ADVERTISEMENT

Mind-Blowing Ohio State recruiting stat

Chickenman Testa

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2003
25,670
46,388
1
From the Brain himself, since Tom Ryan arrived he’s never had a recruiting class rated lower than 13 (Cael has had several NR classes since 2010). In the last 6 years, here are the comparitive rankings:

Ohio State: 6,1,13,10,1 and 3 this year

PSU: 4,22,1,7,NR, and 1

What’s (not) going on in Columbus?
 
From the Brain himself, since Tom Ryan arrived he’s never had a recruiting class rated lower than 13 (Cael has had several NR classes since 2010). In the last 6 years, here are the comparitive rankings:

Ohio State: 6,1,13,10,1 and 3 this year

PSU: 4,22,1,7,NR, and 1

What’s (not) going on in Columbus?
Recruiting National Championship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ccdiver
Recruiting National Championship.
The parallels to Mack Brown when he was UTs football coach are instructive. Mack Brown could only win due to overwhelming talent and won his only NC with an otherworldly performance from Vince Young who was never really coached. Ryan won during our punt year. He had a team with Stieber, NATO, Bo Jordan and Snyder and barely scraped over 100 points, then couldn’t win with teams containing nato, both Jordans, Snyder, Myles Martin and Joey McKenna.
 
The parallels to Mack Brown when he was UTs football coach are instructive. Mack Brown could only win due to overwhelming talent and won his only NC with an otherworldly performance from Vince Young who was never really coached. Ryan won during our punt year. He had a team with Stieber, NATO, Bo Jordan and Snyder and barely scraped over 100 points, then couldn’t win with teams containing nato, both Jordans, Snyder, Myles Martin and Joey McKenna.

There have been a lot of long bus rides and average officiating.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: diggerpup
These are probably his one-starter classes:
- 2013 = Zain
- 2015 = Cenzo
- 2019 = Carter
- 2022 = Levi

10 titles and counting from those four one-starter classes.

Meanwhile, Ryan has had 10 champs total since 2010 (Stieber 4x, Snyder 3x, Tomasello, Martin, Mendez).
With 9.9 scholarships, there are going to be a few years when the money is not available, a spot in the line-up is not available or the talent is lacking for the lineup needs. Get a few of those lining up in the same season and Cael isn't handing out many offers.
 
These are probably his one-starter classes:
- 2013 = Zain
- 2015 = Cenzo
- 2019 = Carter
- 2022 = Levi

10 titles and counting from those four one-starter classes.

Meanwhile, Ryan has had 10 champs total since 2010 (Stieber 4x, Snyder 3x, Tomasello, Martin, Mendez).

This is simple:

Ryan is very good at attracting talent; not so good at developing it.

Arguably, NATO and Martin not only didn't progress, they regressed.
 
These are probably his one-starter classes:
- 2013 = Zain
- 2015 = Cenzo
- 2019 = Carter
- 2022 = Levi

10 titles and counting from those four one-starter classes.

Meanwhile, Ryan has had 10 champs total since 2010 (Stieber 4x, Snyder 3x, Tomasello, Martin, Mendez).
Ouch
 
  • Like
Reactions: danoftw
From the Brain himself, since Tom Ryan arrived he’s never had a recruiting class rated lower than 13 (Cael has had several NR classes since 2010). In the last 6 years, here are the comparitive rankings:

Ohio State: 6,1,13,10,1 and 3 this year

PSU: 4,22,1,7,NR, and 1

What’s (not) going on in Columbus?
good recruiting does not equal great coaching!!LOL
 
Ryan = Franklin
And while I know Buckeye fans are going to get all bent out of shape about this thread, they say far, far worse about Franklin.

Both of them talk too much and focus on sideshows and empty salesmanship. Also, you can almost smell the panic from both of them when things get a little stressful.

At least Ryan has a title, though.
 
but the real question here is how many of those classes were better than any of Cael's classes including his NR classes?any?? and I mean winning team titles?
 
This is simple:

Ryan is very good at attracting talent; not so good at developing it.

Arguably, NATO and Martin not only didn't progress, they regressed.
The extended scramble between Max Dean and Martin when Dean upset the heavily favored Martin showed his limitations and also illustrated why Nickal generally handled him. Bo would get in a flurry with him and Martin would be lost
 
This is simple:

Ryan is very good at attracting talent; not so good at developing it.

Arguably, NATO and Martin not only didn't progress, they regressed.
That's kind of dumb about NATO and Martin. Sort of like saying that Nageo and Truax both regressed at PSU.

NATO was terrific, finishing 1-3-3-3 at NCAAs. That's three losses in four NCAA tourneys. He just had trouble with Iowa guys, losing to Gilman in 2016, Clark in 2017 (at 133 lb), then Lee in 2018 (back at 125).

