Did I ever say we should shutdown the entire state? No
I said the places that are faring the worst are those that wanted to get the economy going and ignoring common sense precautions. Generally, those decisions on reopening were made at the level of the governor so that choice applies to the entire state. Some areas did better than others probably because of a combination of factors including population density, extent of travel, personal behaviors, and others.
GA, FL, AZ, and TX all wanted to reopen sooner, which is fine assuming you do it as safely as possible. But they didn’t. They decided to not to require masks and in some cases discouraged or prevent local authorities from doing so. They likely opened areas like restaurants or bars with too much capacity too quickly. Putting people indoors for extended periods without masks is tempting fate. They didn’t do enough and now they are having to back track in areas to shut down bars and are just now deciding to mandate masks.
I don’t want to shutdown again, it is costly and no fun.