Objective is on the field results. Apparently everything didn't matter since the LOSS that Alabama had was ignored. Tell.me when Did Florida State lose....oh that's right they didnt.
Undefeated Florida State left out of College Football Playoff
- Thread starter CJFisJoePaII
- Start date
If nothing else, this choice of Alabama over Florida State makes a farce out of the weekly polling reveals. Such drama in the horse race, but when it gets to the end, the judges just make their own choice.
What actually happens always matters. You're just reducing it to not losing a game and ignoring everything else. Which is illogical--see Liberty. I'm the consistent one not you
Objectively, no team has been able to defeat FSU. that cannot be said for Texas or Alabama.
Really Lando? Liberty is a Conference USA participant. You are comparing apples to oranges.
Comparing FSU with a SOS of 55 to Bama or Texas is the same thing.
If you want it to be objective you can't pick which of the 10 conferences are better. The ACC is basically a G5 conference. It is what it is.
The ONLY argument anyone can make for FSU is they didn't lose. Same with Liberty. Any other review they lose.
Clemson is in the same conference and have been in the playoffs six times and twice winning the natty, since 2015. Doesn't sound like a G5 quality conference to me.
And conferences improve and get worse over time. This year there were 5 teams in consideration and we all know who the weakest is.
No, neither 5 nor 6 are in the playoff. Neither is 1.
Rankings change. Teams up and down as it's all opinion.
The team that got handled at home by Texas, and needed a Hail Mary to beat a bad 6-6 team just two weeks ago?
No, it's the team with SOS of 55 that struggled with BC, doesn't have a top 12 win and doesn't have their star QB. One that needed a miracle to beat Clemson. FSU played a weak schedule in the weakest P5 conference. They didn't deserve a spot and I said that long before the committee put them in.
Michigan playing Bama or FSU--what team has a better chance to beat them. We all know it isn't FSU. If you say otherwise you're either lying or you don't know enough about football to be discussing it.
Does the best team in the international league get into the MLB playoffs?....now use your brain and apply that to Liberty. Also Alabamas loss was ignored as they had a worse record than Florida state.
Liberty is in the same league as every other FBS team
The loss wasn't included. If you look at everything not just loss it's clear Bama is the better team. It's not even close. You and others refuse to look at anything other than 13-0 but disregard it with Liberty.
SEC/Big Ten is like MLB. ACC/Big XII are basically AAA if we're being honest using your illogical approach.
