Well, cjf stopped it down the stretch. One has to wonder why. I observed 26 didn't have the energy late in the season. Sometimes coaches manage to win battles and lose sight of the war (see the most recent Star was movie)
But overall I am not sure if your point. Are you saying that we must never speculate? So, in that case, nobody should have an opinion since we don't know if another returner would have been better or worse. And why aren't you complaining when people suggest hack wouldn't have worked in this system? Why follow recruiting since we have no idea how those kids will play in college? Perhaps you are saying CJF is perfect and never makes a coaching mistake? Is it your point that all PSU fans should just follow blindly? Is it your position that out coaching staff has never made a mistake?