I can’t decide where to rank Spencer all-time. And keep in mind he needs to win it again first. But what do you do with him not winning his first two Big Ten tournaments? And the five losses? Would VJ have been the best PSU wrestler ever had he beaten Lewis in 2019 and won it when Covid canceled 2020? I think even with four NCAA titles, we would have put VJ behind a number of PSU two and three timers.
If he wins it all and ends up second all-time in NCAA tournament points, I’ll be willing to call him the 2nd or 3rd best NCAA tournament wrestler ever, behind Cael and possible behind Dake (whose standing in my rankings have increased dramatically.). But overall all-time? I’m just not ready to put him in the top 3. Maybe with time, I will, like how I’ve come around on Dake.