Good for you!
I live in Bay Village and love it. The three areas in west Cuyahoga county are all very nice: Bay, Rocky River and Westlake. They are all 15 to 30 minutes from downtown, depending upon traffic (and no snow or accidents!).
RR has the best public schools in the area, probably in the state but home prices are nuts. (and I mean nuts, probably twice the price as Bay). They also have a great pool and workout club that is very inexpensive for RR residents. They also come to your house to pick up the trash, way cool. They have a great park on the lak
e named Rocky River Park.
Bay is a very nice, sleepy place. Lots of nice modularity priced home with a school system typically placed in the top 20 in the state. It is, rumor has it, the highest rate of FBI agents and engineers in the country (engineers are from NASA). It hugs the lake, like RR, and has a lot of really great state parks. Go check one out at the flashing yellow light at the
corner of Lake and Columbia Road. There is a little creek that flows into the lake. If you have to convince a wife or kids, take them to these parks and it will be all over. IMHO, much nicer than Cincy. Bay also has a nice pool but the area was donated by nuns that stipulated it would be closed on Sundays so that is a challenge.
Westlake is more "midwestern" and off the lake. There are some nice developments with some around golf courses, if that is your thing. Its a bit of a larger community. Westlake will be more "columbus-ish" or "Cincy-ish" since it isn't on the lake.
Avon and Avon Lake are nice but its in Lorain County and the culture is a slight change there. You can get more bang for the buck. Nice schools, especially avon lake. Much lower property taxes, though, and like every other big city, the fastest growing big box area because it is on the interstate outside the home county (lower sales taxes). But this is now getting out there as far as recruits going to and from the city.
Should you decide to live downtown there are hundreds of options in the city. And if not for the fact I live on the lake, I'd move there too. (little concerned about riots killing property value one day though). Ohio City is probably the "cool place" to live right now. Lots of good places to eat and condos popping up. Downtown there are dozens of lofts popping up. Just go to realtor.com and look downtown. Lots of energy downtown right now.
This one is just under $600k but the building has lots of places for ~ $300k.
If you are looking for the condo thingy, a place at Crocker Park could be cool. Crocker Park is one of those new "outdoor malls" with high end eateries and stores. Above the stores are condos. If you are an empty nester, that could be cool and fun.
Either way, drop me a line when you get settled and lets go to "around the corner" and have a pop and some wings. This week should be fun if the Tribe can close it out.