ADVERTISEMENT

Who Replaces Gattis?

Would love to see Engram come back. Probably wishful thinking I don't know if he'd leave the NFL ranks .
 
  • Like
Reactions: BBrown
How about Mike Bellamy, currently at Toledo and has previously coached in the Big 10?
 
Franklin won't lack applications from quality candidates; I'm sure his phone is already ringing. But, he won't pick from those. He'll go with someone he's previously worked with or someone highly recommended by coaches that Franklin trusts.
 
One of JF's latest Twitter follows is a former PSU, RB great. Is it possible we hired Corley to be WR coach and will bring in Blair Thomas to be RB coach?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ranger Dan
One of JF's latest Twitter follows is a former PSU, RB great. Is it possible we hired Corley to be WR coach and will bring in Blair Thomas to be RB coach?

Would you want the Army WR coach to be our WR coach? I think that would be an underwhelming hire if that was the course CJF went. I’m sure the Army WR’s are amazing at blocking since their offense is not known to pass and stretch the field, but I want a real WR coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doc69
Would you want the Army WR coach to be our WR coach? I think that would be an underwhelming hire if that was the course CJF went. I’m sure the Army WR’s are amazing at blocking since their offense is not known to pass and stretch the field, but I want a real WR coach.
The duties of a coach are to recruit players, provide specific training for their role on the team, and help them maximize their potential on and off the field. Just because someone hasn’t coached an all American wide receiver, doesn’t mean that they aren’t great at all of the things a coach is supposed to do.
 
The duties of a coach are to recruit players, provide specific training for their role on the team, and help them maximize their potential on and off the field. Just because someone hasn’t coached an all American wide receiver, doesn’t mean that they aren’t great at all of the things a coach is supposed to do.

No doubt! I get that, but in addition to all that I want my coach to be able to know and teach the fundamentals and “little things” of the position and if you’ve never been a WR or coached them I would prefer someone else. But at the end of the day if a coach is picked by CJF and is wearing blue and white in the fall I’m supporting him.
 
No doubt! I get that, but in addition to all that I want my coach to be able to know and teach the fundamentals and “little things” of the position and if you’ve never been a WR or coached them I would prefer someone else. But at the end of the day if a coach is picked by CJF and is wearing blue and white in the fall I’m supporting him.
CJF coached wide receivers in the NFL. I trust he'll pick a the right man for the job.
 
One of JF's latest Twitter follows is a former PSU, RB great. Is it possible we hired Corley to be WR coach and will bring in Blair Thomas to be RB coach?

I seriously doubt it and sincerely hope not. Blair is a great guy, but he hasn’t coached football in 13 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BBrown
I wonder if Smith wants to coach WR. Since Corley and Smith have coached WR before, Franklin has some flexibility if he wants to hire another positional coach. This hire might be very interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BBrown
I am in the camp that believes that Penn State should not direct coaching searches with a focus upon the pool of former players or coaches who have coached here before. I know that this is a "fan" issue and not a tendency or even a thought process entertained by CJF or Penn State. That being said, we shouldn't exclude former players of coaches just because of this history.

Now, discussing the coaching search to replace Gattis, some have floated Bobby Engram's name, but have indicated that he is unlikely to leave his NFL role for a college / lateral move. When looking at an article today about the class of 2019 crystal predictions to Penn State, however, I see that Bobby's son is listed. This isn't startling news, but I'm wondering whether Bobby could have an interest in coaching his son in college and consider coming back to Penn State to do so. I'm not sure whether little Engram is going to play WR or CB in college, but there would still be a lot of value in coaching in the same program. It's still a long shot, but something more than an impossibility.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitt1300
I am in the camp that believes that Penn State should not direct coaching searches with a focus upon the pool of former players or coaches who have coached here before. I know that this is a "fan" issue and not a tendency or even a thought process entertained by CJF or Penn State. That being said, we shouldn't exclude former players of coaches just because of this history.

Now, discussing the coaching search to replace Gattis, some have floated Bobby Engram's name, but have indicated that he is unlikely to leave his NFL role for a college / lateral move. When looking at an article today about the class of 2019 crystal predictions to Penn State, however, I see that Bobby's son is listed. This isn't startling news, but I'm wondering whether Bobby could have an interest in coaching his son in college and consider coming back to Penn State to do so. I'm not sure whether little Engram is going to play WR or CB in college, but there would still be a lot of value in coaching in the same program. It's still a long shot, but something more than an impossibility.

If big brother Harbaugh and the Ravens aren't a lot better next year he may be out of a job.
 
I am in the camp that believes that Penn State should not direct coaching searches with a focus upon the pool of former players or coaches who have coached here before. I know that this is a "fan" issue and not a tendency or even a thought process entertained by CJF or Penn State. That being said, we shouldn't exclude former players of coaches just because of this history.

Now, discussing the coaching search to replace Gattis, some have floated Bobby Engram's name, but have indicated that he is unlikely to leave his NFL role for a college / lateral move. When looking at an article today about the class of 2019 crystal predictions to Penn State, however, I see that Bobby's son is listed. This isn't startling news, but I'm wondering whether Bobby could have an interest in coaching his son in college and consider coming back to Penn State to do so. I'm not sure whether little Engram is going to play WR or CB in college, but there would still be a lot of value in coaching in the same program. It's still a long shot, but something more than an impossibility.
of all the criterion for hiring a position coach or coordinator, "Penn State roots" would be about #45 on my list
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ranger Dan
of all the criterion for hiring a position coach or coordinator, "Penn State roots" would be about #45 on my list
I disagree. Stability is an incredibly important aspect when hiring a position coach. Look at what a powerful force LJ sr was to the program. Nothing is more powerful than a passionate and talented lifer as your position coach. It's gonna be hard to get that from an outsider. I agree though that coaching ability and recruiting ability totally trump anything else. But if those are close you give it to the guy with program ties.



Bobby engram would be an absolute dream but I can't imagine a position coach choosing coaching PLUS 24/7/365 recruiting over just coaching. Some guys like Franklin seem to relish the opportunity to work constantly but I doubt it's appealing to most. It's also more reasonable to expect it from someone getting paid In the millions rather than the hundred thousands
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT