ADVERTISEMENT

Suriano still out?

With the braggadocio coming from RU and the chatter about them being a perennial top 5 or top top 10 team, I assumed they had a history of wrestling success that I just wasn’t aware of. Nope. Got to looking at the historical team results at the link below. Of the 39 times they’ve scored team points in the NCAAs their best finish was 15th. That happened once (2016) and they did worse the next year.

Interesting to note the schools on the list with stronger wrestling credentials, many of whom have shut down their programs. No, I’m not suggesting Rutgers should shut down their program or that they won’t do well in the future. They obviously have some solid building blocks to work with at present. Just noting the apparent disconnect between their current attitude, expectations, and pending facility upgrades vis-a-vis past performance.

http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/stats/wrestling_champs_records/2017-18/D1.pdf
So what? Let them have some fun and some enthusiasm. Good for them and good that there is another program that wants to be a top 5 - 10 program and is pitting money into it to make it happen.
 
Rutgers will always be 3 levels down from PSU no matter what they have for facilities....We have Cael and a great staff who make wrestling fun....
Always is a long time.

Do not doubt the ability of Rutgers to make big strides if they get everything in place. Gooddale has the job because he had the job when Rutgers joined the Bigs. It is a bad look to fire the guy right away. If he does not produce, I can see him getting canned.

All this talk about being a top 5 team and not producing, may just be the last straw. Missouri did the same thing with Wes Roper years ago. He was the coach for a long time when the program was not fully funded. They fully funded it and gave him some time to make some strides. After a few years he got fired and Brian Smith took over and the rest is history. I can see Gooddale with a similar story in the her future. JMHO
 
I think they have a point about school support -- but it's not the one they think.

New Jersey has been picked clean by outside programs in every sport for decades. New Jersey, whose state pride is matched only by Texas. There's gotta be a reason they all leave home, and Goodale isn't the reason for all the other sports.

So I'm skeptical that a new wrestling coach will get them where they should be. Some improvement, sure. But there's deeper rot. Kinda like Pitt.

First off, theres not many NJ D1 colleges that have ever been top shelf.. Rutgers has never challenged in any major sport since their 1976 final 4 basketball team.. Seton Hall did have a couple basketball teams too. Thats it,

Rutgers could pick the bones clean for athletes in NJ but theyve never made the commitment to sports.. Now there seems to be a commitment from the school but there needs a corresponding commitment to hire top coaches to bring in recruits

Goodale has lured a few in state kids like Winston, who probably sacrificed his college career joining with Goodale... Hes brought in several good NJ wrestlers, as he should be expected to. This year Glory is going to Princeton, Kinner to tOSU & OMalley to Drexel... et al.. Who's coming in from outside NJ thats high caliber like PSU, tOSU, Iowa teams?

If Donny or Borroughs took over, it'd make a big difference but Goodale likes his boss chair too much
 
Imagine if Burroughs decided to "come home" to coach, and took the Rutgers job. I realize that at this point he has no coaching experience, and has little knowledge of being the CEO of a D1 wrestling program, but I think that someone like him could certainly keep more kids in the state, as well as pull in kids from out of state. For all we know though, he may be waiting for Manning to step down. Just an example.
Intriguing as that may be, he's also at least 2 years away from retiring, probably more. If that's something he would want. And if Rutgers would wait until he's available and ready, or even have the foresight to think of him.
 
Goodale has lured a few in state kids like Winston, who probably sacrificed his college career joining with Goodale... Hes brought in several good NJ wrestlers, as he should be expected to. This year Glory is going to Princeton, Kinner to tOSU & OMalley to Drexel... et al.. Who's coming in from outside NJ thats high caliber like PSU, tOSU, Iowa teams?
Their only significant nonresident recruits are Robinson (at Blair, from VA) and Aguilar (CA).

For being in a neighboring state, their PA efforts have been pathetic at best. Zero PA recruits again this year. To the best of my knowledge, the best PA wrestler they've had in recent memory (ever?) was Dippery before he transferred to Rider.

One would think they could fall down and land into more PA recruits than that. Rider has -- 2 PA state finalists (Fidelibus, Laird) and a potential 2018 champ (Wright).
 
Intriguing as that may be, he's also at least 2 years away from retiring, probably more. If that's something he would want. And if Rutgers would wait until he's available and ready, or even have the foresight to think of him.
I think even Rutgers would have the foresight to have a multi world and Olympic champ from their own state on a short list of possible coaches. If not, well there's bigger problems.
 
They will look for their next coach where they found their next potential national champ...PSU. Frank is a Jersey guy, has been a coach at RU and experience in multiple successful college rooms, as well as Olympic and international success. I would not be surprised at all to see him back there as a head coach.
 
First off, theres not many NJ D1 colleges that have ever been top shelf.. Rutgers has never challenged in any major sport since their 1976 final 4 basketball team.. Seton Hall did have a couple basketball teams too. Thats it,

Rutgers could pick the bones clean for athletes in NJ but theyve never made the commitment to sports.. Now there seems to be a commitment from the school but there needs a corresponding commitment to hire top coaches to bring in recruits

Goodale has lured a few in state kids like Winston, who probably sacrificed his college career joining with Goodale... Hes brought in several good NJ wrestlers, as he should be expected to. This year Glory is going to Princeton, Kinner to tOSU & OMalley to Drexel... et al.. Who's coming in from outside NJ thats high caliber like PSU, tOSU, Iowa teams?

If Donny or Borroughs took over, it'd make a big difference but Goodale likes his boss chair too much

Biggest problem Rutgers has is that it's in NJ. Just kidding, but it's probably not helping.

Perhaps they can try and convince everyone that they're really in NY...like the NY Giants.
 
They will look for their next coach where they found their next potential national champ...PSU. Frank is a Jersey guy, has been a coach at RU and experience in multiple successful college rooms, as well as Olympic and international success. I would not be surprised at all to see him back there as a head coach.
Frank is exactly who they should hire. And by the time he's done at VT, he will have significant recruiting connections in PA and OH.

"Should" being the key word -- how many times can it possibly be used about Rutgers? Also, Pitt "should" have hired Santoro, then "should" have hired Flynn, and then "should" have hired a couple other guys before they got lucky with Gavin. Programs like that are chicken and egg discussions, who they are because who they hire, and who they hire because who they are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUer1989
I'm in total agreement with you. First, Goodale never even placed at Nationals. He qualified three times at Lock Haven. He never won a state title in NJ. So his credentials as a wrestler aren't nearly as good as a ton, a literal ton, of coaches, including Santoro at Lehigh. Heck, Zach Tanelli at Columbia had more success in college and at least wrestled in the B1G. Why would you think Scott Goodale is *the* guy to lead you to the podium - or even help you be the best wrestler you can be?

Second, the stupid things he says in the media aren't exactly helping the cause. He comes across as a guy with a lot of bravado (or that he doesn't think before he talks) and little results.

Third, he is generally clueless about in-match strategy, which results in a lot of close losses for his wrestlers that could be close wins.

If I were the Rutgers AD, I'd be thinking that maybe the guy on staff with the NJ state titles and NCAA titles as a wrestler, a lot of coaching experience at the collegiate level and whose arrival on staff saw several midweight wrestlers overachieve is the guy who should be leading the program.
 
...Goodale was a successful high school coach in NJ but that doesn't always mean one will be equally successful as a college coach where the job entails recruiting, organization, alumni relations, fund raising, etc., etc., ...
...sorta like when Notre Dame hired Moeller High School coach Gerry Faust to revive their football program in the 80's... didn't work out as they had expected ... :(
 
To play devil's advocate: one could've said the same thing about Dresser at Virginia Tech, and with a much lesser in-state talent pool to draw from.

Then again, Goodale is no Dresser.

Didn’t realize Goodale’s tenure at RU mirrors Dresser’s time at VT with the exception of 1 year. Provides an interesting basis for comparison of their respective production at NCAAs, and Dresser’s apparent ability to do more with less on the talent pool front. Given that Rutgers just squeaked out a winning season this year, makes you wonder how much longer RU will be patient with Goodale.

Year / Dresser Result / Goodale Result
2017 / 6th / 19th
2016 / 4th / 15th
2015 / 10th / 31st
2014 / 8th / 34th
2013 / 10th / 35th
2012 / 11th / 45th
2011 / 33rd / 27th
2010 / 24th / 32nd
2009 / 39th / 48th
2008 / no pts / no pts
2007 / 60th / no pts
2006 / 29th / n/a
 
Imagine if Burroughs decided to "come home" to coach, and took the Rutgers job. I realize that at this point he has no coaching experience, and has little knowledge of being the CEO of a D1 wrestling program, but I think that someone like him could certainly keep more kids in the state, as well as pull in kids from out of state. For all we know though, he may be waiting for Manning to step down. Just an example.

