- In 2023-2024, 34.2% of Philadelphia students in grades 3-8 scored proficient or above in English Language Arts (ELA)
- In 2023-2024, 21.8% of Philadelphia students in grades 3-8 scored proficient or above in math
- In 2023-2024, 41.3% of Philadelphia students in grades 4 and 8 scored proficient or above in science
Now do rural areas.
I did a quick search for "math reading proficiency rural schools pennsylvania" ... one of the first links was to Sugar Valley Charter (yay charter schools!) ... I have no idea what this school is ... I don't even know where it's located ... it's likely in Pennsyltucky somewhere ...
At Sugar Valley Rural Charter School, 22% of students scored at or above the proficient level for math, and 33% scored at or above that level for reading.
Of course, this is all some kind of nonsense, since every state sets their own proficiency levels ... PA could simply change their testing or levels and ... boom ... everyone is more proficient!
Massachusetts has MCAS testing, which is similar to the type of testing that most states have adopted, in general format ... they have 4 buckets ... "Exceeds Expectations," "Meets Expectations," "Partially Meets Expectations," and "Not Meeting Expectations." Of course, the way it's set up, in some subject matter sub-areas, you can't exceed expectations. The questions either indicate you know it, or you don't. Like, when they were really little, a bucket was whether they knew their numbers to 100. Either you did (meets) or you didn't (does not meet). Brilliant. Regardless, my older son, through the years, hovered at the lower end of "exceeds expectations" and the higher end of "meets expectations." Without knowing any better, one may think that he was an OK student ... a bit above average, maybe ...
He just had a perfect score on the math section of his PSAT, an almost perfect on the verbal, and he's a straight A student taking the toughest course-load possible (maxed out AP courses, Honors for the rest, multiple math/science courses, no "fun" courses for a break from the rat race).
Point being ... context matters. What is and is not considered "proficient" matters.