ADVERTISEMENT

OT Propane heaters

marshall23

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2013
18,934
28,959
1
All knowing board: After living in my home for 40 years, I had heating pipes freeze in the ceiling of my garage last week. I am looking for advice as I am considering purchasing an indoor propane heater as a precaution should we encounter another similar cold spell in the future. I live in a raised ranch with bedrooms above the garage area. Of course the garage is poorly insulated. I would only use the heater during times like the last incredible cold snap. Thoughts?
 
Agree, kerosene heater or even an electric one....never propane indoors due to co hazard.
 
My heat in my addition went out this past fall. The plumbers in the area were overwhelmed with all the flooded basements this year. The guy that has worked on it said he couldn't get to it until January. Well, January came, and he didn't.

I went with electric heaters and use a small propane one to heat rooms and give the electric heaters a rest. During the cold and windy spell, the electric heaters only heated rooms to the mid 50s. The propane would bring it up into the 60s within a half hour.

You can use propane, but you can't bring the tanks in the house. If you plan to use a 20lb tank, you'll need to get a hose extension and bring it through a window or some other method.

Or, you can use 1 lb tanks that are disposable. You aren't supposed to fill them, and if you have a fire or some other disaster, you probably won't be covered by insurance, and there is a penalty of up to a $500,000 fine and 5 years in jail. They do make reusable 1 lb tanks that you can refill. Flame King makes a kit for about $50-60. Makes things affordable.

If you go with a bigger tank on the outside, Tractor Supply had some gas heaters with a thermostat and fan for $149. I almost bought one. But, you aren't supposed to use any of the gas heaters while you are asleep. You might not wake up.

I have a wood stove in the main house, so I keep my oil heat temp down and use the wood to take the chill off. In the bedroom, we have a mattress pad heater that makes a cool room tolerable. Bathroom trips are a little spirited.

I never used kerosene as a heater. I've been in places that had them and they smell worse than gas.
 
I grew up with a Kerosene heater. Very economical, but it did smell. I did not notice it, but my wife told me the smell would make her sick. (That is her excuse for only staying one night at at time at my parents house, while we spent a week with her family.)
There is also a safety factor of it getting knocked over, kids getting burned by touching it, etc. If you cannot tell, I am not a fan of a Kerosene Heater.
 
All knowing board: After living in my home for 40 years, I had heating pipes freeze in the ceiling of my garage last week. I am looking for advice as I am considering purchasing an indoor propane heater as a precaution should we encounter another similar cold spell in the future. I live in a raised ranch with bedrooms above the garage area. Of course the garage is poorly insulated. I would only use the heater during times like the last incredible cold snap. Thoughts?
I actually think it would be safer and more effective to take down the drywall on your garage ceiling, reinsulate the joist cavities properly and then rehang new drywall. A 4x8 sheet of 5/8" drywall is only around $10. This is an easy DIY project if you have a few buddies to help you hang the drywall or you can go rent a lift.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 91Joe95
I grew up with a Kerosene heater. Very economical, but it did smell. I did not notice it, but my wife told me the smell would make her sick. (That is her excuse for only staying one night at at time at my parents house, while we spent a week with her family.)
There is also a safety factor of it getting knocked over, kids getting burned by touching it, etc. If you cannot tell, I am not a fan of a Kerosene Heater.
I'm alone now, wife passed away and kids are all grown up. I'm looking for something to heat my garage during ultra cold spells so the pipes above won't freeze. Not looking for anything in my living areas.
 
THere are indoor safe propane heaters that work great. The Big Buddy puts out a lot of heat. There are smaller versions as well (Little Buddy) and an even smaller one. But many other propane heaters are not rated indoor safe. As an extra precaution, use a carbon monoxide alarm (about $15) but not really necessary. The Big Buddys are efficient and pose no risk. Available at most Home Depots, but I got my last one on Amazon.
 
I actually think it would be safer and more effective to take down the drywall on your garage ceiling, reinsulate the joist cavities properly and then rehang new drywall. A 4x8 sheet of 5/8" drywall is only around $10. This is an easy DIY project if you have a few buddies to help you hang the drywall or you can go rent a lift.

This is the best idea. But make sure it gets done properly. With living space over the garage, you gotta definitely follow code or you could cause yourself more issues later.
 
I'd avoid the propane, especially if you have to hook up a tank. Fittings invariably leak, and then you've got a serious problem in an indoor space when that happens. They make electric heating tape that wraps around pipes. Also, a very simple solution is to crack open your faucets and let it slowly trickle out during those really cold times. Drywall is not hard, especially in a garage, and it's also cheap if you need to hire someone for it.
 
All knowing board: After living in my home for 40 years, I had heating pipes freeze in the ceiling of my garage last week. I am looking for advice as I am considering purchasing an indoor propane heater as a precaution should we encounter another similar cold spell in the future. I live in a raised ranch with bedrooms above the garage area. Of course the garage is poorly insulated. I would only use the heater during times like the last incredible cold snap. Thoughts?

If you can get a 240V circuit to the garage you could go with something like this....
https://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200631888_200631888
 
All knowing board: After living in my home for 40 years, I had heating pipes freeze in the ceiling of my garage last week. I am looking for advice as I am considering purchasing an indoor propane heater as a precaution should we encounter another similar cold spell in the future. I live in a raised ranch with bedrooms above the garage area. Of course the garage is poorly insulated. I would only use the heater during times like the last incredible cold snap. Thoughts?
Remove drywall along pipe run and have heat tapes wrapped on pipes. Re-drywall. Plug tapes into 120v when necessary.

Drip water faucets at end of pipe runs if possible.

Add 1-2 2" solid form insulation over drywall along pipe runs and add drywall over insulation for fire rating.
 
THere are indoor safe propane heaters that work great. The Big Buddy puts out a lot of heat. There are smaller versions as well (Little Buddy) and an even smaller one. But many other propane heaters are not rated indoor safe. As an extra precaution, use a carbon monoxide alarm (about $15) but not really necessary. The Big Buddys are efficient and pose no risk. Available at most Home Depots, but I got my last one on Amazon.
NICE! And,what is the version that is smaller than the “Little Buddy” called? If it’s “The little Buddy’s ‘Little Buddy’”, then I think I have a Trademark infringement case as my very own “Little Buddy” always responds to that moniker (he loves irony)!
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT