There are multiple DiCarlo's in the Ohio Valley. The WSJ ran an article on Ohio Valley Pizza and DiCarlo's was the most mentioned. Here is another article on the topic.Are you familiar with/like DiCarlo's Pizza also in Washington, PA.
I previously had access to some prime deer hunting land in that area and we would always stop there for a pizza. It was very good.
This was close to 20 years ago.
Vincents Pizza on Ardmore Blvd. Home of the original 'Vinnie Pie': <<<link shows a pic of a vintage 'Vinnie' with his 5 lb. pizza pie!
This is obviously not the type of Pizza that Portnoy would review, it is a very good and unique pizza from my youth.
On the to go orders, they used to place your pie on a heavy piece of carboard and wrap it with old newspapers and tape it up.
VERY generous with the toppings....
Ohio Valley Pizza
