Greetings from UFF! Now that the brackets came out I was able to plug them in and crunch the “official” numbers for 2019. As a quick reminder, this is based on a probabilistic simulation of the whole NCAA tournament, including bonus points. The model is created in the software package GoldSim, which is the Jason Nolf equivalent of modeling software (Check them out!). If you have any questions or have a modeling problem you want to discuss please message me. Now that is out of the way…….
The model does very well, but this year looks to be a dog fight for the 4th trophy so the order of 3 to 5 could easily be scrambled. Here are a few observations:
1) Teams that tout # of qualifiers generally don’t have a good chance. It is great for your program but not great for winning the tourney. YOU NEED HIGH END FIREPOWER TO WIN. Think #1 and #2 seeds.
2) Bonus points are very important. The Penn State way. Penn State is really wrestling with the equivalent of 12 guys due to their bonus point rate. Watch the bonus rates drop off tremendously by the third round for most teams but not for Penn State (usually).
3) Teams that grind can work their way to a 4th place trophy but that is about it. Plus grinding is bad for the sport. Who wants to watch 7 minutes of collar ties and “riding” that entails letting a guy to his feet after 15 seconds and forcing him out of bounds 17 times? Stay in the circle and put on your damn big girl panties!!!! If you are in low scoring matches very frequently all it takes it one mistake and you are done, may work for duals but is a bad strategy for the tourney. You can grind your way to an individual title but the days of a team grinding its way to a title are over.
4) At the NCAA tourney almost every guy is a past state champion of some sort – I appreciate all the effort you put in.
5) Seeds don’t matter as much as we like to debate. Instead, look for early round landmines for highly ranked guys. That is what really hurts your team scoring (or serious injuries). A guy that is severely under- or over-seeded is likely to over or under perform.
6) There is one characteristic of a top ten wrestler that best predicts whether he will over or under perform his seed. This is based on sensitivity analyses using genetic algorithms on the data from many past seasons. Message me and I will let you know what it is
Okay here are the results for 2019 (As before, this is the team and probability of 1st, 2nd, 3rd, based on 10,000 realizations using latin hypercube sampling). Do we really care about 4th? Does anyone remember even who the third place team for most things? No, they don't. The model has a nice GUI and you can make charts and other cool stuff. If someone wants to see them message me and I can email you some jpg’s or other image files:
Team 1st 2nd 3rd
PSU 99.97 0.03 0 Chance of winning: Extremely high
Ohio St 0.03 66.3 26.0 Chance of winning: Your telling me there’s a chance
OkSt 0.00 28.8 47.2 Chance of winning: Tiny
Mich 0.00 3.2 14.5 Chance of winning: Same as against Ohio St in football
Iowa 0.00 3.8 12.5 Chance of winning: Hummingbird’s pecker size
This year is the year to sit back and enjoy the whole thing. Cheer for that unranked guy to place. Watch the battle for 3rd to 5th as teams. Enjoy a couple of our special wrestlers for one last tourney. If PSU got beat it would be a tremendous accomplishment for someone and that in unto itself should be appreciated.
UFF
The model does very well, but this year looks to be a dog fight for the 4th trophy so the order of 3 to 5 could easily be scrambled. Here are a few observations:
1) Teams that tout # of qualifiers generally don’t have a good chance. It is great for your program but not great for winning the tourney. YOU NEED HIGH END FIREPOWER TO WIN. Think #1 and #2 seeds.
2) Bonus points are very important. The Penn State way. Penn State is really wrestling with the equivalent of 12 guys due to their bonus point rate. Watch the bonus rates drop off tremendously by the third round for most teams but not for Penn State (usually).
3) Teams that grind can work their way to a 4th place trophy but that is about it. Plus grinding is bad for the sport. Who wants to watch 7 minutes of collar ties and “riding” that entails letting a guy to his feet after 15 seconds and forcing him out of bounds 17 times? Stay in the circle and put on your damn big girl panties!!!! If you are in low scoring matches very frequently all it takes it one mistake and you are done, may work for duals but is a bad strategy for the tourney. You can grind your way to an individual title but the days of a team grinding its way to a title are over.
4) At the NCAA tourney almost every guy is a past state champion of some sort – I appreciate all the effort you put in.
5) Seeds don’t matter as much as we like to debate. Instead, look for early round landmines for highly ranked guys. That is what really hurts your team scoring (or serious injuries). A guy that is severely under- or over-seeded is likely to over or under perform.
6) There is one characteristic of a top ten wrestler that best predicts whether he will over or under perform his seed. This is based on sensitivity analyses using genetic algorithms on the data from many past seasons. Message me and I will let you know what it is
Okay here are the results for 2019 (As before, this is the team and probability of 1st, 2nd, 3rd, based on 10,000 realizations using latin hypercube sampling). Do we really care about 4th? Does anyone remember even who the third place team for most things? No, they don't. The model has a nice GUI and you can make charts and other cool stuff. If someone wants to see them message me and I can email you some jpg’s or other image files:
Team 1st 2nd 3rd
PSU 99.97 0.03 0 Chance of winning: Extremely high
Ohio St 0.03 66.3 26.0 Chance of winning: Your telling me there’s a chance
OkSt 0.00 28.8 47.2 Chance of winning: Tiny
Mich 0.00 3.2 14.5 Chance of winning: Same as against Ohio St in football
Iowa 0.00 3.8 12.5 Chance of winning: Hummingbird’s pecker size
This year is the year to sit back and enjoy the whole thing. Cheer for that unranked guy to place. Watch the battle for 3rd to 5th as teams. Enjoy a couple of our special wrestlers for one last tourney. If PSU got beat it would be a tremendous accomplishment for someone and that in unto itself should be appreciated.
UFF