below are the rankings from various publications, web sites, and ranking services. I'll update the review as additional rankings are posted during the week, and when all are posted will generate an average ranking.
InterMat (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (4th)
141: Gulibon - 13th (13th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 16th (Morelli - 19th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 13th (13th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (no PSUer)
Team Tournament - 1st (1st)
Team Dual Meet - 1st (1st)
FloWrestling (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: No PSUer (No PSUer)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 10th (12th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 12th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Tournament Team - 1st (1st)
Dual Team - 1st (1st)
P4P
Zain - 5th (5th)
Nico - 9th (9th)
McIntosh - 13th (12th)
Nolf - 20th (19th)
The Open Mat (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 4th (5th)
141: Gulibon - 14th (15th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 11th (14th)
174: Nickal - 2nd (1st)
184: Cutch - 12th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (no PSUer)
Wrestling Report (Top 33 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: Gulibon - 21st (20th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 13rd (Morelli - 17th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 14th (14th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Team - 1st (1st)
Individual - 1st (new ranking)
WIN Magazine (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 6th (6th)
141: Moss - 16th (Gulibon - 20th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 15th (Morrelli - 16th)
174: Nickal - 2nd (1st)
184: Cutch - 15th (15th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer
Team Tournament - 1st (1st)
Team Dual - 1st (1st)
USA Today/NWCA Division 1 Coaches Poll
PSU - 1st (1st)
Amateur Wrestling News (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (4th)
141: Gulibon - 13th (12th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 8th (Morelli - 14th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 16th (16th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
WrestleStats (Top 100+ wrestlers, including those RSing)
125: Nico - 4th (4th), Yanovich - 72nd (72nd), Higgins - 154th (158th), Stossel - 185th (193rd)
133: Conaway - 5th (4th), Corez - 4th (3rd), Carpenter - 192nd (186th)
141: Gulibon - 28th (31st), Moss - 42nd (45th), T. Law - 90th (96th), Dinmore 115th (118th), Giannangell - 178th (175th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 2nd (2nd), Beitz - 11th (10th), V. Joseph - 32nd (27th)
165: Rasheed - 8th (16th), Hammond - 20th (20th), Morelli - 21st (24tht), C. Law - 56th (54th), Livingston - 104th (98th), Bisono - 199th (not sure if he was ranked last week)
174: Nickal - 2nd (1st), Brill - 37th (37th)
184: Cutch - 9th (9th), Stout - 44th (44th), Van Cura - 76th (81st), Daily - 193rd (190th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: Johnson - 186th (175th)
Team - 1st (1st)
Associated Wrestling Press (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: Gulibon - 7th (7th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 15th (19th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 12th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Dual Impact Index powered by National Collegiate Open (All starters, with redshirts included)
125: Nico - 3rd (4th), Yanovich - 38th (36th), Higgins - 70th (70th), Stossel - 76th (75th)
133: Conaway - 8th (11th), Cortez - 3rd (3rd)
141: Moss - 23rd (25th), Gulibon - 27th (29th), Dinmore - 36th (39th), Giannangeli - 69th (68th), T. Law - 73rd (72nd)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 1st (1st), Beitz - 8th (8th)
165: Rasheed 7th (10th), Morelli - 11th (10th), Hammond - 6th (5th), C. Law - 34th (36th), Livingston - 65th (63rd), Bisono - 75th (73rd)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st), Brill - 42nd (36th)
184: Cutch - 10th (9th), Stout - 28th (29th), Van Cura - 42nd (41st)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: Johnson - 72nd (no previous ranking, as he didn't have 5 matches)
Team Tournament - 1st (1st)
Team Dual - 1st (1st)
Team Dual Component - 1st (first time this ranking appeared)
Team Roster Component - 1st (2nd)
P4P
Zain - 1st (1st)
Nolf - 5th (5th)
McIntosh - 8th (7th)
Nickal - 15th (10th)
Nico - 41st (50th)
Rasheed - 73rd (107th)
Cutch - 89th (83rd)
Conaway - 105th (104th)
Moss - 179th (192nd)
Johnson - 718th (NR)
Average
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: Gulibon -17th (18th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 11th (14th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 13th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Team - 1st (1st)
Just when I was about to drop Associated Wrestling Press from the weekly review, they posted weekly rankings for the 2nd week in a row. The computer generated rankings are becoming far more accurate, as they got a lot more data from Midlands and from the Scuffle. If the 2 computer generated rankings (WrestleStats and Dual Impact Index) are excluded from the Average, these would be the Average for the respective PSU wrestlers (with a comparison in parenthesis): Nico - 4th (same), Conaway - 5th (same), Gulibon - 14th (up), Zain - 1st (same), Nolf - 3rd (same), Rasheed - 11th (same), Nickal - 1st (same), Cutch 13th (same), McIntosh - 1st (same), Team - 1st (same). Since only 1 ranking would be different (Gulibon is 17th with all rankings, and 14th if the computer generated are excluded), it appears that the computer generated rankings have gotten sufficient data for the season, so I'm going to stop writing up the variation, unless it gets quite skewed in the future.