Martin went 1-5-2-3. A bit of a blip in his sophomore year in 2017, but still damn good, four losses in four NCAA tournaments. Lost to Max Dean (then of Cornell) in the 2019 tourney, but of course beat Bo Nickal in the 2016 final.
 
This is simple:

Ryan is very good at attracting talent; not so good at developing it.

Arguably, NATO and Martin not only didn't progress, they regressed.
i think this is a lazy and oft repeated assessment.

ohio state has been very very good. the only reason to arrive at such a claim is to compare it to penn state, which is unfair.

penn state blows everyone out of the water. Ohio State does better than 'ok' for any sports program/franchise.
 
That's kind of dumb about NATO and Martin. Sort of like saying that Nageo and Truax both regressed at PSU.

NATO was terrific, finishing 1-3-3-3 at NCAAs. That's three losses in four NCAA tourneys. He just had trouble with Iowa guys, losing to Gilman in 2016, Clark in 2017 (at 133 lb), then Lee in 2018 (back at 125).

Martin went 1-5-2-3. A bit of a blip in his sophomore year in 2017, but still damn good, four losses in four NCAA tournaments. Lost to Max Dean (then of Cornell) in the 2019 tourney, but of course beat Bo Nickal in the 2016 final.
Agreed, though IMO the blip for Martin was his freshman year, where his half completely blew up. As the 11 seed, he beat the 6 plus three unseeded guys before the finals. The 2 and 3 seeds both lost their openers.

Credit to Martin for winning. Point is: had he finished 5 at 174, then 5-2-3 at 184, nobody would say he regressed.
 
Ryan is a much better recruiter of top wrestling talent than Franklin is of top end football talent.
Or Ryan is a better recruiter of highly ranked wrestlers while Carl finds and develops talented guys who are not ranked as highly.
 
These are probably his one-starter classes:
- 2013 = Zain
- 2015 = Cenzo
- 2019 = Carter
- 2022 = Levi

10 titles and counting from those four one-starter classes.

Meanwhile, Ryan has had 10 champs total since 2010 (Stieber 4x, Snyder 3x, Tomasello, Martin, Mendez).
Yeah, but in all fairness Bo Jordan would have been a multi-timer if he just hadn’t been dealt that hand …
 
And while I know Buckeye fans are going to get all bent out of shape about this thread, they say far, far worse about Franklin.

Both of them talk too much and focus on sideshows and empty salesmanship. Also, you can almost smell the panic from both of them when things get a little stressful.

At least Ryan has a title, though.
And hasn’t been sued for endangering the health of his athletes *yet.
 
The bad situation with Sasso kept Ohio State from a team trophy ...

Mendez/Welsh/Feldman is a very solid returning core to work with --- Kilkeary coming off R/S is a boost. Geog/Rogotzky/Bouzakis will be impactful - I see that line-up closer to 80 points in 2025 - will that be enough for a trophy?
 
Or Ryan is a better recruiter of highly ranked wrestlers while Carl finds and develops talented guys who are not ranked as highly.
Nobody actually thinks Ryan is a better recruiter. Don't get me wrong, he's obviously a good/great recruiter, but he's also forced to be an accumulator due to his guys not living up to expectations. Due to Cael's higher hit/success rate, he doesn't have to accumulate to the point Ryan does, which is ultimately reflected in the recruiting rankings.
 
If you take away Cael, Ryan has several NCAA team championships, Ohio State would probably be the best program over the last 10 to 15 years.
LOL A chance,how many years has he been there?if he was the football coach he would have been gone long ago!!
 
Nobody actually thinks Ryan is a better recruiter. Don't get me wrong, he's obviously a good/great recruiter, but he's also forced to be an accumulator due to his guys not living up to expectations. Due to Cael's higher hit/success rate, he doesn't have to accumulate to the point Ryan does, which is ultimately reflected in the recruiting rankings.
Cael philosophy is so far ahead of others in recruiting. Granted none can boast his accomplishments. Take Nick Lee and Chad Red for example, many if not a majority of coaches would have taken Red but Cael would rather have a guy fall short with the right attributes and the mindset to keep developing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: baccafarmer
OSU has no RTC, they constantly land great recruits and not sure how when these type of stats are easy to see. They do a good job of marketing themselves, but better open up the check book to bring in RTC guy and pay the wrestlers if they want to land Blaze, Basset or Jax
 
That's kind of dumb about NATO and Martin. Sort of like saying that Nageo and Truax both regressed at PSU.

NATO was terrific, finishing 1-3-3-3 at NCAAs. That's three losses in four NCAA tourneys. He just had trouble with Iowa guys, losing to Gilman in 2016, Clark in 2017 (at 133 lb), then Lee in 2018 (back at 125).

Martin went 1-5-2-3. A bit of a blip in his sophomore year in 2017, but still damn good, four losses in four NCAA tournaments. Lost to Max Dean (then of Cornell) in the 2019 tourney, but of course beat Bo Nickal in the 2016 final.

You actually post the position finishes that show both were nat'l champs and freshman and then show they never finished higher than third, except for the year Martin finished 2nd (because he was pinned).

I didn't say they didn't have good careers. But by the standard of improving (or at least maintaining obviously if you are an NC); they didn't do that. Nor did I say they were "bums", I have no doubt it's hard to maintain focus when you win it all and the classes start to get harder.

Compare that with Ant, Bo, Jason, Zain, Ant, Levi got beat in the finals and won this year. Mesenbrink finished second after not competing. Bartlett got better every year. Nico went 2-2-3-1. AB and Starocci got there year 1 and stayed there. Kasak better through this past season (ask Lovett).

You want to retract your kind of dumb statement?
 
These are probably his one-starter classes:
- 2013 = Zain
- 2015 = Cenzo
- 2019 = Carter
- 2022 = Levi

10 titles and counting from those four one-starter classes.

Meanwhile, Ryan has had 10 champs total since 2010 (Stieber 4x, Snyder 3x, Tomasello, Martin, Mendez).

You forgot about Moore and Pletcher.

FQZbNI1XsAkdGZy
 
Cael philosophy is so far ahead of others in recruiting. Granted none can boast his accomplishments. Take Nick Lee and Chad Red for example, many if not a majority of coaches would have taken Red but Cael would rather have a guy fall short with the right attributes and the mindset to keep developing.
Carl went after Red pretty hard.
 
Ohio State recruits way too many guys that are at or near their ceiling at the end of high school. I think Rocco Welsh will fall in to this category that his first year will probably be his best year. I know it’s a running joke, but they love guys that are completely jacked by age 17-18. Those guys just have no more levels to jump. Obviously Cael likes noodle armed guys that he can develop.
 
Carl went after Red pretty hard.
IIRC Red recruited Cael hard. Cael was interested and active, but simultaneously recruiting Nick Lee.

Once Lee committed to PSU, the writing was on the wall for Red, and he went corn about 2 weeks later.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jtothemfp
You actually post the position finishes that show both were nat'l champs and freshman and then show they never finished higher than third, except for the year Martin finished 2nd (because he was pinned).

I didn't say they didn't have good careers. But by the standard of improving (or at least maintaining obviously if you are an NC); they didn't do that. Nor did I say they were "bums", I have no doubt it's hard to maintain focus when you win it all and the classes start to get harder.

Compare that with Ant, Bo, Jason, Zain, Ant, Levi got beat in the finals and won this year. Mesenbrink finished second after not competing. Bartlett got better every year. Nico went 2-2-3-1. AB and Starocci got there year 1 and stayed there. Kasak better through this past season (ask Lovett).

You want to retract your kind of dumb statement?
No retraction. I still say that NATO and Martin did not regress throughout their careers, but maintained a high level of excellence. Same goes for Kyle Snyder and Logan Stieber. Luke Pletcher and Kollin Moore (both 2020 national champs, ha) improved pretty much every year throughout their careers. Jesse Mendez sure improved from his freshman to sophomore season. The broad, sweeping statements about Tan Tom and anOSU are rather ill-conceived.

And since you bring up PSU, what about Mark Hall, Cenzo Joseph, and RBY? All champs who came up just a tad short in their final seasons. It happens; winning a title is hard and even harder to repeat. Doesn't mean they regressed.
 
IIRC Red recruited Cael hard. Cael was interested and active, but simultaneously recruiting Nick Lee.

Once Lee committed to PSU, the writing was on the wall for Red, and he went corn about 2 weeks later.
I was so happy that cael chose nick. What a great wrestler he fit in with our program perfectly. Wish Joe would have planned out or Matt
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pitchfork Rebel
Kollin Moore and Luke Pletcher were as much 2020 NC's as Cenzo and Hall.

By the way, Cenzo had his best winning percentage in 2020. Hall had three losses in three years, two were to Zahid- one was a single point in the finals and he took a regular season L to Kem which he avenged in the B10's, (that's improvement).

RBY was a three time finalist; who lost once in three years to Vito-who broke a ridiculously long win streak and looked unbeatable until he was surprised by Crookham. Just about all observers thought RBY improved even as he remained unbeaten.

You're free to disagree; but you could have made a better case with a wrestler like Nick Nevills or the Lees not named Nick. On the other hand, there's a lot of examples of Penn State wrestlers getting better during their time-and a lot of Ohio Staters setting deadlift PR's.

Bottom line, Carl is better at developing his athletes.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT