Alrighty, then. Sometimes it is easy.
For the Excel nerds, the following is what got me into trouble...
=IF(AND(B6<>"",B6=B$4,C6=C$4),3,IF(AND(B6<>"",B6=B$4,C6<>C$4),2,0))
How? Well, when Penn State forfeits the 125 match, and, therefore, there is nothing in cell B6, B6 being nothing causes the AND statements to be false and return 0. The zero is correct for 125, but copy, paste and repeat across the weights, and it fails.
Anyway, here are the updated results. Same totals, but corrected individual bout scores.