Yep. JVP was so pissed after the 1973 team got no national love (12-0, #5 rank), that he said he had taken his own poll... the Paterno Poll... and PSU was voted #1. I think the team got rings.
The New York Times poll in 1994 had us at #1, and we had that painted onto the back of the south end scoreboard for a season or two. The NCAA said no go for some reason and we took it off. Imo, we should have said too bad, and kept declaring 1994 at least as co-champs, and then same with 1973, 1969, 1968. In my feeble mind, I will always consider both 1969 and 1994 as co-NC seasons for us. My vote counts!
No playoff? Can't really say who 'won' the NC back then. I would have liked our chances in 1977 with 1 loss, and in the 2 loss seasons of 1981 and 1991, we would have been a very tough team to beat. Throw 1971 in there, even with the last game loss at Tennessee. Give Joe a month to prepare, and PSU was a tough team to beat far more often than not.