Finebaum ALREADY BITCHING... 😂

[mcpat]

Laughable, this system as currently oriented gave two teams outside the top 8 by the Final CFP Selection Rankings byes in the 1st RD (#12 and #9)! It required two teams ranked top 4 by the Final CFP Selection Rankings to play in the 1st RD (#3 Texas and #4 PSU)! It replaced the #11 ranked team in the Final CFP Selection Rankings with the #16 Team! And you claim this is a good system??? It's a ridiculously stupid and grossly inequitable "playoff" system. Out of one side of your mouth you say #1 v #16 @home, #2 v #15 @home, #3 v #14 @home and #4 v #13 @home are easy wins for the higher seeds especially with home-field advantage, so what on earth could be your problem with letting them play???? (It does not extend the playoff a single day) - you actually imply that #5 v #12 @home, #6 v #11 @home and #7 v #10 @home are easy wins for higher ranked team.... Keep in mind, this is ABSOLUTELY NOT what this absurd system gave us in the 1st RD! Using the actual Final CFP Selection Rankings, this system gave us #3 v #16, #4 v #10, #5 v #8 and #6 v #7 at the home of higher ranked team in the 1st RD???? It also put the #12 and #9 Selection Ranked teams into the 2nd RD without playing a game???? It eliminated the #11 Selection Ranked team without playing a game???? And due to it's beyond absurd 12-Team Re-Seeding System (it reseeded the Selection Rankings/Seeding

Yes. But as I said, not the seeding.

Funny how almost your entire post complains about seeding and I said seeding needs revisited.

 

[CJFisJoePaII]

Yes. But as I said, not the seeding.

Funny how almost your entire post complains about seeding and I said seeding needs revisited.

Good Lord, it's more than just the seeding the 12-Team Model does not work when you want to give auto-bids to 5 highest ranked Conference Champions. None of the Conferences play remotely similar schedules, so trying to compare them on record is pointless. Loaded Conferences like the B1G or SEC could easily have the 3, or even 4, best teams in the Country. Between the two, they could easily have 8 of the top 12.... other Conferences could easily have 2 or 3 of the top 12.... there is no way to know other than to seed the Bracket and let them play on the field. A 12-Team Bracket does not work when you want to guarantee 5 Conference Champions. You act like we know precisely how good a team like Boise State is.... - the actual reality is WE DON'T!... as their game earlier this year against #1 Oregon proves.

 

[mcpat]

You act like we know precisely how good a team like Boise State is.... - the actual reality is WE DON'T!... as their game earlier this year against #1 Oregon proves.

Is that how I act? You’re such a clown show.

 

[CJFisJoePaII]

Is that how I act? You’re such a clown show.

Yea, I'm a "clown show" because I don't claim to know with certainly who the 16 best D1A teams are out of a universe of 134 DIA teams??? Okee dokee Chief.... [insert eyeroll]. You might want to take a look in the mirror regarding that "clown show" thing genius.