OK, I am probably going to regret entering this particular Thunderdome, but here goes.
First, I'll add I am the second person in this thread to have worked in the ticket office. I am quite familiar with TM and Archtics software.
Now, let's all dial back the vitriol. We all want a packed house that helps carry us to a dominant performance to propel us to the Fiesta Bowl.
Normally, through my experience working in the ticket office, I am loathe to truly believe students, as some come up with some doozies that clearly aren't true. And in this case, I was prepared to not believe them again. UNTIL, the exact same thing started happening with regular season ticketholders like myself. There are dozens of posts on the usual popular Facebook PSU pages from season ticketholders who received emails saying that they had reserved their seats only to find that wasn't the case. (I am not on FB, but my wife was showing them to me as we watched hoops this evening.) One of the posts was someone I am friends with and served with on a charity board. He is, like me, a decades-long ticketholder. He reserved his seats, received the email confirming that he had done so, only to see HIS SEATS for sale when he viewed the public sale online yesterday morning. He called the ticket office, and was basically told sorry, can't help you. He ended up purchasing his seats for a nominally higher cost due to fees. Several other people posted the same experience.
When you combine all this, I think it's obvious something went wrong in the process. PSU has the ability in this instance, to point the finger at the CFP and TM, who are each pointing their fingers back at PSU. And in virtually every instance, I would not believe anything TM says or does. While not chicanery, all of these respective parties have screwed the pooch publicly and none should get the benefit of any doubt from a rightfully skeptical public. For further evidence, I will offer this tidbit: on the most recent BJC concert I worked about a month ago, there were several complaints regarding handicap seating. When I received one of these complaints, I looked up the tickets the woman purchased. Indeed, inexplicably, seats that were not handicapped accessible or in any way ADA approved were marked as such by TM/Archtics. This could not be explained by anyone in the ticket office.
Finally, and this is anecdotal and I am dubious myself. But I know a student who is friends with my son. I told him about the lottery and he said he was applying. I ran into him this weekend before Saturday's game and asked if had gotten a ticket and he said he didn't "win the lottery." I wasn't shocked by his answer given the past demand for student tickets.
What did shock me was that SEVEN FULL SECTIONS of student tickets were available for the NLC and public sale. Again, SEVEN sections (I am combining the halves of EBU and WBU as one section.)
So, while there is at this time no smoking gun, there is now a lot of circumstantial evidence pointing to some type of snafu. I think we can all agree on this. I don't know Audrey Snyder, but I'm sure she was shocked when she saw THAT MANY student tickets available. And she combined that data point with the unbelievable hotel prices into a social media post that subsequently drew this reaction.
Given that this story in now getting wider audiences, more info may come out. But again, IMO, something get messed up somewhere. And the evidence that's currently available points to either TM or PSU screwing up, but also possibly at CFP trying to maximize ticket sales by limiting cheap student tickets and expanding much more expensive public tickets at 6x the price ($25 vs $150).
Let's see what happens and where any news stories or investigations lead. Again, none of the entities currently involved (PSU/CFP/TM) have clothed themselves in glory in the past, and TM is one of America's most hated companies.
Hopefully, we can continue the discussion in a less heated manner. Carry on.