ADVERTISEMENT

Hardshell Crabs prices - updated 10-30-2024

Anyone got a good place they used for Old Bay steamed crabs in the Philly Burbs? Not just by the dozen, but by the half or full bushel?
 
Well, depends what you mean by real. I would say 99.99% of the crab cakes sold utilize garbage sourced from ex-US. The demand is for bigger the better lumps even if it’s bleached ex-US garbage versus true flavor from the brine in domestic waters whether it be the Chesapeake or Louisiana Gulf. I can’t say I’ve been to any place in PA or NJ that impressed me but that’s because I compare everything to mine and nothing remotely comes close.

You're saying that all of us here in PA should meet at your place for great crab cakes?

;);)
 
I'm well past the age of sitting and picking crabs. I will devour heaping quantities of soft shell crabs and crab cakes, but picking is for young'uns who fill up mostly on hushpuppies and fries in-between itsy-bitsy little bites of crabmeat and shell shards, for about 2 hours.
 
I'm well past the age of sitting and picking crabs. I will devour heaping quantities of soft shell crabs and crab cakes, but picking is for young'uns who fill up mostly on hushpuppies and fries in-between itsy-bitsy little bites of crabmeat and shell shards, for about 2 hours.
You just don't get it. It's not a meal, it's an event.
 
Unless you want to pick and make a crab cake for me, I’ll see you in July when soft shell season starts!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BBrown
Unless you want to pick and make a crab cake for me, I’ll see you in July when soft shell season starts!
What...there is no soft shell season. In the Chesapeake crabs molt every 4 weeks or so when not hibernating. The Maryland watermen cull their catch for what are called peelers (crabs about to molt within a day or so) and place them in a tank until they actually molt. Since crabs usually come out of hibernation during April the peelers start showing up, and thus soft shells are available.
 
The price of crabs is way up this year. :(

52.jpg
Yes way up. Here in bmore they started telling us about a month ago to expect really high prices. They said it’s a low yield this year but not why🤷‍♂️.
 
Yes way up. Here in bmore they started telling us about a month ago to expect really high prices. They said it’s a low yield this year but not why🤷‍♂️.
I thought some fungus or disease hit the Bay crab population hard a couple years ago. Is that gone? Or hasn't the population rebounded yet?
 
Yes way up. Here in bmore they started telling us about a month ago to expect really high prices. They said it’s a low yield this year but not why🤷‍♂️.
Here is the winter dredge survey. Certainly down from recent years but the number of females is a good sign for next year. I suspect inflation (gas, etc.) has a lot to do with the prices. Also, when you throw $4 trillion around everyone has their hands out.

 
  • Like
Reactions: BBrown
I thought some fungus or disease hit the Bay crab population hard a couple years ago. Is that gone? Or hasn't the population rebounded yet?
That sounds kind of familiar but I think that was a while ago.
And either last year or the year before (I'm thinking 2019) was supposed to be a really good year. Unless your a local doing it for the family I'm not sure how many restaurants
use crabs that actually come from the bay. I think a lot come from the Philippines and Indonesia.
Also, last year and now this year, they have had a very, very hard time finding crab pickers (I think a lot were probably illegals, not judging) So thats really jacked up the price of shelled crab meat.(this is also true of the local Oysters).
If its in a can it probably (99%) came from indonesia or the Philippines. If its in a clear container its usually local.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PAgeologist
Just use the recipe on the Old Bay Container. It's damn good and not hard.
2 of the best places I"ve been to for crab cakes (in baltimore area) are Costas Inn
and believe it or not (its true) Box Hill Pizzeria in Abingdon, MD.
I prefer mine broiled but I had a friend do his on a charcoal grill and they were pretty awesome.
 
Last edited:
What...there is no soft shell season. In the Chesapeake crabs molt every 4 weeks or so when not hibernating. The Maryland watermen cull their catch for what are called peelers (crabs about to molt within a day or so) and place them in a tank until they actually molt. Since crabs usually come out of hibernation during April the peelers start showing up, and thus soft shells are available.
What I’ve read is that blue crabs molt in July/August.

this article says seasonality, but much longer
 
As I understand it, quality is not the issue. Harvest and picking capacity is. Our club was recently put on supply allocation as restaurants were reopening creating demand pressure.

btw, go to cap’n John’s on Cobb island.
 
You may not want to hear this, but THE best crabcakes I have ever eaten were at the Big Fish Grill in Rehoboth Beach, DE. Tons of meat and little or no filler.
Taste?
Lots of joints in Philly have little filler, but it's Asian crab, no flavor.
 
I love hearing the description of a good crab cake as "no filler". Without any "filler" it wouldn't be a crab cake as it wouldn't be able to "hold" together and therefore would be a pile of seasoned crab meat. If that's what you want order crab meat with a side of spices.

Crab cakes require some breading (bread, crackers, etc) and some eggs to bind the crab meat together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: odshowtime
Oh hell, screw this thread ..................I only read first couple posts had to go somewhere . I am coming back to SE PA early July. Been many years. Beginning of thread talks of bumper crop got me ALL excited , end of thread says prices way up and shortages :( :( :( !!!!!

Both older brothers had sailboats when I was a teen thru college Perryville and Havre de Grace . Ate many a crab accompanied with bucket of Rolling Rock.

Will sail farther south with another friend when I get back , will there at least be oysters ???????
 
  • Like
Reactions: odshowtime
Oh hell, screw this thread ..................I only read first couple posts had to go somewhere . I am coming back to SE PA early July. Been many years. Beginning of thread talks of bumper crop got me ALL excited , end of thread says prices way up and shortages :( :( :( !!!!!

Both older brothers had sailboats when I was a teen thru college Perryville and Havre de Grace . Ate many a crab accompanied with bucket of Rolling Rock.

Will sail farther south with another friend when I get back , will there at least be oysters ???????
Eastern shore st michaels
 
if I see crab cakes on the menu , I check the price. If it says Market, I might try , if it says 2 for $12 I pass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim
Don’t get a cheesesteak anywhere other that Philly. Don’t get steamed crabs or a crab cake anywhere other than Maryland.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BrucePa
Don’t get a cheesesteak anywhere other that Philly. Don’t get steamed crabs or a crab cake anywhere other than Maryland.
I like the general locavore sentiment, but the best cheesesteak I ever had in my life was in Delaware, and the best crab cake I ever had in my life was in Washington DC, but I certainly get the sentiment.

By the way, only eat Italian food in New Jersey. Don't ever violate that rule.
 
I like the general locavore sentiment, but the best cheesesteak I ever had in my life was in Delaware, and the best crab cake I ever had in my life was in Washington DC, but I certainly get the sentiment.

By the way, only eat Italian food in New Jersey. Don't ever violate that rule.
Sorry, in this household it's only eat Italian food in my wife's kitchen!!
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: mjrino and BrucePa
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT