
Momma Cass
Cheryl Crow siging G&R Sweet Child of Mine
Etta James
Outstanding choice. She really should have been in the poll. Right there with the greatest ever.
And has to be - without doubt - one of R&R all time beauties.
Agree wholeheartedly. Incredible talent. And if autotune was around then, they would have calibrated the autotune to Karen.
Laura Nyro kicked ass. The Fifth Dimension covered so many of her greatest songs - 'Wedding Bell Blues', 'Stoned Soul Picnic', 'Sweet Blindness' and Barbra Streisand had 'Stoney End' and "Time and Love'. Everyone forgets the writer and original performer.
Let me add one more dark horse candidate. Made only a small mark in America, but was an immense star touring in Europe - Chi Coltrane.
Yeap Ann Wilson..........."Crazy On You", a great example of her "stuff".
One of my best friends out west worked with Cherie Currie, also of the Runaways. The Runaways actually had three singers who were very stylized and cool: Cherie, Joan, and Lita. It always pisses me off when critics call them a "producers creation" because that band was all talent, there was nothing fake or prefabricated about them. The only reason they say that, is because a svengali-type put them together in the studio when they started.
What a powerhouse, really just amazing, and she can STILL sing, although she doesn't do nearly as many shows or appearances any more.
I like them all, really like Stevie Nicks and Linda Rondstadt, but out of them all, no one has the range and rock heart of Ann Wilson. Ann Wilson all the way.
