Yeah, I believe we're pretty much on the same page here.
Those Pitt fans, like many Penn State fans, don't actually follow the sport as a whole. Anyone that thought Northwestern was going to get killed by Pitt isn't a true fan of the sport. Picking Pitt to win would have fine but Northwestern's offense is too talented not to move the ball well against Pitt's defense.
As you know, the B1G being overrated is largely incorrect and perceived because the B1G had to play up in most bowl games. Penn State and Michigan played extremely well. Ohio State's failure to show up really, really helped people push their agenda.
I get why people are criticizing Narduzzi for failing to win 9+ given the state of the Coastal Division but Pitt is performing well for what is reasonable to be expected at Pitt. Kind of like when people think Ferentz or Pat Fitzgerald aren't good coaches. Iowa & Northwestern aren't going to dominate. They'll have solid year and maybe once in a while a great year but they're going to remain a mid-level BIG program. Just like Pitt can became a steady solid performer in the ACC and probably win a weak division from time to time. Unless Richt gets Miami on a roll.
Narduzzi CAN coach--doesn't mean he's elite. I believe he's an excellent coach for Pitt at this time. I also believe he won't be there long. I also believe many here don't like him simply because of his recruiting tactics but that's just an opinion.