Comparing CJF with a vacuum again...smh
Despite the fact that his tenure has had a few low points, imho without CJF, PSU would be unequivocally WORSE. For various reasons, the name Penn State does not recruit for itself or represent itself the way that it once may have...CJF's leadership and charisma is to be given credit for competing for recruits at such a high level. This has kept PSU relevant each season except for last year. That said, although the OL and DL recruiting have experienced some success, it has certainly not been at the same level as recruiting for other positions, which is precisely why PSU is more prone to upsets (despite its talent at other positions) than the highest tier of teams with dominant lines. Also, he clearly has proven successful in recruiting stars, but the depth behind those stars has obviously been an issue; DL depth was a primary factor in the referenced lost leads in the OSU games.
Those of us who support Franklin are not contending that everything he does is perfect...but we have the foresight to reasonably and logically predict that his replacement will not recruit as well as him, win as much as he has, or have us with at least a chance in the conversation for playoff births during the season (and a chance to actually earn one if factors such as avoiding injuries to key players turn out favorably during any given season).
So when I support Franklin it isn't because I think he has already had Saban-level success and can do no wrong or never makes a bad decision, it is because I don't want the program to go BACKWARDS. Backwards is the most likely outcome of dismissing or losing Franklin. Currently, on any given year, PSU at least has a puncher's chance...why would we give that up unless Saban himself is heading north?