Top Ten Players for 2024

[OKLionFan]

Black Shoe Diaries is counting down the top ten players for Penn State this year.
So far they have:
10. CB A.J. Harris
9. LB Tony Rojas
8. DB Jaylen Reed
7. TE Tyler Warren

Top six not posted yet. Anyone have any thoughts?
My top six would be:

6. LT Drew Shelton
5. DE Dani Dennis Sutton
4. DB Kevin Winston
3. RB Nick Singleton
2. DE Abdul Carter
1. QB Drew Aller

 

[PSU Soupy]

Kaytron Allen??

I would list top six:
6) DDS
5) Winston
4) Kaytron Allen
3) Nick Singleton
2) Abdul Carter
1) Drew Aller

With much of the OL in the 11 -15 range. Shelton perhaps the most important of the group at 11.

 

[LandoComando]

Kaytron Allen??

I would list top six:
6) DDS
5) Winston
4) Kaytron Allen
3) Nick Singleton
2) Abdul Carter
1) Drew Aller

With much of the OL in the 11 -15 range. Shelton perhaps the most important of the group at 11.

I'd switch 1-2 but Allen has to be in the Top 10 list or I don't understand what the list is supposed to be about.
I agree with 3-6

 

[Obliviax]

I don't have a problem but if you looked at the most impactful "person" instead of player, I'd say Andy K.

 

[OKLionFan]

I don't have a problem but if you looked at the most impactful "person" instead of player, I'd say Andy K.

I hope our most impactful player is Julian Fleming. We’d be really good because we know what everyone else is capable of.

 

[lazydave841]

I don't have a problem but if you looked at the most impactful "person" instead of player, I'd say Andy K.

Tengwall does his "critical players" top 10.

To note:

1. He puts Andy K at his #1
2. He blames Allar's struggles on a. Offensive coordinator b. WRs playing bad

 

[MacNit2.0]

Black Shoe Diaries is counting down the top ten players for Penn State this year.
So far they have:
10. CB A.J. Harris
9. LB Tony Rojas
8. DB Jaylen Reed
7. TE Tyler Warren

Top six not posted yet. Anyone have any thoughts?
My top six would be:

6. LT Drew Shelton
5. DE Dani Dennis Sutton
4. DB Kevin Winston
3. RB Nick Singleton
2. DE Abdul Carter
1. QB Drew Aller

Kaytron A = #1

 

[bdgan]

Rojas won't be out top player but how he performs might be most important.

 

[OKLionFan]

OK, Below were my final six and the actuals.

6. LT Drew Shelton 6. QB Drew Aller
5. DE Dani Dennis Sutton 5. DB Kevin Winston
4. DB Kevin Winston 4. RB Katron Allen
3. RB Nicholas Singleton 3. DE Dani Dennis Sutton
2. DE Abdul Carter 2. RB Nicholas Singleton
1. QB Drew Aller 1. DE Abdul Carter

There wasn't much disagreement on the six best. Salute to everyone who called me out on leaving Katron off of my list. What was I thinking?

 

[lazydave841]

OK, Below were my final six and the actuals.

6. LT Drew Shelton 6. QB Drew Aller
5. DE Dani Dennis Sutton 5. DB Kevin Winston
4. DB Kevin Winston 4. RB Katron Allen
3. RB Nicholas Singleton 3. DE Dani Dennis Sutton
2. DE Abdul Carter 2. RB Nicholas Singleton
1. QB Drew Aller 1. DE Abdul Carter

There wasn't much disagreement on the six best. Salute to everyone who called me out on leaving Katron off of my list. What was I thinking?

Allen is quiet. Steady Eddie. He's been what we hoped Noah Cain would become without the "3 years and I'm off to the NFL" talk. A lot of what he, and the entire team, has done for 2 years is taken for granted because we've lost to the same 2 top 5 level teams 2 years in a row.