InterMat's 1/12 Rankings
FloWrestling's 1/11 Rankings
TOM's 1/12 Rankings
Wrestling Report's 1/12 Rankings
WIN Magazine's 1/11 Rankings
USA Today/NWCA Division I Wrestling Coaches Poll for 1/12
Amateur Wrestling News' 1/12 Rankings
WrestleStat's 1/12 Rankings
Associated Wrestling Press' 1/14 Rankings
Dual Impact Index presented by the National Collegiate Open 1/11 Rankings
InterMat (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (4th)
141: Gulibon - 13th (13th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 16th (Morelli - 19th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 13th (13th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (no PSUer)
Team Tournament - 1st (1st)
Team Dual Meet - 1st (1st)
FloWrestling (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: No PSUer (No PSUer)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 10th (12th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 12th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Tournament Team - 1st (1st)
Dual Team - 1st (1st)
P4P
Zain - 5th (5th)
Nico - 9th (9th)
McIntosh - 13th (12th)
Nolf - 20th (19th)
The Open Mat (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 4th (5th)
141: Gulibon - 14th (15th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 11th (14th)
174: Nickal - 2nd (1st)
184: Cutch - 12th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (no PSUer)
Wrestling Report (Top 33 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: Gulibon - 21st (20th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 13rd (Morelli - 17th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 14th (14th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Team - 1st (1st)
Individual - 1st (new ranking)
WIN Magazine (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 6th (6th)
141: Moss - 16th (Gulibon - 20th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 15th (Morrelli - 16th)
174: Nickal - 2nd (1st)
184: Cutch - 15th (15th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer
Team Tournament - 1st (1st)
Team Dual - 1st (1st)
USA Today/NWCA Division 1 Coaches Poll
PSU - 1st (1st)
Amateur Wrestling News (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (4th)
141: Gulibon - 13th (12th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 8th (Morelli - 14th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 16th (16th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
WrestleStats (Top 100+ wrestlers, including those RSing)
125: Nico - 4th (4th), Yanovich - 72nd (72nd), Higgins - 154th (158th), Stossel - 185th (193rd)
133: Conaway - 5th (4th), Corez - 4th (3rd), Carpenter - 192nd (186th)
141: Gulibon - 28th (31st), Moss - 42nd (45th), T. Law - 90th (96th), Dinmore 115th (118th), Giannangell - 178th (175th)
149: Zain - 2nd (2nd)
157: Nolf - 2nd (2nd), Beitz - 11th (10th), V. Joseph - 32nd (27th)
165: Rasheed - 8th (16th), Hammond - 20th (20th), Morelli - 21st (24tht), C. Law - 56th (54th), Livingston - 104th (98th), Bisono - 199th (not sure if he was ranked last week)
174: Nickal - 2nd (1st), Brill - 37th (37th)
184: Cutch - 9th (9th), Stout - 44th (44th), Van Cura - 76th (81st), Daily - 193rd (190th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: Johnson - 186th (175th)
Team - 1st (1st)
Associated Wrestling Press (Top 20 per weight class)
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: Gulibon - 7th (7th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 15th (19th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 12th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Dual Impact Index powered by National Collegiate Open (All starters, with redshirts included)
125: Nico - 3rd (4th), Yanovich - 38th (36th), Higgins - 70th (70th), Stossel - 76th (75th)
133: Conaway - 8th (11th), Cortez - 3rd (3rd)
141: Moss - 23rd (25th), Gulibon - 27th (29th), Dinmore - 36th (39th), Giannangeli - 69th (68th), T. Law - 73rd (72nd)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 1st (1st), Beitz - 8th (8th)
165: Rasheed 7th (10th), Morelli - 11th (10th), Hammond - 6th (5th), C. Law - 34th (36th), Livingston - 65th (63rd), Bisono - 75th (73rd)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st), Brill - 42nd (36th)
184: Cutch - 10th (9th), Stout - 28th (29th), Van Cura - 42nd (41st)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: Johnson - 72nd (no previous ranking, as he didn't have 5 matches)
Team Tournament - 1st (1st)
Team Dual - 1st (1st)
Team Dual Component - 1st (first time this ranking appeared)
Team Roster Component - 1st (2nd)
P4P
Zain - 1st (1st)
Nolf - 5th (5th)
McIntosh - 8th (7th)
Nickal - 15th (10th)
Nico - 41st (50th)
Rasheed - 73rd (107th)
Cutch - 89th (83rd)
Conaway - 105th (104th)
Moss - 179th (192nd)
Johnson - 718th (NR)
Average
125: Nico - 4th (4th)
133: Conaway - 5th (5th)
141: Gulibon -17th (18th)
149: Zain - 1st (1st)
157: Nolf - 3rd (3rd)
165: Rasheed - 11th (14th)
174: Nickal - 1st (1st)
184: Cutch - 13th (12th)
197: McIntosh - 1st (1st)
285: No PSUer (No PSUer)
Team - 1st (1st)
Just when I was about to drop Associated Wrestling Press from the weekly review, they posted weekly rankings for the 2nd week in a row. The computer generated rankings are becoming far more accurate, as they got a lot more data from Midlands and from the Scuffle. If the 2 computer generated rankings (WrestleStats and Dual Impact Index) are excluded from the Average, these would be the Average for the respective PSU wrestlers (with a comparison in parenthesis): Nico - 4th (same), Conaway - 5th (same), Gulibon - 14th (up), Zain - 1st (same), Nolf - 3rd (same), Rasheed - 11th (same), Nickal - 1st (same), Cutch 13th (same), McIntosh - 1st (same), Team - 1st (same). Since only 1 ranking would be different (Gulibon is 17th with all rankings, and 14th if the computer generated are excluded), it appears that the computer generated rankings have gotten sufficient data for the season, so I'm going to stop writing up the variation, unless it gets quite skewed in the future.
InterMat's 1/12 Rankings
FloWrestling's 1/11 Rankings
TOM's 1/12 Rankings
Wrestling Report's 1/12 Rankings
WIN Magazine's 1/11 Rankings
USA Today/NWCA Division I Wrestling Coaches Poll for 1/12
Amateur Wrestling News' 1/12 Rankings
WrestleStat's 1/12 Rankings
Associated Wrestling Press' 1/14 Rankings
Dual Impact Index presented by the National Collegiate Open 1/11 Rankings