For sure Spencer was one of the most dominant wrestlers we have ever seen.
What went wrong? Without a doubt 2 repared ACLs and the resulting average gas tank or worse didn't help. I think his own dominance did him in, in the end. As great as he was he really was, he did not possess a 'diverse' skill set. He is strong in neutral, and other worldly on top, but IMO his defense has too many holes, his bottom game is mediocre enough to make him vulnerable.
Ok I'll say it!!!!!
One of Cael's montras is we strive to get better every day. To me Spencer looks like a guy who dedicated too much time enduring he was the strongest physical specimen and too little time on all of his weaknesses and creating new strengths and a diversity of attacks and offensive moves.
In the end Spencer distilled down to crazy arm and hand strength, a tilt, an arm bar, and a few strong single leg takedowns. He possessed all those same skills in highschool. I don't see this version of Spencer beating Gillman. Now way.
Had Spencer gone to Penn State, his tool chest would have been overflowing with new skills and weaknesses eliminated. I believe at PSU and that red shirt year, even with 2 resisted ACLs, he is a 4xer, probably makes a run at Nolf's pin record.
Despite an incredible 3xer, in a very small sense he is just one more hammer that T&T failed to develop to his full potential. I'll also stick by the belief that Marinelli, Kemerer and Warner all win at least 1 championship each in blue and white.
So Spencer is not a 4xer, he is still one of the best ever.