Maybe, but we have no clue. I give credit for the longevity. By that logic, how does Cael do if he wrestles 10 more years? Maybe he’s the best. Since I can’t predict what could of happened, I go by results only. Two guys have 6 golds, one of them also has 4 more medals. Which is more accomplished? The answer is clear.
Also, let’s remember how different the world is now than them. Smith lost a match in pool competition the same year he went on to win the world title. If there were pools now maybe Burroughs has 7 golds instead of 8. How about if Smith had to go through multiple Russians instead of just one?