Do have any knowledge of or experience with All-Season tires that have a Severe Snow Service Rating, I wonder if they would be a reasonable compromise to winter tires to avoid changing tires every winter. I see that there is a Kinergy 4S2 with that rating, that' not the same tire you had is it?
Not sure if you are referring to all-season tires rated with the ubiquitous “M+S” (mud snow) rating that is stamped on just about every all season tire these days - which is meaningless .... those tires = hot garbage in winter driving here along the shores of the Great Lakes...
or, You may be referring new hybrid designs ie. Michelin CrossClimate, which I do see get good reviews - alas, these seem to be still outshined in severe winter driving when contrasted by a genuine dedicated winter compound (at least that is what i read)... at $200 a tire, I’m not biting ... I’d rather be inconvenienced by an excellent dedicated winter set(s) clogging my garage.... I’m not interested in compromises when I’m trying to get somewhere when it’s dicey icy/snowy , and at $200 a pop they can keep their “decent” tires