He won't get a bye. The top 3 seeds will almost certainly be 1 Ayala (undefeated in conference), 2 Byrd (only loss to Ayala), 3 Brown (only loss to Byrd). Guessing Van Dee gets the 4, Davis gets the 5 on the basis of their H2H, plus Davis having beaten Shawver and Bouzakis.
Even if he did, I'm not sure that's actually better. It's a tradeoff -- he'd lose RPI 10 pts to everyone, but it would only matter for a few. But if he finishes 3rd, then he loses Conference Finish 10 pts to a few guys he might otherwise be seeded ahead of.
Or Davis could just forfeit the opener and go straight to consis ... wait a minute, his dad isn't the head coach. Never mind.