Burroughs would have his pick of open jobs and there are jobs far better than Rutgers.
 
After reading all these comments about Goodale and who would be a good replacement.
Would Jeff Buxton ever consider the job? He certainly knows the whole Northeast for recruiting purposes and might be one the better mat instructors that a team could hire.
 
Burroughs would have his pick of open jobs and there are jobs far better than Rutgers.
True and also some jobs that are not open too. That is what happened with Cael at Iowa State, they were afraid of Ohio State hiring him and dumped Bobby Douglas to hire Cael.
 
True and also some jobs that are not open too. That is what happened with Cael at Iowa State, they were afraid of Ohio State hiring him and dumped Bobby Douglas to hire Cael.

Exactly. There are far better options than Rutgers for him.
 
Where in the world is Carman SanDiego? Dirty Jerzy!

Seriously.....if you want a quick how did we get to a 7 page thread but condensed to a couple tweets and paragraphs click on the flo link. nothing new, just a rehash of how we got here.

https://www.flowrestling.org/articles/6125198-where-in-the-world-is-nicky-suriano

According to Flo article, 'however we have yet to hear an official word on the topic from Rutgers.'

I'd expect NJ.COM to crush Rutgers and Goodale for not being more forthcoming and available to discuss this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: diggerpup
According to Flo article, 'however we have yet to hear an official word on the topic from Rutgers.'

I'd expect NJ.COM to crush Rutgers and Goodale for not being more forthcoming and available to discuss this.
History shows that when NJ.com gets around to writing an article on Suriano whatever the story, somehow it is Cael's and Penn State's fault.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUer1989
I mostly agree. If he had a better resume as a wrestler, you might think (regardless of how erroneously) he could get you on the podium. But you are correct, his being stuck in the 15-20 range as a coach in "good" years and in the 30s in off years for so long sort of indicates what he really is. That and his ridiculous claims about the program combine to paint a picture of a Rex Ryan-like figure. And I knew plenty of Jets fans who were drinking the Ryan kool aid.

A Goodale acolyte on the Scarlet board will say he hasn't had the support of the school previously and that now that he is fully funded the results will surely follow, but the results since he has been funded, including this year, bely that. I agree with Johnny Handsome that they need a new coach and he might be under Rutgers' nose. Maybe next year, when it's highly possible the wheels will come off the cart with the losses of their seniors, people will get a more accurate reading on Goodale and make a move to Pritzlaff - because I think he is the one who is really responsible for whatever progress the program has seen. That hiring was the best thing Goodale has done at Rutgers, imo.


Donny doesn't want the responsibilities the HC has to deal with. Talking with adminstration, etc. He just wants to coach wrestling. That is what I was told when I mentioned to my friend (RU Wrestler from 04-08, season ticket holder) that we need a better coach to take us to the next level.
 
History shows that when NJ.com gets around to writing an article on Suriano whatever the story, somehow it is Cael's and Penn State's fault.

Indeed! I was sarcasticly pointing out their journalistic double standard.
 
Where in the world is Carman SanDiego? Dirty Jerzy!

Seriously.....if you want a quick how did we get to a 7 page thread but condensed to a couple tweets and paragraphs click on the flo link. nothing new, just a rehash of how we got here.

https://www.flowrestling.org/articles/6125198-where-in-the-world-is-nicky-suriano

Just read the flo article. Am I to understand they pulled 2 different true freshman shirts in consecutive duels. I had heard one but did not know 2 were pulled. Are these 2 just depth/room guys or potential future starters?

Disclaimer.....I am not sure how one defines “depth/room guys” but Rutgers should define it differently than Penn State, Iowa or tOSU do. Despite the fact they are a perennial top 5 or 10 team. o_O
 
A bunch of Division 1 Programs are going to get better landing Pennsylvania top recruits..Penn State starts 3 in State guys.
Keener, Retherford, Nolf, Joseph, and McCutchen until Injured. Not sure where you are going with this statement.
 
What does this even mean? Have they not bee trying already?
It means the only PA guy they've landed in 5+ years was Tyson Dippery, and virtually every other program east of the Rockies recruits PA, even Sparty got a PA state champ, but now they're ready.
 
  • Like
Reactions: diggerpup
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT