OT: Looking for recommendations for a good bottle of Scotch...

[Nittany Ziggy]

A contractor friend gave me a bottle three Christmas's past. I enjoyed the nectar. About $100 a bottle.

Glenmorangie Lasanta, The Sherry Cask Finish, 12 Years Old
$64.00 is a favorite of mine.

Glenfiddich 18 Bottling Note
This 18 year old from Glenfiddich's core range was matured in a mix of Oloroso sherry and bourbon casks.

Tasting Note by The Chaps at Master of Malt (REVIEW)
Nose: Loads of fruit. Zesty grapefruit, baked toffee apples. Dry, chocolate Flake-y wood and cinnamon.

Palate: Candied fruits and Glenfiddich freshness balances richer notes of dried apricot, more cinnamon and toffee, ginger and dry Sherry.

Finish: Peels and a touch of salted toffee.

This just sounds fishy. Either he is a friend of "Paps" or he was showing gratitude for a time when Step let a lean batch of concrete onto a job site! BWWWWWAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA,,!!!

 

[step.eng69]

This just sounds fishy. Either he is a friend of "Paps" or he was showing gratitude for a time when Step let a lean batch of concrete onto a job site! BWWWWWAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA,,!!!

Ziggy, Ziggy, Ziggy....the contractor was an old friend of Pop's close friend, Howard, whose company I worked in since 1984 (a small business engineering firm by Philly). Actually you have my e-mail address, so you can track down the firm. Any way Howard pass two years ago. I often did minor structural work for the contractor as a favor to Howard, and the fellow gave me a bottle, $hit, he brought a full case to our office. Last year he cut back to Macallan 12 yr, I was disappointed.

By the way, did you know I was union member of the Operating Engineers Local 542 since 1978, out of Philly and also a member of the Philly United Brotherhood of Carpenters, Local 1595 since 1987. I often wonder if I'm the only Professional engineer in the state that belonged to construction unions.

 

[Diego Badman]

to give as a gift.

We want to give this to the chair of a committee I have been involved with.

Looking for something in the $90-$120 range, and by keeping it in that range, it makes it equitable for those who are contributing. It has to be scotch as he is a scotch drinker - no wine, no beer, no vodka, etc.

Thanks in advance.

I like two:

Glenlivet 12
Oban 14

Where I live, the Glenlivet is about $45-$50 per bottle, while the Oban is $80-$85 per bottle.

 

[We Are . . .]

Something from Ardbeg or Laphroaig

I've developed a taste for the peated malts and these two are very good choices. Best description of Laphroaig 10: "Like kissing a mermaid that just ate barbecue for dinner." Ardbeg is also good. My son and I just tried Laphroaig Quarter Cask. It's not for the faint hearted. I love it.

I like two:

Glenlivet 12
Oban 14

Where I live, the Glenlivet is about $45-$50 per bottle, while the Oban is $80-$85 per bottle.

Visited the Oban distillery a few years ago. It's a very good Highland malt from the west coast of Scotland. We still have a bottle tucked away for special occasions. We've also grown fond of Highland Park (Orkneys).

 

[Diego Badman]

I've developed a taste for the peated malts and these two are very good choices. Best description of Laphroaig 10: "Like kissing a mermaid that just ate barbecue for dinner." Ardbeg is also good. My son and I just tried Laphroaig Quarter Cask. It's not for the faint hearted. I love it.



Visited the Oban distillery a few years ago. It's a very good Highland malt from the west coast of Scotland. We still have a bottle tucked away for special occasions. We've also grown fond of Highland Park (Orkneys).

Appropriate Friday afternoon discussion. Just purchased a bottle of Oban.

 

[Indian rocks rich]

to give as a gift.

We want to give this to the chair of a committee I have been involved with.

Looking for something in the $90-$120 range, and by keeping it in that range, it makes it equitable for those who are contributing. It has to be scotch as he is a scotch drinker - no wine, no beer, no vodka, etc.

Thanks in advance.

Can’t go wrong with glenlivet

 

[Indian rocks rich]

A contractor friend gave me a bottle three Christmas's past. I enjoyed the nectar. About $100 a bottle.

Glenmorangie Lasanta, The Sherry Cask Finish, 12 Years Old
$64.00 is a favorite of mine.

Glenfiddich 18 Bottling Note
This 18 year old from Glenfiddich's core range was matured in a mix of Oloroso sherry and bourbon casks.

Tasting Note by The Chaps at Master of Malt (REVIEW)
Nose: Loads of fruit. Zesty grapefruit, baked toffee apples. Dry, chocolate Flake-y wood and cinnamon.

Palate: Candied fruits and Glenfiddich freshness balances richer notes of dried apricot, more cinnamon and toffee, ginger and dry Sherry.

Finish: Peels and a touch of salted toffee.

Step how come no Glenlivet

 

[vader_psu]

Has anyone tried the Costco Kirkland 18 year single malt or the 27 year blended? Thoughts?

 

[anacreon3]

to give as a gift.

We want to give this to the chair of a committee I have been involved with.

Looking for something in the $90-$120 range, and by keeping it in that range, it makes it equitable for those who are contributing. It has to be scotch as he is a scotch drinker - no wine, no beer, no vodka, etc.

Thanks in advance.

I've been enjoying the Balvenie 21 year Finished in PortWood... it might be a bit more than your price range, but I've seen it as low as $150.00.

 

[step.eng69]

Step how come no Glenlivet

I do have a bottle of Glenlivet that I bought a few years ago for my son in laws father who was to visit. They didn't make the trip and I have been sipping since. I basically drink bourbon, but I do Scotch occasionally.

 

[katchthis]

Has anyone tried the Costco Kirkland 18 year single malt or the 27 year blended? Thoughts?

Had one of the Costcos this week at a friends. Didn't check the year. It was okay, kind of like a Johnny Walker Black.

 

[CF LION]

 

[Indian rocks rich]

Thanks

At this point, based on what a few people have said and my own personal experience, I am leaning towards the Balvenie 14.

Glenlivet single malt. Try it. Very good the 12 year is very good you can save money that way

 

[BriarwoodBash]

Glenfiddich 18yr or Macallan 15 yr. are fabulous. If you really want to give him a smooth treat - RedBreast 15 yr. or Middelton. Both Irish whiskies, but much smoother than Scotch.

I agree with most of the comments but would completly 2nd The Good DrJC here. Mac15 is right down the middle and RedBreast is treat.

 

[LionJim]

Had one of the Costcos this week at a friends. Didn't check the year. It was okay, kind of like a Johnny Walker Black.

He was serious? Well, F me.

 

[Nashville Lion]

Thanks. I honestly don't know - but I am sure I can figure out a way to find out.

your photo Ro.....wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[cavs61]

Oban 14, Maccallen 15 ,Dalmore 18 all get my vote . Sitting here getting ready to leave my office and getting VERY THIRSTY.. All within your price range and very enjoyable especially tailgating

 

[Nittany Ziggy]

Ziggy, Ziggy, Ziggy....the contractor was an old friend of Pop's close friend, Howard, whose company I worked in since 1984 (a small business engineering firm by Philly). Actually you have my e-mail address, so you can track down the firm. Any way Howard pass two years ago. I often did minor structural work for the contractor as a favor to Howard, and the fellow gave me a bottle, $hit, he brought a full case to our office. Last year he cut back to Macallan 12 yr, I was disappointed.

By the way, did you know I was union member of the Operating Engineers Local 542 since 1978, out of Philly and also a member of the Philly United Brotherhood of Carpenters, Local 1595 since 1987. I often wonder if I'm the only Professional engineer in the state that belonged to construction unions.

Love it Step! I see below that you prefer bourbon just like me. We need to get together, sample a few and exchange some tales. Will you break your resolution on cigars?

 

[step.eng69]

Step how come no Glenlivet

When I got home I looked to see the age, its a 15 yr. It's hardly been consumed, guess I finished off the bottle I was saving for Randy's dad and bought another. O well, where does time go?

 

[step.eng69]

Love it Step! I see below that you prefer bourbon just like me. We need to get together, sample a few and exchange some tales. Will you break your resolution on cigars?

You & Back Mountain were supposed to meet me at Blehar's parking stall. My sis in law and I waited for a while & no one showed. The weather was bad, cleared to bearable by game time.

 

[vader_psu]

He was serious? Well, F me.

I was just at the Costco in DC a couple of weeks ago and they have liquor and wine for sale. Supposedly the Kirkland liquors are made by well-known brands but they are half the price.

https://www.buzzfeed.com/hannahloewentheil/xx-secrets-for-buying-wine-and-liquor-at-costco

 

[LionJim]

I was just at the Costco in DC

The one off New York Avenue, near the Arboretum?

 

[drunkatmydesk]

Glendronach 18 yo

 

[vader_psu]

The one off New York Avenue, near the Arboretum?

Yes, I believe that's the only one in the area that sells liquor. The stores in VA sell beer and wine.

 

[LionJim]

Yes, I believe that's the only one in the area that sells liquor. The stores in VA sell beer and wine.

Cool. I work a couple miles from there.

 

[Diego Badman]

I like Balvenie. 14 year old is around $70-$80. I think there is a big jump to 17 year or though. Maybe the $130 range.

I’ve never had Balvenie. It’s a peaty Scotch. Correct? If so, I probably wouldn’t like it. I had Laphroig one time. It will be the only time.

 

[katchthis]

He was serious? Well, F me.

The Costco bourbon and vodkas are pretty good ones for mixed drinks.

 

[LionJim]

The Costco bourbon and vodkas are pretty good ones for mixed drinks.

Good to know. Whenever Jane gets Kirkland, it's usually of pretty good quality. Right now I'm trying to think of something that doesn't have a Kirkland brand. Cattle prods? Suppositories?

 

[MICH.Nit Fan]

Thanks. I honestly don't know - but I am sure I can figure out a way to find out.

As others have said, there are many different preferences . I was a liquor salesman for nine years, so I had some exposure to this. One great line that sticks in my mind was from a "sell-sheet", which gave us points to bring up in our sales pitches. "Tastes slightly of burnt rope", was for one of the Scotches. I quite frankly don't remember which one it was, maybe one of the Oban line. It's been too long.

