ADVERTISEMENT

McDevitt WR verbals to Alabama

What was the PSU interest in him?

Offer, but not sure where he was on our board. I played football in the backyard with his dad Marky when we were kids. His dad was 3 years younger I think and very fast for the neighborhood. His dad did not have D1 size or skills.

Hard to evaluate his son because Mcdevitt literally plays only teams that they beat 60+ to 0. But I've seen the son play and he does have decent size, speed, and athleticism. Just wonder what he and teammates would do playing in the appropriate division against actual competition.
 
Good luck to him at Bama. Can't argue with a player that wants to go the the best roster in college football and compete.

But from the talk and articles on the 2024 class it didn't seem that Franklin and Hagans had Scott in their top 4 WR targets. Anyone believe that or otherwise?
 
Offer, but not sure where he was on our board. I played football in the backyard with his dad Marky when we were kids. His dad was 3 years younger I think and very fast for the neighborhood. His dad did not have D1 size or skills.

Hard to evaluate his son because Mcdevitt literally plays only teams that they beat 60+ to 0. But I've seen the son play and he does have decent size, speed, and athleticism. Just wonder what he and teammates would do playing in the appropriate division against actual competition.
if a player from McDevitt isn't on our board, but Alabama wants them, we are not good at this
 
if a player from McDevitt isn't on our board, but Alabama wants them, we are not good at this
Lots of highly rated players flame out at Alabama. Don't kid yourself. Many make it to the NFL but that is because they've pulled the top recruiting classes for over a decade.

I trust Franklin here and further, I wouldn't recruit any McDevitt players to PSU until they start to play real competition. How can you evaluate players that go against teams that have maybe 1 or 2 players that would be on their 2 deep and none that would start?
 
I’d say it’s 50/50 his offer is still committable by signing day unless this kid is insanely underrated and blows up between now and then. If that’s the case, huge miss by Franklin.
 
if a player from McDevitt isn't on our board, but Alabama wants them, we are not good at this
100%. In an era where detailed information and game film on prospects from across the country is readily available, identifying a prospect that is being recruited by other major P5 schools is the recruiting equivalent of tying your shoes. I suspect the kid just wasn't interested - it happens.
 
Let’s remember that Alabama pulled Robert foster about 10 years ago and he only had 35 catches during his time there. He got hurt early and then he fell down the depth chart. He was a much higher blue chip too. I hope this kid knows what he’s signing up for.
 
100%. In an era where detailed information and game film on prospects from across the country is readily available, identifying a prospect that is being recruited by other major P5 schools is the recruiting equivalent of tying your shoes. I suspect the kid just wasn't interested - it happens.
I'm confused. You agree with the guy that said we're aren't good at recruiting, BUT, you suspect that said recruit just wasn't interested in PSU. Do we suck or not?
 
I'm confused. You agree with the guy that said we're aren't good at recruiting, BUT, you suspect that said recruit just wasn't interested in PSU. Do we suck or not?
It takes two interested parties to make a deal. If the kid had his heart set on Bama....
 
There hasn't been much buzz about him on free boards. That of corse means very little. If AL gave him the green light, I have to assume that PSU would as well.
 
I'm confused. You agree with the guy that said we're aren't good at recruiting, BUT, you suspect that said recruit just wasn't interested in PSU. Do we suck or not?
That's not how I read his post. He didn't say that we weren't good at recruiting, only that if we didn't have a guy in PA good enough to get an offer from 'Bama on our board (he was, and we offered), then we weren't good at it. Since that clearly wasn't true, neither of us was saying we "suck" at recruiting. Identifying talent worthy of recruiting when you're not in finding diamonds in the rough mode is not difficult. My final comment is my SWAG that the kid wasn't that interested in PSU or had others, Alabama in particular, higher on his list. That's based, in part, on personally knowing two kids from my hometown who were excellent prospects that had limited or no interest in PSU.
 
Last edited:
Lots of highly rated players flame out at Alabama. Don't kid yourself. Many make it to the NFL but that is because they've pulled the top recruiting classes for over a decade.

I trust Franklin here and further, I wouldn't recruit any McDevitt players to PSU until they start to play real competition. How can you evaluate players that go against teams that have maybe 1 or 2 players that would be on their 2 deep and none that would start?
why in the world would we stop recruiting McDevitt? It is historically one of the better programs in the state, it is in Harrisburg, and multiple NFL players have come out of there. not recruiting there would be one of the dumbest possible things penn state could do
 
  • Like
Reactions: lilromeo
why in the world would we stop recruiting McDevitt? It is historically one of the better programs in the state, it is in Harrisburg, and multiple NFL players have come out of there. not recruiting there would be one of the dumbest possible things penn state could do
Who is the last NFL player? Ricky waters?
 
Top players produce nothing at all schools because it comes down to the kid committing to improve after years of it usually being easy for them. Great programs recruit all schools
 
100%. In an era where detailed information and game film on prospects from across the country is readily available, identifying a prospect that is being recruited by other major P5 schools is the recruiting equivalent of tying your shoes. I suspect the kid just wasn't interested - it happens.
Maybe he was very interested but ranked #5-6 on the “take” chart or concerned about WR depth and his role at PSU? Quite possibly he didn’t have a green light to verbal. Sounds like he was pretty interested. I’m sure that JF saw him enough to have him properly ranked on the recruiting depth chart. Seems like he was pretty interested in PSU.

 
Last edited:
Losing a WR to Bama isn't the end all be all.

I have zero idea where he ranks on our list of WRs, but there's no shame in him picking Bama over us, other than it sucks to lose a Pennsylvania kid.
 
Maybe he was very interested but ranked #5-6 on the “take” chart or concerned about WR depth and his role at PSU? Quite possibly he didn’t have a green light to verbal. Sounds like he was pretty interested. I’m sure that JF saw him enough to have him properly ranked on the recruiting depth chart. Seems like he was pretty interested in PSU.

To be clear, you're trying to say that a kid Bama accepted a commitment from didn't have a commitable offer from Penn State? He was also more concerned about our depth at WR than Bama's? Making sure I'm reading this right
 
Losing a WR to Bama isn't the end all be all.

I have zero idea where he ranks on our list of WRs, but there's no shame in him picking Bama over us, other than it sucks to lose a Pennsylvania kid.
i think the concern isn't that he picked Alabama, it is that it's not so clear that Penn State was trying really hard to recruit a player in Harrisburg who is good enough to play for Alabama
 
  • Like
Reactions: lazydave841
i think the concern isn't that he picked Alabama, it is that it's not so clear that Penn State was trying really hard to recruit a player in Harrisburg who is good enough to play for Alabama

I get that.

I'd be interesting in seeing the teams list. I'm sure it's paywall info. 2 top 200 WRs in the state and we don't have a verbal from either. And missed on one last year. I'm sure this is why Hagens is here now, but one has to wonder how quickly we can expect to him to sway some highly rated WRs.
 
I view it the same way as Scott. How do you know if he's a good QB when he throws to WRs that are open by 10 yards and he has 10 seconds in a clean pocket to do it?

I also liken it to the kid who played QB for Kansas State this year in the CCG and bowl. PA kid with no offer and some were like "why didn't we offer him?" And it's like, he was a 2*/3* kid that if we took him this place would be nuclear.
 
I also liken it to the kid who played QB for Kansas State this year in the CCG and bowl. PA kid with no offer and some were like "why didn't we offer him?" And it's like, he was a 2*/3* kid that if we took him this place would be nuclear.
Stone has offers, just not PSU. I don't think PSU is interested. Other schools that don't know McDevitt is playing 2 classes below where they should have offered.
 
i think the concern isn't that he picked Alabama, it is that it's not so clear that Penn State was trying really hard to recruit a player in Harrisburg who is good enough to play for Alabama
I get your point. But so far we only know that he was good enough to be recruited by Alabama.

He may never play a down there.

Bama could drop him like hot potatoe if they find someone they like better between now an signing day.
 
I get your point. But so far we only know that he was good enough to be recruited by Alabama.

He may never play a down there.

Bama could drop him like hot potatoe if they find someone they like better between now an signing day.
Yeah Bama WR recruiting is insane. Surprised they took him.
 
To be clear, you're trying to say that a kid Bama accepted a commitment from didn't have a commitable offer from Penn State? He was also more concerned about our depth at WR than Bama's? Making sure I'm reading this right
And maybe Alabama could be wrong and Penn State right about Scott.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregInPitt
Yep and the pitters will be bragging if there is no room for Lindsey the LB from Alliquippa, when the reality may be that PSU was waiting for LB's higher on Diaz' LB board. Can't believe everything that's written.
 
Yep and the pitters will be bragging if there is no room for Lindsey the LB from Alliquippa, when the reality may be that PSU was waiting for LB's higher on Diaz' LB board. Can't believe everything that's written.
That is exactly correct. Lindsey is good but we like about 6 or 7 better including the 2 committed already to us. Narduzzi would love to get anything decent in the WPIAL. PSU, OSU, UM, ND, and The SEC have 1st shots at the top 10 or so PA players. Pitt gets what they don't want.

After LOI day is over, Narduzzi rings the dinner bell......and its leftovers again.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT