ADVERTISEMENT

OT: For fans, I found the ultimate Cormac McCarthy line!

LionJim

Well-Known Member
Oct 8, 2003
37,797
19,331
1
Levittown, PA to Olney, MD
Re-reading All the Pretty Horses, page 23 in my paperback. "The boy who rode slightly before him sat a horse not only as if he'd been born to it which he was but as if were he begot by malice or mischance into some queer land where horses never were he would have found them anyway."
 
  • Like
Reactions: eloracv and demlion
Having read most of his books, some more then twice because well most don't even understand what he wrote and to quote it you better know it, etc.

The reason I say he is a hack is because most don't even understand his books for: theme, plot, narration, character development ( this one really throws the stupid into orbit ), etc.

Cormac McCarthy doesn't suck, he is just a hack. There is nothing original in his writing. Entertaining, yes. Genius, no...


Just one example: INCFOM the scene in the hotel makes no logical sense but with out the scene we don't get any ???? believable ????? surrealism that completes the action in the book / movie.

Most of you never read the book, just saw the movie, oh well...


Joke sig is less to say about me and more to say about living in the 21st century.

Trump Trump Trump Trump Trump is now my answer for everything...

N i t t a n y A m e r i c a
 
Having read most of his books, some more then twice because well most don't even understand what he wrote and to quote it you better know it, etc.

The reason I say he is a hack is because most don't even understand his books for: theme, plot, narration, character development ( this one really throws the stupid into orbit ), etc.

Cormac McCarthy doesn't suck, he is just a hack. There is nothing original in his writing. Entertaining, yes. Genius, no...


Just one example: INCFOM the scene in the hotel makes no logical sense but with out the scene we don't get any ???? believable ????? surrealism that completes the action in the book / movie.

Most of you never read the book, just saw the movie, oh well...


Joke sig is less to say about me and more to say about living in the 21st century.

Trump Trump Trump Trump Trump is now my answer for everything...

N i t t a n y A m e r i c a
LOL!
 
A bit of a twisted piece of literary criticism. Fits the persona though. I like it.
I am personally very fond of bad spelling, bad grammar, bad punctuation, and bad sentence structure in the service of an attack on McCarthy which suggests he is a hack because: 1) people don't read his books; 2) people don't understand his books; and 3) the ending of a movie made from his book fails to satisfy the reviewer. This from a guy who thinks it is very telling about the US that Donald Trump is the frontrunner for the Republican nomination.
 
I am personally very fond of bad spelling, bad grammar, bad punctuation, and bad sentence structure in the service of an attack on McCarthy which suggests he is a hack because: 1) people don't read his books; 2) people don't understand his books; and 3) the ending of a movie made from his book fails to satisfy the reviewer. This from a guy who thinks it is very telling about the US that Donald Trump is the frontrunner for the Republican nomination.

I am personally very fond of bad spelling, bad grammar, bad punctuation, and bad sentence structure in the service of an attack on McCarthy which suggests he is a hack because: 1) people don't read his books; 2) people don't understand his books; and 3) the ending of a movie made from his book fails to satisfy the reviewer.

That's entertainment!
 
I am personally very fond of bad spelling, bad grammar, bad punctuation, and bad sentence structure in the service of an attack on McCarthy which suggests he is a hack because: 1) people don't read his books; 2) people don't understand his books; and 3) the ending of a movie made from his book fails to satisfy the reviewer.

That's entertainment!

I was watching a special on Jon Stewart's departure from the Daily Show and at one point they were talking about Steve Carrell and they said something like, "The combination of his basic stupidity and massive arrogance is extremely funny." Bingo. Nittany America has a big career awaiting him if his literary reviews fail to garner kudos.:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: mn78psu83
When those with high praise come speaking you up with low objectives because they are caught in a net of words they don't understand, well who am I to banter wit and folly ?

On the other hand, if your hand fails to serves its rightful purpose, dig a little deeper you may find yourself very accommodating.

As to Cormac, he is what he is and he does what he does...

Trump Trump Trump !!!

N i t t a n y A m e r i c a
 
  • Like
Reactions: mn78psu83
When those with high praise come speaking you up with low objectives because they are caught in a net of words they don't understand, well who am I to banter wit and folly ?

On the other hand, if your hand fails to serves its rightful purpose, dig a little deeper you may find yourself very accommodating.

As to Cormac, he is what he is and he does what he does...

Trump Trump Trump !!!

N i t t a n y A m e r i c a
One of your better efforts. Bravo! Well done. Made me think of Nietzsche on Victor Hugo - "Victor Hugo: oder der Pharus am Meere des Unsinns."
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim
When those with high praise come speaking you up with low objectives because they are caught in a net of words they don't understand, well who am I to banter wit and folly ?

On the other hand, if your hand fails to serves its rightful purpose, dig a little deeper you may find yourself very accommodating.

As to Cormac, he is what he is and he does what he does...

Trump Trump Trump !!!

N i t t a n y A m e r i c a
Thank God for copy and paste
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT