ADVERTISEMENT

OT: What is That Delightful Smell?

Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnstownsteel
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
Oh nice...great gift idea. Not to be so bold and straightforward but any chance you could adopt me?

Take your time....
 
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
I prefer Wusthof. I have had both and the quality of Wusthof is far superior to Cutco. They’ll become generational heirlooms.
 
I agree with Hoosier Lion...
Cutco has a great marketing program and decent knives but I think you are paying for marketing..
 
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
From someone that buys lots and lots of steel, US steel is not even close to being the best in the world. That would come from Japan. And coincidentally, they make the best knives too.
I have purchased many knives from Koki.

I recommend this as a starter set:

 
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?

I have Dalstrong. German steel made in China. I try my best to not purchase from China but these came highly recommended and I'm not dissapointed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Agoodnap
From someone that buys lots and lots of steel, US steel is not even close to being the best in the world. That would come from Japan. And coincidentally, they make the best knives too.
I have purchased many knives from Koki.

I recommend this as a starter set:

US steel is not even close to being the best in the world.

blasfemia-blasphemy.gif
 
I have Dalstrong. German steel made in China. I try my best to not purchase from China but these came highly recommended and I'm not dissapointed.
A buddy who owns restaurants gifted me a Dalstrong knife. It's nice but stays in the box. I have been using the same Wusthof knives for 20+ years. BTW Cutco sucks, my wife bought 2 from a cousin a couple of years ago. I'll send them to anyone that wants them.
 
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
I've been super pleased with my newish Misen Knives. Japanese steel, the chef's knife is kinda hybrid between the european and japanese style--crazy sharp, and holds the edge a good long while. And the price is practically shocking for how good they are. You can absolutely find better, but you will pay a great deal more, and unless you're almost pro-level w/ your skills, you probably wouldn't notice.
 
From someone that buys lots and lots of steel, US steel is not even close to being the best in the world. That would come from Japan. And coincidentally, they make the best knives too.
I have purchased many knives from Koki.

I recommend this as a starter set:

Can you sharpen them with iron?
 
I've been super pleased with my newish Misen Knives. Japanese steel, the chef's knife is kinda hybrid between the european and japanese style--crazy sharp, and holds the edge a good long while. And the price is practically shocking for how good they are. You can absolutely find better, but you will pay a great deal more, and unless you're almost pro-level w/ your skills, you probably wouldn't notice.
I like mine also!
 
  • Like
Reactions: nerfstate
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
Cutco used to be pretty good. Recently they've gotten into the cheap market. New West knife works makes some fantastic knives. Been gifted a couple. Awesome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Agoodnap
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
Oklahoma made and Arkansas honed. And honed
 
Cutco used to be pretty good. Recently they've gotten into the cheap market. New West knife works makes some fantastic knives. Been gifted a couple. Awesome.
These look really nice. Here's their website if anyone wants to look.

 
From someone that buys lots and lots of steel, US steel is not even close to being the best in the world. That would come from Japan. And coincidentally, they make the best knives too.
I have purchased many knives from Koki.

I recommend this as a starter set:

I never said us steel is the best, I merely pointed out Cutco is us made with us steel because I like to buy US products if there is an option.

These JCK's you recommend look nice and price is very good. They are now high on my list.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 82bordeaux
I prefer Wusthof. I have had both and the quality of Wusthof is far superior to Cutco. They’ll become generational heirlooms.
These are nice too. I have a friend with a set and I'll borrow a couple to give them a go. Pricing seems reasonable as well.
 
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
I did some custom butchering back in the day. The two brand of knives I used almost exclusively were F. Dick and Forschner. The older gentleman I learned meat cutting from used nothing else. They sharpen fairly easy and they stay sharp longer than most. They are not inexpensive, but they are nowhere near the price of some of the knives on the market today.

That being said, I would recommend you also get them a good steel for touching them up when they start to get dull. Regardless of which knife you choose, it will become dull. At some point the steel will not bring them back sufficiently and they will need resharpened. If they do not have a steel and sharpening system and knowledge in how to use them, in a short time they will have an expensive knife that is dull and unusable and dangerous. It will likely be placed in a knife block and will not be used until some one resharpens it for them. This has been my personal experience. Educate them in not storing them in a silverware drawer(also my personal experience)
 
Well, Christmas is just around the corner and I'm thinking about getting my children some good cutlery. I've been a Cutco guy for a long time and generally think they're great but before I start my kids off I thought I'd ask what you guys would recommend. Cutco is very expensive, but it's made in the US with US steel so that's a serious plus, however the cost makes accumulating a wide variety quite painful. So, what do you guys use and if you had to do it over again what would you choose?
Honestly, they might not turn any heads, but I love my victorinox fibrox 8" chef's knife. I have a pretty nice Miyabi knife, a 6" and 8" Wusthof, and a chef's knife a buddy who's into knife making made for me. Almost every time I reach for the Victorinox. It feels good in the hand, if my hands are wet it doesn't slip, it's light, it holds an edge fairly well, and it's very easy to sharpen. Plus they're cheap enough if someone comes over and wants to help cooking I don't have anxiety about them using that knife. I would get their 8" chef's knife, their boning knife, and their paring knife(although I do prefer my wusthof pairing knife to theirs). That should be enough to take care of 90+% of all cooking needs.
 
I never said us steel is the best, I merely pointed out Cutco is us made with us steel because I like to buy US products if there is an option.

These JCK's you recommend look nice and price is very good. They are now high on my list.
After using these you'll never use anything but Japanese knives.
 
.
I did some custom butchering back in the day. The two brand of knives I used almost exclusively were F. Dick and Forschner. The older gentleman I learned meat cutting from used nothing else. They sharpen fairly easy and they stay sharp longer than most. They are not inexpensive, but they are nowhere near the price of some of the knives on the market today.

That being said, I would recommend you also get them a good steel for touching them up when they start to get dull. Regardless of which knife you choose, it will become dull. At some point the steel will not bring them back sufficiently and they will need resharpened. If they do not have a steel and sharpening system and knowledge in how to use them, in a short time they will have an expensive knife that is dull and unusable and dangerous. It will likely be placed in a knife block and will not be used until some one resharpens it for them. This has been my personal experience. Educate them in not storing them in a silverware drawer(also my personal experience)

Steel sharpens steel?
 
What kind of knife does Willie point at the camera when making carbonara?
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT