ADVERTISEMENT

Attending a Univ Research Conf - PSU one of the presenters

I strongly suspect that whatever the “books” say, the costs of Penn State’s continued maintenance and operation of nearly 20 branch campuses, and all of their requisite chancellors, administrations, physical plants, etc. are a major, major, major money loser.

Edit: that’s on top of the operation of two separate law schools and the other “special mission” campuses - I suspect that the med school makes money given the biomed research dollars that it brings in, but I don’t know enough about Penn Tech in Williamsport or the grad school in the Philly area to say. I can say with a relatively high degree of confidence that the two law schools are likely not profitable.

Which leads to an interesting (at least I think so) question: do unabsorbed costs of one division leak into others e.g. is undergrad tuition at, say, University Park subsidizing Dickinson Law? I'd like to say "no" but I couldn't with any degree of confidence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 91Joe95
Which leads to an interesting (at least I think so) question: do unabsorbed costs of one division leak into others e.g. is undergrad tuition at, say, University Park subsidizing Dickinson Law? I'd like to say "no" but I couldn't with any degree of confidence.
I don’t know the answer to that; what I do know is that Dickinson’s (Carlisle) latest disclosures indicate that more than 70% of its ~200 total students have either full tuition scholarships or a full tuition scholarship with an additional stipend, and the University Park campus’ numbers are similar. Someone is making up that difference, and unless they’ve gotten several donations in the 8 figures in the recent past that haven’t been publicized, the university is eating the costs. Where the books are balanced from there is anyone’s guess.
 
I don’t know the answer to that; what I do know is that Dickinson’s (Carlisle) latest disclosures indicate that more than 70% of its ~200 total students have either full tuition scholarships or a full tuition scholarship with an additional stipend, and the University Park campus’ numbers are similar. Someone is making up that difference, and unless they’ve gotten several donations in the 8 figures in the recent past that haven’t been publicized, the university is eating the costs. Where the books are balanced from there is anyone’s guess.

That is unusually high (to say the least) for a professional school. Any idea why?
 
That is unusually high (to say the least) for a professional school. Any idea why?
Unusually high is an understatement. Amongst relative peer schools in-state, the percentage of students receiving half-tuition scholarships or larger is: 58% at Villanova, 39% at Pitt, 49% at Temple, and then 86% at PSU-UP and 91% at Dickinson. It’s staggering.

Couldn’t tell you, but a few guesses: the purchase, combined, and separated campuses of the law schools have led them to believe that they need to “establish” themselves by giving heavy incentives for students to attend, especially since the alumni relationships were so fractured by Spanier during the purchase of Dickinson saga; Penn State and Dickinson’s locations are less than enviable for law students, where there’s an advantage in being within commuting distance from state and federal courts and law firms for internship and job opportunities both during the school year and in the summers; and an overall slackened applicant pool that never really recovered post-recession.

My personal guess, though, is that it’s a rankings related numbers game - the US News law school rankings take into account the overall student aid pools and the overall resources a law school has at its disposal via tuition revenues. This incentivizes schools to enter into a game where they set “tuition” at a shockingly high amount, but then give “scholarships” to almost every student in order to double-dip the rankings metrics by both having high resources and a high student aid pool. In Penn State’s case, out-of-State tuition is more than $50,000, far higher than its peer schools, and doesn’t give a set in-state tuition discount unlike its state-related peers, but instead gives an automatic $20,000 “scholarship” to every Pennsylvania student.
 
Unusually high is an understatement. Amongst relative peer schools in-state, the percentage of students receiving half-tuition scholarships or larger is: 58% at Villanova, 39% at Pitt, 49% at Temple, and then 86% at PSU-UP and 91% at Dickinson. It’s staggering.

Couldn’t tell you, but a few guesses: the purchase, combined, and separated campuses of the law schools have led them to believe that they need to “establish” themselves by giving heavy incentives for students to attend, especially since the alumni relationships were so fractured by Spanier during the purchase of Dickinson saga; Penn State and Dickinson’s locations are less than enviable for law students, where there’s an advantage in being within commuting distance from state and federal courts and law firms for internship and job opportunities both during the school year and in the summers; and an overall slackened applicant pool that never really recovered post-recession.

My personal guess, though, is that it’s a rankings related numbers game - the US News law school rankings take into account the overall student aid pools and the overall resources a law school has at its disposal via tuition. This incentivizes schools to enter into a game where they set “tuition” at a shockingly high amount, but then give “scholarships” to almost every student in order to double-dip the rankings metrics by both having high resources and a high student aid pool. In Penn State’s case, out-of-State tuition is more than $50,000, far higher than its peer schools, and doesn’t give a set in-state tuition discount unlike its state-related peers, but instead gives an automatic $20,000 “scholarship” to every Pennsylvania student.

In short, the schools are so bad they have to pay the students to attend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 91Joe95
In short, the schools are so bad they have to pay the students to attend.
My guess is it’s more a situation of “pay the students to attend for as long as it takes to boost our rankings high enough that we don’t need to pay them as much anymore.” Whether that strategy pans out is anyone’s guess, but Dickinson in particular certainly presents a fantastic value while the gettin’ is hot if you don’t mind a career practicing law in the Harrisburg area.
 
NSF. Numbers are for 2017, most recent published. For that five year period, OSU's research went from $793mm to $864mm. PSU's from $837mm to $859mm.

Check your NSF HERD numbers again. DoD funding to PSU was $213mm in 2017. No where near 51%.
 
Check your NSF HERD numbers again. DoD funding to PSU was $213mm in 2017. No where near 51%.

My mistake, 38%. Just like OSU's total research has gone down over the last reported five years. Oh, wait, that wasn't my mistake.
 
Take a tour of the Millennial Science Complex sometime. $265 million just for the building. Underground vibration proof labs that facilitate internationally recognized research. It would make any rational alum proud. Offering graduate students projects that advance their exposure to industry and the scientific world in general. This basic research offers baseline commercial opportunities for industry, potentially makes out country safer from our adversaries. Endless positives. Basically the definition of a leading research university’s mission. And yet, we here from a nothing like Norm about the evils of investment. Bear in mind he has never been in a position of leadership. With his personality, leading his neighborhood watch group would be out of his reach.

All organizations can improve. Penn State is doing amazing things everyday!
I have toured it extensively. Both while under construction and after it has been up and running. On my second tour (when it was fully operational) I was concerned about the number of Chinese nationals who had access to this technology that makes us "safer from our adversaries".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ski and 91Joe95
Wow. Hitting a nerve with the cabal of PSU negativity! Time for some more positives.

PSU’s industry extremely friendly intellectual property policy. Super smart and very well received. Try working out a license agreement with MIT.

The establishment of centers of excellence. For example, faculty report to a college and can also work for a center of excellence. This cross functional approach is very appealing to industry. When you have a project, typically it touches multiple disciplines. Penn State’a unique approach matches the process. Smart!!

Hiding under a skirt? Former C Level in the Consumer Health industry here. Dealt with lower level types like Norm (without the obvious narcissistic complex) my entire career. No great organization or business saves itself to greatness.
It takes vision and sound decision making. No fist pounding myopic bean counter like Norm ever benefited an organization.

But, to the point. So many positives and proud of Penn State.

This guy's gold. He gives Bushwood a run for his money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stormingnorm
More great news about Penn State:

IBM donates super computer system to Penn State’s CyperSience Institute. Facilitating advanced research in Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning. Right in PSU’s research wheelhouse. Again, The CSI is a multi-disciplinary approach that industry loves!

PSU team places second in Nasa’s 3-D printing Mars Habitat competition to the tune of $200,000. What cool stuff. Great faculty, impressive students. Main campus 3D printing facilities are so impressive. Alloys, metals. Precision parts for jet fighters, submarines, and medical device applications (great synergy with Hershey).

Great facilities, faculty and leadership. All from the culture effective leadership creates!

Penn State Proud!
 
More great news about Penn State:

IBM donates super computer system to Penn State’s CyperSience Institute. Facilitating advanced research in Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning. Right in PSU’s research wheelhouse. Again, The CSI is a multi-disciplinary approach that industry loves!

PSU team places second in Nasa’s 3-D printing Mars Habitat competition to the tune of $200,000. What cool stuff. Great faculty, impressive students. Main campus 3D printing facilities are so impressive. Alloys, metals. Precision parts for jet fighters, submarines, and medical device applications (great synergy with Hershey).

Great facilities, faculty and leadership. All from the culture effective leadership creates!

Penn State Proud!

We Are!...Awful!
 
More great news about Penn State:
..................................
Great facilities, faculty and leadership. All from the culture effective leadership creates!
Penn State Proud!

I realize the leadership of this University is not as bad as many here (including myself) portray it to be, but to suggest it is great borders on the absurd. At best it is average. Penn State is a good University, not great, and its status in the academic community is trending downward, albeit slowly. That trend could be reversed by "great" or even "good" leadership, but at Penn State such leadership is sadly lacking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 91Joe95
More great news about Penn State:

IBM donates super computer system to Penn State’s CyperSience Institute. Facilitating advanced research in Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning. Right in PSU’s research wheelhouse. Again, The CSI is a multi-disciplinary approach that industry loves!

PSU team places second in Nasa’s 3-D printing Mars Habitat competition to the tune of $200,000. What cool stuff. Great faculty, impressive students. Main campus 3D printing facilities are so impressive. Alloys, metals. Precision parts for jet fighters, submarines, and medical device applications (great synergy with Hershey).

Great facilities, faculty and leadership. All from the culture effective leadership creates!

Penn State Proud!

IBM donated an AC922 server to PSU. Nice piece of hardware, but not a supercomputer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 91Joe95
A system based on the Summit and Sierra Super Computers old timer Art. Super Computer architecture. Right? Make sense? Get it? Machine learning? AI ? Nice piece of machinery? You must be over 80.
 
A system based on the Summit and Sierra Super Computers old timer Art. Super Computer architecture. Right? Make sense? Get it? Machine learning? AI ? Nice piece of machinery? You must be over 80.

You're putting the architecture of a commodity AC922 in the same league as Summit and Sierra? I don't need a case; you've made it.
 
So proud?

Yet so anonymous?

I wonder why?

LOL.


The fact that your “pride” is highlighted by your excitation at how much was spent - rather than how much was achieved - is kinda’ telling :)

Almost as if, for you, the accomplishment WAS spending as much as possible.

The fact that you continue to be utterly unable to differentiate between opposing “fraud” and “waste”, as opposed to “investment” is another.

Funny that, eh?



So.... Mr/Mrs/? Featho...... you gonna’ come out from behind your Momma’s skirt?
Or are you gonna’ live the rest of your life as some anonymous scrotum licker?

Man, bitchy much? Why do you even talk PSU anything? Maybe rename the board to something non-PSU since you're so anti. Good grief. It's pretty damn sad.
 
Penn State continues to knock it out the park. Helping to build a much needed and improved eco system for startups in this economically declining state. $750,000 for deep learning? Continue to be PSU proud. So many great things happening. This is just from my LinkedIn news feed.

https://www.pennlive.com/opinion/20...nomic-green-shoots-emerge.html?outputType=amp

https://news.psu.edu/story/573460/2019/05/07/research/penn-state-google-ai-impact-grantee?utm_source=newswire&utm_medium=email&utm_term=573787_HTML&utm_content=05-08-2019-22-22&utm_campaign=Penn State Today

How much of the improved ecosystem is barren directly responsible for?

:eek:
 
Penn State continues to knock it out the park. Helping to build a much needed and improved eco system for startups in this economically declining state. $750,000 for deep learning? Continue to be PSU proud. So many great things happening. This is just from my LinkedIn news feed.

https://www.pennlive.com/opinion/20...nomic-green-shoots-emerge.html?outputType=amp

https://news.psu.edu/story/573460/2019/05/07/research/penn-state-google-ai-impact-grantee?utm_source=newswire&utm_medium=email&utm_term=573787_HTML&utm_content=05-08-2019-22-22&utm_campaign=Penn State Today

So, by my rough calculations, that $70MM+ for the museum could fund more than 70 of those world beating projects. Which to choose, which to choose...
 
Barron is leading the Invent Penn State initiative. Some great hires from the private sector. Attracting Venture Capital is key here, and is happening. If you are a qualified investor check on the 1855 fund. Some great startup opportunities. This doesn’t happen by accident. Providing administrative support, legal advice, etc to students, alums, and folks off the street. Pennsylvania is a mess. The only hope is attracting intellectual capital. Perfectly fits the land grant mission. Hence the $1 million PNC investment. You guys really don’t have a clue!
 
So, by my rough calculations, that $70MM+ for the museum could fund more than 70 of those world beating projects. Which to choose, which to choose...

Bear in mind that $85 MM is the cost now. With a bit of elbow grease (or maybe not for the elbow :eek: ), I'm sure barren will come up with a revised proposal that costs more (which will of course be approved by the bot).

:eek:
 
Penn State continues to knock it out the park. Helping to build a much needed and improved eco system for startups in this economically declining state. $750,000 for deep learning? Continue to be PSU proud. So many great things happening. This is just from my LinkedIn news feed.

https://www.pennlive.com/opinion/20...nomic-green-shoots-emerge.html?outputType=amp

https://news.psu.edu/story/573460/2019/05/07/research/penn-state-google-ai-impact-grantee?utm_source=newswire&utm_medium=email&utm_term=573787_HTML&utm_content=05-08-2019-22-22&utm_campaign=Penn State Today

Barron is leading the Invent Penn State initiative. Some great hires from the private sector. Attracting Venture Capital is key here, and is happening. If you are a qualified investor check on the 1855 fund. Some great startup opportunities. This doesn’t happen by accident. Providing administrative support, legal advice, etc to students, alums, and folks off the street. Pennsylvania is a mess. The only hope is attracting intellectual capital. Perfectly fits the land grant mission. Hence the $1 million PNC investment. You guys really don’t have a clue!

You're Morning Sermonette brought to you by Larry the FISH.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 91Joe95
Norm. You have some real mental health issues. I suspect is stems from a complete lack of friends, running a marginal business at best, and the knowledge that aside from a free football message board forum no one cares what you say. Most importantly, you are a despicable human being. Please seek help!
 
Barron is leading the Invent Penn State initiative. Some great hires from the private sector. Attracting Venture Capital is key here, and is happening. If you are a qualified investor check on the 1855 fund. Some great startup opportunities. This doesn’t happen by accident. Providing administrative support, legal advice, etc to students, alums, and folks off the street. Pennsylvania is a mess. The only hope is attracting intellectual capital. Perfectly fits the land grant mission. Hence the $1 million PNC investment. You guys really don’t have a clue!

Yes, you have made the point quite convincingly that intellectual capital is clearly needed badly. Let's build yet another building that produces nothing while claiming funds are badly needed. All is well.
 
I have toured it extensively. Both while under construction and after it has been up and running. On my second tour (when it was fully operational) I was concerned about the number of Chinese nationals who had access to this technology that makes us "safer from our adversaries".

They are stealing there as well. Chinese theft of intellectual property is likely to be the biggest property theft in the history of man.
And of course, universities aid and abet the theft.
 
That's nice, but I'll kindly wait for feato to finish up his work day and provide a more credible response. You understand of course.

Is feato related to feetsie? Might explain a lotta things.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT