ADVERTISEMENT

Abdul Carter

Interestingly, I could not understand how Abdul Carter was not a 5* and number 1 lber in his class after watching him play and checking his off the chart measurables. I can only assume he skipped most the pay for Stars camps that measure one on ones in free space...

He is as much a get on defense as Singleton is on offense. We, ladies and gentlemen get to watch them both ...
 
Did you hear what I heard? PHYSICALITY AND VIOLENCE? When did you EVER hear a Pry coached defense preach PHYSICALITY AND VIOLENCE? Yes, I put it in all caps, because I NEVER heard this during the Pry era....this is Manny Diaz at work. This is not your older brothers Penn State defense...this is a LOT more like your Dads Penn state defense...this kind of talk reminds me not of Micah Parsons era, not Poz era, not Lavar era, nope.

This is Trey Bauer, Shane Conlan, Duffy Cobbs, Bob White era....mean, hard, physical, create turnovers....
 
Carter is going to be a key component vs Michigan. His emergence, plus our running game has swayed the pendulum IMO. Going to Michigan is tough, but shoring up weak spots is huge.
If you want to start Carter you have to move Jacobs to Mike. You cannot ask a true freshman to play Mike, especially when you have a 4th year man playing the will who is capable of coming in and playing the Mike. Unless...you put Sutherland at the Mike.
 
If you want to start Carter you have to move Jacobs to Mike. You cannot ask a true freshman to play Mike, especially when you have a 4th year man playing the will who is capable of coming in and playing the Mike. Unless...you put Sutherland at the Mike.

No idea what Manny has in mind, but he's probably salivating at the prospects before him.

That’s interesting. I think Michigan looks better when McCarthy is under center. Only time will tell I suppose.

McCarthy is a dual threat. With our m2m, he can definitely hurt us with his legs.

Big issue is going to be how he handles pressure. Michigan has played some soup cans thus far and ran the score up. Yes, they look effective and efficient, but it would be red flags if they didn’t.

Unless something happens between now and the game, this game is looking like a very tough match-up. I feel that we have been tested more and will know who we are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Westcoast24
No idea what Manny has in mind, but he's probably salivating at the prospects before him.



McCarthy is a dual threat. With our m2m, he can definitely hurt us with his legs.

Big issue is going to be how he handles pressure. Michigan has played some soup cans thus far and ran the score up. Yes, they look effective and efficient, but it would be red flags if they didn’t.

Unless something happens between now and the game, this game is looking like a very tough match-up. I feel that we have been tested more and will know who we are.
McNamara has beaten Penn State, McCarthy has not.
 
If you want to start Carter you have to move Jacobs to Mike. You cannot ask a true freshman to play Mike, especially when you have a 4th year man playing the will who is capable of coming in and playing the Mike. Unless...you put Sutherland at the Mike.
If Carter would start at Will, where he is now practicing and playing, Jacobs could move pretty easily back to Sam (replacing Sutherland, who would then back him up there, along with DeLuca) where he started and played very well last season. King would hopefully/likely start at Mike with Elsdon backing him up as Elsdon looks too slow to me to be an impact LB for PSU.
 
If Carter would start at Will, where he is now practicing and playing, Jacobs could move pretty easily back to Sam (replacing Sutherland, who would then back him up there, along with DeLuca) where he started and played very well last season. King would hopefully/likely start at Mike with Elsdon backing him up as Elsdon looks too slow to me to be an impact LB for PSU.
Which is fine, except I'm seeing a lot more 2lb sets than 3 LB sets right NOW...looking ahead to Michigan, Minnesota, Illinois, all run heavy teams...yes indeed Good Sir, you just might be on to something...but for now do you do this now? Or spring it later?
 
They did play crap teams which is why it surprised me how Cade looked so sloppy and uncomfortable. Like I said only time will tell.
He looked damn good throwing those 3 touchdown passes against us last year. I'm praying they play McCarthy against us, not McNamara...this is just me but I go by what a certain strength is vs our defense rather than measurables.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Westcoast24
Carter is violent. Some players just seem more aggressive in everything they do. Jacobs is fantastic, but Carter is violent and always in a hurry to be violent. If you've been watching #33 -Dennis-Sutton is improving at a rapid pace. He did not have the spring so he's a bit behind, but he is going to be great as well. The Auburn OT basically had to tackle him on every play to keep him from the QB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NedFromYork
Carter is violent. Some players just seem more aggressive in everything they do. Jacobs is fantastic, but Carter is violent and always in a hurry to be violent. If you've been watching #33 -Dennis-Sutton is improving at a rapid pace. He did not have the spring so he's a bit behind, but he is going to be great as well. The Auburn OT basically had to tackle him on every play to keep him from the QB.
That Auburn quarterback who he shot in and just obliterated, actually moving faster than, is probably the fastest quarterback in the nation. This kid is the real deal. He has to play. Period.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lilromeo
Carter is violent. Some players just seem more aggressive in everything they do. Jacobs is fantastic, but Carter is violent and always in a hurry to be violent. If you've been watching #33 -Dennis-Sutton is improving at a rapid pace. He did not have the spring so he's a bit behind, but he is going to be great as well. The Auburn OT basically had to tackle him on every play to keep him from the QB.
Carter better be fast and violent. Keeping up with some past No 11s.
 
Which is fine, except I'm seeing a lot more 2lb sets than 3 LB sets right NOW...looking ahead to Michigan, Minnesota, Illinois, all run heavy teams...yes indeed Good Sir, you just might be on to something...but for now do you do this now? Or spring it later?
The timing of any changes should be something to watch for. On the one hand why should PSU show any changes on film to Michigan during the 2 games before Michigan. But on the other hand with a young crew of LB's dramatic changes would be great to experiment with against the weaker opponents to get players comfortable with their responsibilities.

In the 2 LB sets it would seem that Jacobs being in his 3rd year could be the one that sets the defense, usually the responsibility of the Mike in a 3 LB set, if he was on the field with Carter.

And then there is the fact that PSU apparently played some 3-1-7 sets against Auburn. Overall a lot less snaps for LB's and with the top 3 performers apparently being Jacobs, Carter and King will the staff get enough snaps for Sutherland and Elsdon to keep them involved.

But in games such as versus Michigan that would like to power run until they are stopped, I'm still hoping for Jacobs, King and Carter to be the starters.
 
Last edited:
If Carter would start at Will, where he is now practicing and playing, Jacobs could move pretty easily back to Sam (replacing Sutherland, who would then back him up there, along with DeLuca) where he started and played very well last season. King would hopefully/likely start at Mike with Elsdon backing him up as Elsdon looks too slow to me to be an impact LB for PSU.
Agreed 100%. This is the way to go. Having Jacobs, Carter and King on the field simultaneously is the goal and your suggestion seems the best way to get there.

WE ARE!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregInPitt
Did you hear what I heard? PHYSICALITY AND VIOLENCE? When did you EVER hear a Pry coached defense preach PHYSICALITY AND VIOLENCE? Yes, I put it in all caps, because I NEVER heard this during the Pry era....this is Manny Diaz at work. This is not your older brothers Penn State defense...this is a LOT more like your Dads Penn state defense...this kind of talk reminds me not of Micah Parsons era, not Poz era, not Lavar era, nope.

This is Trey Bauer, Shane Conlan, Duffy Cobbs, Bob White era....mean, hard, physical, create turnovers....
Spot on. Watching Iowa, Illinois, Minnesota having their way against us was disgusting to watch.
 
The timing of any changes should be something to watch for. On the one hand why should PSU show any changes on film to Michigan during the 2 games before Michigan. But on the other hand with a young crew of LB's dramatic changes would be great to experiment with against the weaker opponents to get players comfortable with their responsibilities.

In the 2 LB sets it would seem that Jacobs being in his 3rd year could be the one that sets the defense, usually the responsibility of the Mike in a 3 LB set, if he was on the field with Carter.

And then there is the fact that PSU apparently played some 3-1-7 sets against Auburn. Overall a lot less snaps for LB's and with the top 3 performers apparently being Jacobs, Carter and King will the staff get enough snaps for Sutherland and Elsdon to keep them involved.

But in games such as versus Michigan that would like to power run until they are stopped, I'm still hoping for Jacobs, King and Carter to be the starters.
I would go the other way and show them multiple sets, player groups, blitzes and formations over the next two weeks so that there are so many variations that it makes it extremely difficult to scheme. Then I'd throw something totally different at them. Diaz is certainly not constrained by anything. I heard that they played 27 different defensive players for over 10 snaps each against Auburn. That is 2.5 full teams which is an insane number against a "good" opponent and with an away travel squad.

No one can argue with the desire of having Jacobs and Carter on the field at the same time, but are Manny's WIL and SAM similar to those of Pry. Jacobs probably would have to move to WIL and has not played it under Manny. If you leave only Carter and Jacobs on the filed then they are playing MIKE and SAM and responsible for setting the D. Big question is whether Jacobs can play all 3 spots, make the calls etc. Who comes off the field when we go to extra safeties and corners? It may be more difficult than you think. I don't know though. Maybe they practice at all spots just in case and they can do it seamlessly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregInPitt
That is 2.5 full teams which is an insane number against a "good" opponent and with an away travel squad.

Think I read something that we didn't have any limitations on our travel squad because that's a Big 10 rule, not SEC. Tried to find the link but didn't see it.
 
No one can argue with the desire of having Jacobs and Carter on the field at the same time, but are Manny's WIL and SAM similar to those of Pry. Jacobs probably would have to move to WIL and has not played it under Manny. If you leave only Carter and Jacobs on the filed then they are playing MIKE and SAM and responsible for setting the D. Big question is whether Jacobs can play all 3 spots, make the calls etc. Who comes off the field when we go to extra safeties and corners? It may be more difficult than you think. I don't know though. Maybe they practice at all spots just in case and they can do it seamlessly.
It is amazing that PSU could play so many players and seem to play well with all the combinations.

Jacobs moved to Will after last season from Sam where he started and played very well for all of 2021 and practiced there last Spring under Manny, and started there this season, so I didn't follow you there....
 
Last edited:
It is amazing that PSU could play so many players and seem to play well with all the combinations.

Jacobs moved to Will after last season and has practiced there last Spring under Manny, and starter there this season, so I didn't follow you there....

Well, honestly the 4th QTR D, which was deep on depth chart, didn't play all that well, but the game was over at that point. Still the last 0.5 of that 2.5 probably saw way more snaps than they usually would in that game (i.e, virtually the entire 4th QTR).
 
Well, honestly the 4th QTR D, which was deep on depth chart, didn't play all that well, but the game was over at that point. Still the last 0.5 of that 2.5 probably saw way more snaps than they usually would in that game (i.e, virtually the entire 4th QTR).
I messed up my Wills and Sams again.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT