I recently watched a Franco Wrestling video which gave us the definitive answer (?!!). Yeah, the guy is pretty annoying, but since I saw it on the internet, it must be so.
The video was to name the greatest team ever that won 5 NCAA championships. There were 5 contestants, 2 Iowa teams, an Okie State team, and 2 from PSU. Of course they are the two teams being compared in this thread.
After long and tedious explanations, he concluded that Penn State 2017 was the greatest 5 champion team in history. But he ranked an Iowa team and the Okie State team just behind them.
Franco Wrestling said it. I rest my case.
Seems to me, we should allow the 2022 team members to actually finish their college careers, then look back and compare again.