Was DT that year a better overall wrestler than Dake that year?
If you measure by team points during the season and in the NCAA tournament, it's not even close. DT by a mile.
That question doesn't have anything to do with wrestling, does it?
? Of course it does, because by pretty simple logic, the guy you want on your team is the better wrestler. I can't think of any reason why you'd want Dake on your team in 2013 rather than Taylor except for bragging rights unrelated to your team's actual performance. If Taylor gets more team points during the season and during NCAAs, why would you want Dake instead? So you can say "we had x+1 individual champs" instead of "we had x individual champs". There is rather obvious scenario where having the champ instead of the guy who scored more team points could cost you a team championship.