Like most issues, there is nuance that can't be boiled down into "right or wrong." Franklin has been tasked with operating a football program that thrives on the field. Of course he will(and should) want any resource or commitment that gets him to that end. If he didn't, why would he want to coach here, seriously? Jay has a responsibility to the financial vitality of the University for years to come, not merely the football program. He has a responsibility for fiscal stewardship that impacts the entirety of the university and as he stated, that is a tough proposition as the school becomes less and less affordable and they are furloughing teachers and academic projects. Both are trying to do what is right for their particular departments. You see this everywhere and business and life. That said, and I have constantly belabored the point, I don't particularly understand why Penn State enacts "half-measures" when it comes to football. Either commit everything you need to promoting a championship football team(coaching salaries, facilities, NIL opportunities, dare I say....relaxed academic standards) OR don't pay a top 10 coach $6M a year while providing average support/resources around him? I think we have conflated "success with honor" with being great at all things(wonderful academic institution with perennial championship football) as though those virtues can really coexist in the current College football environment. News flash, they can't. You have to be willing to cheat, steal, cut other sports, steroids, pay players, get rid of non revenue producing sports etc. Name the last champion that was a paragon of "Success with Honor?" If Franklin ever does leave, it will be because he did not feel FULL commitment from the university to produce a championship level football team. And look, we don't have to have a championship level football team, but if you don't want all the expenses and that come with that, then you need to be okay with average coaching, 8-9 win seasons. The top 10-15 coaches want to go to places that are ALL IN on winning. You want to know why it is even rumored that Franklin could go to an LSU or USC? Because there is no doubt those places will provide everything possible to win a championship.