I'm in total agreement with you. First, Goodale never even placed at Nationals. He qualified three times at Lock Haven. He never won a state title in NJ. So his credentials as a wrestler aren't nearly as good as a ton, a literal ton, of coaches, including Santoro at Lehigh. Heck, Zach Tanelli at Columbia had more success in college and at least wrestled in the B1G. Why would you think Scott Goodale is *the* guy to lead you to the podium - or even help you be the best wrestler you can be?
Second, the stupid things he says in the media aren't exactly helping the cause. He comes across as a guy with a lot of bravado (or that he doesn't think before he talks) and little results.
Third, he is generally clueless about in-match strategy, which results in a lot of close losses for his wrestlers that could be close wins.
If I were the Rutgers AD, I'd be thinking that maybe the guy on staff with the NJ state titles and NCAA titles as a wrestler, a lot of coaching experience at the collegiate level and whose arrival on staff saw several midweight wrestlers overachieve is the guy who should be leading the program.