That's flat out false about ISU vs. Rutgers. NJ is the 3rd or 4th best HS wrestling state in the country, and its residents are notoriously territorial about the state. Rutgers is the only public school in the state with D1 wrestling. Put the same coach, a good recruiter, in Ames and in New Brunswick, and ISU loses.
It's absolutely true that Jackson outrecruited Goodale -- but when has ISU had a NJ wrestler on its roster? Meanwhile Rutgers has lost out on every top end NJ wrestler in beyond the past decade except Ashnault and Glasgow. Burroughs, Molinaro, Caldwell, Mocco, Hahn, Campolattano, Kolodzik, McFadden, Chakonis, Kutler, Kui, Lewis, Sebastian, Griffith ... and they haven't exactly dipped into PA -- Tyson Dippery is the best recruit in memory (though they did land Dziewa before he flipped to Iowa). The Lehigh Valley (Allentown) -- the #1 or #2 talent pool in the country -- is 1 hr from Rutgers, and yet Rutgers lands none of them.
Frankly, it's embarrassing for the sport that Rutgers isn't at or near top 5 every year and an occasional title contender. Though not nearly as embarrassing as Pitt.