I’ll just say that promoting state college as an end all be all for wrestling all while landing all the top studs over and over is a bit of a self fulfilling prophecy. Cael is a difference maker in folkstyle and has absolutely dominated the last 15 years, but most of the senior level success can be tied to elite recruiting. Most of his greatest folkstyle coaching jobs aren’t big senior level studs. The bonafide studs like DT are.
Snyder was just fine going to Ohio St. Lee was fine going to Iowa. Gable was just fine at Minny. Could they have experienced more team success at PSU??? Absolutely, but the other side of the coin is that If Iowa or Ohio St had been able to recruit more top tier guys like Spencer and Snyder then they may have won more.
If Blaze, Jax, Bo, Dee etc were all to sign with the Pokes…. You’d see some real parity and senior level success outside of State College, real fast.
Oh man, so much to respond to. First, senior level successes. Yes, Snyder did well while training at Ohio State but long before he became a member of the NLWC he would show up at PSU and train for multiple weeks at a time.
The NLWC did dominate the Olympic Trials and a few of their successful wrestlers were recruited to Penn State from other schools. Namely Snyder, Dake and Gilman. However, PSU had 5 of 12 wrestlers wrestling in the best of 3 finals. Success is the number 1 recruiting tool Penn State has, at the senior level as well as at the college level.
As far as the college program, very elite kids have gone to other schools not named Penn State.
Just a few comparisons:
Cenzo choose to go to Penn State and Marinelli went to Iowa. One wrestled in 3 finals (in 3 opportunities, winning 2) and one wrestled in one semi-final.
Megaloudis wrestled at PSU and Gilman wrestled at Iowa. One won a title, the other did not.
Nolf went to PSU and won 3 titles with 4 finals appearances while Kemerer wrestled at Iowa and had a single runner-up and Smith wrestled for his dad and never wrestled in a championship final.
More currently Levi has a championship and 2 finals appearances. Shapiro has a quarter-final loss and 3rd place finish.
It isn't just Penn State getting all of the best recruits. It is Penn State's best recruits out perform other recruits. Again, success is the number one recruiting tool Penn State has.
Remembering tOSU has won multiple recruiting titles and PSU just continues to plow the Bucks under I would be very comfortable making this guess: if Blaze, Jax, Bo and Dee all sign with and wrestle for the Pokes a corresponding collective from Penn State will out perform that impressive Cowboy grouping at the college level and the senior level.