I am never going to be able to grasp how you just assume Teasdale is minimally better than Teske and possibly far superior.
Just a guess, but I think we got something special in Teske. As well as Teasdale.
I love how 4-5 guys on this board sit back and spend most of the time ready to pounce on every comment, inuendoi or even typo that offends their sense of PSU fan superiority, constantly ripping brothers in Blue. Sad. If you have a different opinions state it with specifics - that's all.
What I 'assume' is pretty much Jack S&$@. So we have 2 4x state champs from different big wrestling states. 2- 3 years ago Teas seemed to be the second coming of Spencer Lee but then after a few loses he lost some of that luster. Teske although I believe undefeate in duals and states, and who both beat and then lost to another phenom in Thompson Iowa had less success in tournaments and all ranking services rate him far lower than Teas.
Both are 4x guys from great states and will develope under Cael into ....? Not even someone with your superior knowledge has any clue. 125 is a pretty damned solid weight class next year and it's hard to tell where either will fall, but I think expecting anything more than a top 8-12ish finish as true freshmen seems to me, to be overly optimistic, and thus the points impact for the team is really minimal.
To assume neither will finish above top 12 seems to disrespect Cael's ability to generally recruit great fits for his program and some pretty strong development mad skills. That said Nick Lee, Nolf, Nickal VJ all had the benefit of either a grey shirt or red shirt (granted Nick's came via what would have been his HS senior year).
Now, what I think is, Teasdale's petigree and this upside is likely stronger hence an early redshirt will help him more. If your implication is Teske is an automatic 0 points at Nationals while Teadale is Top 6 as a true freshman, disrespects Cael, Teske and at the same time is probably far too ambitious for Teasdale at this stage of his career.
Thus if you take a hard look at points potential at Nationals this year, the differential between the two will likely have zero impact relative to our winning another one.
If you want to speculate where they are 3-4 years from now and who has the better chance at being a top 4 type guy, most would say Teasdale hands down. From what I hear of Teske's heart and drive I would like another year or two before I can make an informed decision, but we all night just be surprised. I'm really glad we have then both as a future 1-2 punch.