 

[PSUinCAfan]

Johnnie Walker - Black Label (blended)
MacCallen 15 yr (single malt)
Great taste, not overly expensive. Could sip neat every day.
As already posted ...Many others which vary to individuals taste.

 

[Diego Badman]

Johnnie Walker - Black Label (blended)
MacCallen 15 yr (single malt)
Great taste, not overly expensive. Could sip neat every day.
As already posted ...Many others which vary to individuals taste.

Have you tried Johnnie Walker Blue?

 

[MICH.Nit Fan]

Have you tried Johnnie Walker Blue?

Funny thing about Johnnie Blue. I used to sell it, and as a sales staff, all of us liked it, but I'd say that to a man, we liked Gold a little better. And it is way more affordable. Just from my experience. Everyone likes something different.

 

[interrobang]

Johnny Walker Double Black is solid for the price if you want a little smoke in your Black

 

[WestSideLion]

to give as a gift.

We want to give this to the chair of a committee I have been involved with.

Looking for something in the $90-$120 range, and by keeping it in that range, it makes it equitable for those who are contributing. It has to be scotch as he is a scotch drinker - no wine, no beer, no vodka, etc.

Thanks in advance.

Highland Park 18...it’s famtastic and uncommon. If this guy is a scotch drinker, get off the beaten path of most of the suggestions in this thread. The Highland 18 costs around $120-$130. It’s relatively rare and will be appreciated more than the mainstream stuff.

 

[N&B4PSU]

Ardbeg Corryvreckan accompanied me on my cruise thru Scotland et al.

https://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/p/10767/ardbeg-corryvreckan

So my little story...

every decade, almost like a religious pilgrimage, I would open a bottle of Laphraoig... wince, spit, and toss. And go back to my beloved highlands and speysides. Whew!

From the age of 20 til 55 (I cheated a bit)... and then something remarkable happened at 56. I embraced it, loved it, reveled in the fireplace smoke and iodine and peat and sea salt...

And from there... there's been no going back. I can drink the others, but they no longer enthrall me (that said, Talisker 18 still gets me going). It's been a rush from one Islay malt to the next, in search of the perfect dram.

I've had 'em all... but few snuck up on me like this masterful single from Ardbeg. Deeper and more sinewy, lots of smoke and sea and layers of chocolate... there was something bordering of a religious epihany to stand alone on deck late in the night, draped in layer upon layer of clothing to ward off the chill... heaphones on stun (ok, set to "highlander" lol)... staring into the deep sea and sucking down this massive scotch.

thankfully, I poured heavy (brought 2 -- nee 1 -- with me for our 2 week cruise... kindly do not tell me wife or there will surely be a reckoning re the tariff).

I apologize for not reading the thread in its entirety (last i checked, you were uncertain as to the preferred style)... simply providing my own input and advising anyone curious about Islays to take a crack at this honey. Ok, not so much honey.. lol

 

[We Are . . .]

Ardbeg Corryvreckan accompanied me on my cruise thru Scotland et al.

https://www.thewhiskyexchange.com/p/10767/ardbeg-corryvreckan

So my little story...

every decade, almost like a religious pilgrimage, I would open a bottle of Laphraoig... wince, spit, and toss. And go back to my beloved highlands and speysides. Whew!

From the age of 20 til 55 (I cheated a bit)... and then something remarkable happened at 56. I embraced it, loved it, reveled in the fireplace smoke and iodine and peat and sea salt...

And from there... there's been no going back. I can drink the others, but they no longer enthrall me (that said, Talisker 18 still gets me going). It's been a rush from one Islay malt to the next, in search of the perfect dram.

I've had 'em all... but few snuck up on me like this masterful single from Ardbeg. Deeper and more sinewy, lots of smoke and sea and layers of chocolate... there was something bordering of a religious epihany to stand alone on deck late in the night, draped in layer upon layer of clothing to ward off the chill... heaphones on stun (ok, set to "highlander" lol)... staring into the deep sea and sucking down this massive scotch.

thankfully, I poured heavy (brought 2 -- nee 1 -- with me for our 2 week cruise... kindly do not tell me wife or there will surely be a reckoning re the tariff).

I apologize for not reading the thread in its entirety (last i checked, you were uncertain as to the preferred style)... simply providing my own input and advising anyone curious about Islays to take a crack at this honey. Ok, not so much honey.. lol

Beautiful description, Sir. You are a true Scotch lover.

 

[interrobang]

I accidentally found my appreciation for the Islay scotches during the trip to the Croke Park Classic thanks to a brief downpour that forced us into the first bar we came across. There was no turning back at that point.

 

[PSUinCAfan]

Have you tried Johnnie Walker Blue?

Yes I have had Johnnie Walker Blue, and I do not think it is worth the cost. It has a great taste, is smooth and wonderful but not that much more than Black Label.

 

[Diego Badman]

Yes I have had Johnnie Walker Blue, and I do not think it is worth the cost. It has a great taste, is smooth and wonderful but not that much more than Black Label.

I've heard that from many who have tried it. It's good, but it doesn't meet the hype or is worth the price.