https://247sports.com/college/penn-...mpetition-with-Penn-State-football-131188656/
Lions' QB battle lingers as spring camp closes
ByTYLER DONOHUE 3 hours ago
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Penn State concluded a month-long stretch of spring practices Saturday, punctuating the process with its 15th session. The Blue-White Game attracted Nittany Lions fans and recruits from across the country, included
an impressive Beaver Stadium debut for freshman running back Noah Cain, and provided long looks at rising contributors.
It did not, however, feature
Tommy Stevens, the fifth-year senior quarterback long-perceived as heir apparent to
Trace McSorley.
Stevens, who served as Penn State's primary backup QB each of the last three seasons, was in uniform and led Nittany Lions passers through pregame drills.
Considering his "limited" status throughout spring camp after offseason surgery it was no surprise to see him sit out when live action commenced.
It was also no surprise to hear
James Franklin proclaim during a postgame press conference that Penn State is not prepared to name a starter at the position.
"Tommy’s situation – we were put in a tough spot because he had an injury that made it difficult," Franklin said. "We want to be able to name the starter as soon as we possibly can, but we are not ready to do that right now and it’s going to need to be more of a true competition."
Redshirt sophomore
Sean Clifford handled the bulk of first-team reps this spring, and he threw nearly half of the 40 passes attempted Saturday by five different quarterbacks. His afternoon featured 118 yards and one touchdown through the air on 11-of-19 passing, with an additional 31 rushing yards.
He didn't dazzle. He didn't disappoint. He didn't leave Beaver Stadium as Penn State's starting quarterback.
Regardless of how well Clifford performed on Saturday, or throughout the previous 14 spring practice sessions, a question loomed...
Can a QB battle be declared finished before it's fully begun?
From the outside looking in, it's been more of a waiting game than a full-fledged competition as Stevens works to again become a full participant. Franklin's stated desire for "more of a true competition" seems to confirm that sentiment.
Last Wednesday, Clifford called the situation a "day-to-day process" that requires plenty of work away from the field. He also pointed to Stevens as a positional spearhead.
“Tommy does a great job of keeping everybody’s standard high," Clifford said. "That’s one of his strengths — bringing everyone up to his level. So when I throw an incompletion or I make a wrong read, obviously he’s not yelling at me but he’s coaching me up on what I can do better on the next play. He knows that the competition is what it is, but we all want to get better for the team. That’s what the final goal is for the fall, to put the best product out there.”
McSorley and Stevens (No. 2) watch Clifford (No. 14) during a recent practice (Photo: Mark Brennan)
A frustrating stretch for Stevens has been well-documented. After accounting for nine total touchdowns as a passer, receiver and rusher in 2017, he spent substantial time in a walking boot last year, sidelined for spring camp, much of preseason camp, the first four games and the Citrus Bowl.
Stevens, who is down to his last season of college eligibility, has been forced to miss more action during the last four weeks.
"Tommy has done everything right for four years," Franklin said. "There’s been a huge body of work that we’ve seen from him. I think last year, in a lot of ways, wasn’t fair for him because he was playing with an injury, a pretty significant injury."
Stevens addressed the setback, and it's repercussions, earlier this month.
“I’ve kind of been bothered by the whole ‘injury prone’ stigma," he said. "Up until this point last year, I’d never missed a practice. In high school, I never missed anything and played a lot. I wouldn’t say that durability is an issue. I guess (the initial injury) was never really fixed the right way the first time. It was fixed right this time. I’m glad it was fixed right and I’m ready to prove my durability, my worth."
That proving ground looks likely to stretch into the coming months; perhaps even deep into August.
"Our coaching staff has all the belief in the world in Tommy," Franklin said. "Our coaching staff understands what Tommy has done and who he can be, but we also have belief in the other guys, and we’ve created real good competition in our quarterback room."
Redshirt freshman
Will Levis impressed as Penn State's scout team QB in 2018 and has instilled escalated confidence with a quality offseason. Freshmen
Michael Johnson Jr. and
Taquan Robersonenrolled in January and essentially spent this spring following by example.
All due respect to those quarterbacks and their futures at Penn State, this ultimately shapes up as a two-man showdown.
“It’s gonna be as intense as we make it," Clifford said. "We’re trying to put a bunch of pressure on each other to get each other better.”
Clifford, who stepped up as No. 2 QB last season during Stevens' absence, has earned considerable admiration from Penn State coaches and players during his development since enrolling on campus in June 2017.
He's transformed his body and cultivated a reputation as one of the locker room's most competitive personalities.
“You all have seen some of the throws he can make when he comes into games—he’s still doing that," senior cornerback
John Reid. "He has really good touch. He can put the ball in those little holes in the zone, so he’s showing a lot of growth. He’s showing a lot of good things this spring.”
Reid, who arrived on campus in 2015 alongside Stevens and missed the entire 2017 season with a knee injury, identifies with Stevens' struggle and believes the quarterback continues to make strides behind the scenes.
"Even when he's not in, you'll see him behind the offense going through his drop, looking and getting his reads," Reid said. "So it's almost like he's still getting reps. It's so mental from a quarterback aspect that he's like still getting those. ... The decision-making as a quarterback is ultra important and he's been working on that a lot this spring."
The next phase in Stevens' recovery — the one that genuinely launches this quarterback competition — will be a full-time replacement of mental reps with those of the physical variety.
"Obviously having Tommy back is going to be huge for all of us and I’m really excited about that," Franklin said.
Stevens has long been viewed as PSU's next starter. (Photo: Rick Osentoski, USA TODAY)
Penn State doesn't open the season for another four and a half months, so priorities and patience have been important for Stevens.
"Obviously I want to be doing everything but, with the exception of the spring game, there are no games in April," he said. "It’s all about being healthy for the season.”
Penn State starts its 2019 campaign Aug. 31 against Idaho in Beaver Stadium. Stevens has embraced the battle that awaits
"If you’re not getting pushed, there’s a problem," he said. "Even when Trace was here, I was trying to push him every day. ... Cliff’s done a great job, with an increase of reps, too. He plays well and he’s on scholarship at Penn State for a reason. Talented football player.”
Clifford worked to build upon the foundation of his case for starting consideration this spring. Sustained efforts are required to strengthen it.
"I’d tell you that I’m the most competitive guy on this team, because I am," he said. "… Backing it up is the biggest thing.”
The quarterback question mark — directly following a three-season stretch of the most productive quarterback play seen at Penn State — will be a dominant topic of discussion as the offseason continues.
Regarding any potential timeline to determine the outcome, stay tuned.
"Based on how things have played out, I don’t know when that will happen," Franklin said.