We're comparing 2 all-time greats, with virtually no space between them. BUT, for sake of argument Zain DESTROYED Pantaleo 3 times, with 3 punishing falls. Nolf beat Pantaleo 6-4 in their one meeting so far.
Nolf and the huge gap to the field...
- Thread starter NittanyChris
- Start date
We're comparing 2 all-time greats, with virtually no space between them. BUT, for sake of argument Zain DESTROYED Pantaleo 3 times, with 3 punishing falls. Nolf beat Pantaleo 6-4 in their one meeting so far.
Someone is going to argue that Michigan was " beatdown week" so Nolf was at a disadvantage when he wrestled Panteleo. Lol
Well in fairness ... Zain had to work extremely hard to beat Deakin in his senior year at the Keystone Classic and only managed to major him with a last second takedown. Nolf, however, utterly destroyed Deakin from the get-go.
Both tech-ed Micah Jordan (16-0 and 16-1) but Nolf did it 2 1/2 minutes faster.
These comparisons don't always hold water for a variety of reasons (stylistic differences, among other reasons). For example, DT almost always destroyed opponents far worse than Dake (and everyone else) but never managed to solve the matchup with Dake himself in college.
IMHO this entire thread is just semantics. Nolf is awesome, Zain was awesome, Ruth & DT were awesome. They were all different wrestlers. Trying to determine which of those (or any other awesome wrestler like Cael) is an exercise in futility. They were/are ALL AWESOME and lots of fun to watch.
100% agree. They are all so great. It is all about preference and what you like to see. I never thought I'd enjoy watching a wrestler as much as I did David Taylor. In my opinion, he is easily a top 5 all-around talent despite only winning 2 titles. What he did at NCAA's to anyone not named Bubba Jenkins or Kyle Dake is simply remarkable. Then, Jason Nolf came along. In my opinion, Nolf is the most innovative wrestler I've ever watched. We are beyond lucky to have had these absolutely amazing talents. If I had to rank them, it would look like this (though I have no issue with someone ranking them in any order)
1. Nolf - He is just one of a kind with his innovation & relentless style.
2. Taylor - Simply a joy to watch. Always looking for ways to score.
3. Bo - So exciting to watch. He is so clutch.
4. Zain - I can't believe I have him 4. Just an absolute bruiser.
5. Ruth - I can't believe I have him 5. I've never seen someone look so calm during a match. I used to laugh when he'd have a single leg in the air, try a couple of trips and if they didn't work, he decided not to waste energy and just took him out of bounds because he knew he would just score when they went back to the middle.
These were just for fun, and obviously, I didn't include some other guys who could be in the conversation. I can't even tell you the amount of joy I've gotten watch these guys compete. I am also proud of the way and each and everyone of them handled themselves as well.
And, as I recall, he handled Trenge in final with the outcome never in doubt. I can't recall if he gave up a takedown to him or not. I do recall that Cael ankle picked Trenge at least twice in their finals match that year. I don't recall what happened in their earlier bout.
What does being gullible to sarcasm have to do with one’s life choices? Asking for a friend.
Someone didn't read the disclaimer very closely. Instructions were clearly given, but not followed. (insert winky face here)
Seriously though, Nova and Mvattivo summed it up well. All great wrestlers with different styles that were/are very entertaining to watch. Any true wrestling fan appreciated their skills, even when they were beating on their teams guy.
