Top 10 Penn State receivers of all time

[Breeze90]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Kenny Jackson ('80-'83)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

ATTENTION: KENNY JACKSON IS NOW PLACED 4TH and JUWAN JOHNSON WILL REMAIN 10TH GIVEN FUTURE CONSIDERATION

 

[78SweetRevenge]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

Juwan Johnson wouldn't be on my list yet but likely will be in a few months. Good list overall--think we're likely missing old school guys though. I think the top 4 are dead on though

 

[David1956]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

Until J Johnson scores some touchdowns I don't see him on this list.

 

[Connorpozlee]

No Kenny Jackson?
It’s tough to rate receivers for me. A receiver is only as good as the guy throwing the ball to him. With that said, Robinson may belong at the top of that list. McDuffie is as good as I’ve ever seen at Penn State.

 

[artsandletters]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

Disagree. Deon Butler should be 4th, 6th, 8th and 10th. It’s a travesty.

 

[joeparules]

Until you add Kenny Jackson to this list, I cannot take it seriously.

 

[MtNittany]

No Kenny Jackson or Jimmy Cefalo but a guy w/ one career TD on the list?

 

[Option Bob]

Good list. I might place Derek Moye and Terry Smith ahead of Williams , Field, and Scott.

 

[LaJolla Lion]

Juwan Johnson has 1 career TD....no Kenny Jackson and I still think Norwood cracks that top 10. He was cool as they come and simply never dropped balls.

 

[grad83psu]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

 

[grad83psu]

You do know that you listed Butler twice, right? If he's worth both 4th and 6th place, he should be even higher on your list.

 

[We Are . . .]

Have to agree that Kenny Jackson is a serious oversight. A 2-time All American belongs in the top 5.

An old school end who should get an honorable mention is Jack Curry. Greg Garrity is a sentimental favorite for his catch vs. Georgia. Make him an HM as well.

 

[psuro]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

No Kenny Jackson, no Jack Curry and Deon Butler is on twice. He is not normal but he is not that good.

 

[Langmuir]

Gregg Garrity needs to be in the mix.

 

[bdgan]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

DeSean Hamilton is the all time receptions leader with 214. To put that in perspective Butler is second with "only" 179. Hamilton is second all time in receiving yards behind only Bobby Engram.

I think Hamilton is rated too low here. I also think he'll be difficult to replace this season.

 

[danvillenit]

Replace one Butler with Kenny Jackson and replace Juwan with any of the honorable mentions and you have a good list

 

[fastlax16]

You do know that you listed Butler twice, right? If he's worth both 4th and 6th place, he should be even higher on your list.

It's a De(i)on thing. Like Deion Sanders and Leon Sandcastle.

 

[Howie'81]

Not in any order, but I have 11:

Bobby Engram
Allen Robinson
Deion Butler
DeSean Hamilton
Kenny Jackson
OJ McDuffie
Jimmy Cefalo
Chafie Fields
Greg Garrity
Joe Jurevicious
Chris Godwin

 

[Howie'81]

No Kenny Jackson?
It’s tough to rate receivers for me. A receiver is only as good as the guy throwing the ball to him. With that said, Robinson may belong at the top of that list. McDuffie is as good as I’ve ever seen at Penn State.

Jackson made my list (scroll up).

 

[PSU95alum]

This is why Deon Butler made the list twice.

 

[BBrown]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

I would move Hamilton up much higher, especially over Bryant Johnson at least career wise. And while I love the potential of Juwan he hasn't done enough yet to merit the 10 spot.
I would have ranked Kenny Jackson above Butler.

 

[brupsu]

David Daniels Michael Timpson and Scott Fitzke

 

[NelsonMunce]

David Daniels Michael Timpson and Scott Fitzke

I liked Dave Daniels a lot.

 

[psuken]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

No Kenny Jackson or Jimmy Cefalo?

 

[roswelllion]

Hamilton at 4
K Jackson at 5
Godwin . goes to 7
Cefalo at 8
Bryant J goes to 9
Curry at 10

Take out Joe J and Juwan J

 

[BBrown]

David Daniels Michael Timpson and Scott Fitzke

Good call on Fitzke.

 

[john4psu]

1. Engram - Biletnikoff Award winner
2. Jackson - 2-time All-American
3. Robinson - perhaps higher had he stayed another year

Others may have better statistics, but none were as nationally recognized against their peers as those three.

 

[LoyalandTrueLion]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

Is this April 1st?

 

[LoyalandTrueLion]

DeSean Hamilton is the all time receptions leader with 214. To put that in perspective Butler is second with "only" 179. Hamilton is second all time in receiving yards behind only Bobby Engram.

I think Hamilton is rated too low here. I also think he'll be difficult to replace this season.

Style of offense matters. 4 year career and the game has changed. Evan Royster is top 5 back? Yea nope

 

[Wesauking Lion]

Mo Hump is not on the list but he is definitely on the plane..

 

[Cold Smoke]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

Ted Kwalick

 

[psuro]

Ted Kwalick

Not a Receiver.

 

[psuno1]

Pretty good list, you got No 1 correct, might want to add kenny jackson and cefalo, b johnson and make it a top 13- m timpson, t smith and d daniels were pretty good as well.

 

[grinagrin]

Justin Brown

 

[NittanyPirate]

Curry has to be on the top 10 list. His stats compare favorably with many of our recent WR stars despite the evolution of the game.

 

[grinagrin]

Julian Fleming

 

[4IUSox2]

No Kenny Jackson or Jimmy Ceffalo and Jurevicius only 8th?? Wow!!

 

[CLWBT]

Have to agree that Kenny Jackson is a serious oversight. A 2-time All American belongs in the top 5.

An old school end who should get an honorable mention is Jack Curry. Greg Garrity is a sentimental favorite for his catch vs. Georgia. Make him an HM as well.

Agree

Curry has to be on the top 10 list. His stats compare favorably with many of our recent WR stars despite the evolution of the game.

Agree that my H.S. friend and teammate deserves be on the list. RIP Jack Curry.

 

[fairfaxlion2]

No Kinta Palmer or Knowledge Timmons?

 

[CJF_Said_The_Great_Joe_Paterno]

1. Bobby Engram ('93-'95)
2. Allen Robinson ('11-'13)
3. O.J. McDuffie ('91-'92)
4. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
5. Chris Godwin ('14-'16)
6. Deon Butler ('05-'08)
7. Bryant Johnson ('99-'02)
8. Joe Jurevicius ('94-'97)
9. DeaSean Hamilton ('14-'17)
10. Juwan Johnson ('16- )

Honorable Mention:
Derrick Williams ('05-08)
Jordan Norwood ('05-08)
Chafie Fields ('96-'99)
Freddie Scott ('93-'95)

Agree or Disagree?

No Kenny Jackson? Really? Absolutely disagree.