In Massachusetts, the private Catholics compete against the publics (regular and postseason) and while they do have an advantage over the publics, the difference isn't as pronounced. The privates still shouldn't be competing against the publics for postseason team competitions in Massachusetts, but the advantage isn't as overwhelming as it can be in PA's case, because MA has a robust elite private/prep school system. Those schools - the 50-70K/year schools that also heavily recruit - compete against each other, and not the publics. They throw scholarships at the physical freaks, and that takes a large contingent of them out of the talent pool that the "normal" privates can select from. So while the Catholics do produce a D1 kid here and there, they aren't just littered with them. In PA, St. Joe's fills the void that a "typical" 70K/yr prep school in New England would fill.