There is a accepted process for this these days from tiny organizations all the way up through Governmental leadership. Having Franklin, considering his position at the university, be the one to say that succinctly, would be immeasurably better than the dancing off stage right.
Franklin presser
- Thread starter creamery
- Start date
Then keep pushing back! He's not a snowflake. He is compensated very well and he doesn't need some little insubordinate to fight his fight. I'm done, we could all argue about this all night, I thought he came across as weak and wholly unaccountable. He recruited the players, I don't blame him for their criminal acts, but if you are the leader of the program you can at least spar with the media a little. He's always been thin skinned and pavloved the PSU beat into weak little questions in his media scrums...."hey, how are you james" It's just weak to walk off and have some young team pr kid to keep banging the statement.
Everyone eventually sees the light and agrees with me lol
I'm not even criticizing Franklin. I'm criticizing the PR group that came up with this idiotic approach. I'm just tired of us handling every issue that should be a nonstory so horribly wrong it gets blown out of proportion.
Really bad take. There is no way Penn State legal counsel was going to let him “spar with the media a little” on this. They were protecting him and the University by not letting him speak. You follow the advice of your legal counsel.
Ram, I think you make a valid point and make it well as usual, but at the end of the day, I still think this qualifies as a non-story. In fact, it will be history by tomorrow though of course the case itself won't be...nor should it be.
I saw an ESPN piece -- not sure if it's the one you're referring to -- and the focus was Franklin's declining to comment and the facts of the police case. There was mention of the flunky coming out twice to address the reporters' questions but nothing much seemed to be made of that in the write-up.
In other words, the thrust of the item was not the flunky's role at all. Meanwhile, we both agree that there was never any way in hell that Franklin could have or should have commented on the former players or the case against them. I mean, they're long gone from both the team and the university.
As for social media, we all know it's a sewer. Franklin could have stood on his head and levitated to the ceiling. It wouldn't matter. The same people would say the same things regardless.
In sum, I tend to agree with you that it would have been better for Franklin to simply have given the necessary canned answer to the predictable question. Stepping away from the podium was an unnecessarily odd look. But I just don't think it matters much though I respect your opposing view of the question.
he did. he referred them to the spokesperson, as the school (his boss) told him to do. When they keep asking the same question you keep referring them to the comms director. He had no choice but to do what he was told to do.
Now, you may feel PSU was wrong. OK. But again, what are you supposed to say?
"The kids are rat bastards." Well, that would be considered callous and demeaning to them as well as assuming they are guilty. Then they could sue the university for slander should they get off or, even if they don't, that you influenced the jury pool.
"The kids are nice kids who did a dumb thing." That would be considered to be callous to the alleged victim and trying to influence other victims who are hesitant to come forward.
You can't win. You simply say that the university released a statement and there will be no other comment. That is exactly what they did before the clip and after the media edited the clip to get more clicks.
Honestly, I often do wonder if they are so isolated up there in their own little kingdom that they get blindsided by reality at times.
From the BoT who are controlled by only a few people with the rest just there to vote yes on everything, to Old Main and their media/PR folks who are very insular- they all live in an echo chamber. They’re the big fish in the little pond who are used to always getting their way.
Then issues like JS hit or an awkward press conference like yesterday and they get indignant and wrong footed when there’s push back.
They really need new blood from the BoT on down but they’ve created an insular atmosphere to prevent that. It would take the governor and legislature in Harrisburg to break that monopoly but they’re too busy running for higher office than to oversee issues with the state university. It’s so frustrating at times.
Oh my God, he can just say "I'm not going to address legal matters" he can even say, the university has asked me not to comment.....im criticizing the optics of him walking off stage. The little PR guy could have made his announcement 10 minutes earlier, and first question asked, Franklin leaves entirely. If you think I'm wrong, why is it that every other institution handles these things better? I agree it was blown up as a "gotcha" I don't blame Franklin personally, just from a PURE PR and optics standpoint it made him look weak.
That is exactly what was said before the press conference. The reporters asked the question and CJF referred to the spokesperson who said "you saw the release. we will have no other comment". Then they asked again, and CJF stepped aside to give the spokesperson the mic.
It isn't that complicated. the media edited out the version where the media was told there would be no comment on that issue. They asked anyway and are now trying to blow it up. it appears, successfully.
Okay, then I'll play ball. We have the single most sinister team media in the country(people have suggested as much) so all the more reason for Franklin to be a forceful leader and say, "i won't be taking questions on any pending legal matters and if I receive one, this press conference is OVER" Just not that hard and again, PSU is Alaways shocked and awed by how lousy the team beat is. Never able to head it off at the pass.
That is, basically, what was said to the reporters before the press conference and the video they are releasing. So the media persisted in asking but instead of ending the presser, he had the comms guy refer to the press release and AGAIN, state that they would have no further comment.
By my count, that is THREE TIMES the media was told that they would not comment. Before the presser. After the first question. After the second question.
I am not sure how storming off the stage would have been a better look. Especially since the media would simply show the question being asked and Franklin storming off.
Then perhaps penn state needs to reconsider their media credentialing. This is the ONLY school media in the country that would do this after being warned repeatedly it wouldn't be addressed. Something needs to change and a little brow beating from the 28 year old PR twerp ain't it. There is a way for a forceful coach to push back without making it appear that the media has to be sycophantic. Saban would have threaded the needle.
I live in Ohio. You should see how the media fawns over the players and coaches. Interestingly, they are vicious on the Browns, Guardians, Cavs, Bengals, and Reds. But the blue jackets and tOSU can do no wrong.
Regardless, CJF is very gracious with the media. he always tells them that he appreciates them covering the team. Perhaps you are correct. I don't think they bring any value. The MSM is dead for all intents and purposes. Just play the games. Screw the mid-week pressers. What value do they bring PSU? Zero.
GREAT point. Perhaps CJF should have said, "In hindsight, I wish I had done more."
The kids were fired. HR doesn't usually explain why an average employee was fired. Get used to it. We are not entitled to know.
True. That is why Franklin said nothing.
I think just about everyone learned what not to do. That includes psu. Say nothing. Criminal law is not the football coach' area of expertise. If the reporter wants to go interview the DA or the police then fine. Go ahead.
I always thought the press should have been camped out in front of the police chiefs house, not joes.
They already issued the statement before the PC. Any legit reporter with a clue would know that. Only the clueless one's re-ask what they know won't get a response from Franklin.
Yep, "again" why would Franklin issue the statement when PSU had already given that responsibility to someone else, and PSU clearly expected Franklin to NOT address it and just stick to football (oh, that's actually his job ....)
HandjoCommando is dead wrong as per usual - he says CJF can do this.... can do that.... blah, blah, blah.... When he absolutely was not at liberty to say, or do, any of the things blowhard troll-boy says. What blowhard troll-boy does not mention is that the University's Communications Director had just read an Official Statement to the media and told them that CJF was not permitted to provide any comment on the topic whatever (and they were told this immediately prior to the short clip excerpted on media intentionally misleading the viewer as to what transpired).
No...that's not why Franklin did nothing
Penn State's issue was that they didn't say anything. Are you honestly this in love with Franklin, who I didn't even say was wrong, that you now think the issue was Penn State spoke too much?
HandjoCommando is the biggest a$$hole troll on this board and his continual fraudulent use of "we" to aid his douchebag poser-trolling is a perfect example. He is the last person on earth who should be lecturing anyone about anything as his troll opinion is about as valuable as a turd floating in a cesspool.
You're wrong. Reporters never simply take the statement. They knew of the statement. They're still asking questions
Again...Franklin walking away was the problem. That's what he was told to do it was the wrong PR move if you've read anything by the media.
This is related to football and is his job...we just have idiots giving PR advice causing problems. This isn't anti-Franklin.
You blaming the media is hysterical
Again, Franklin was told to not address questions on that subject which is what he did. He clearly was looking for actual football questions.
Franklin is NOT responsible for PSU statements on legal issues and anyone expecting him to perform in that way in any manner is clueless.
You're defending the media is hysterical.
Because the accused are no longer members of the football program, CJF should not be commenting in any manner if but for no other reason to insulate himself from personal legal repercussions. There are people in the university who are paid to comment on university matters outside of athletics and they should be the ones doing it.
Cracks me up, CJF was absolutely told what to do by his employer (you see this situation often when an employer requires an Executive to defer questions to a designated spokesperson at a Press Conference - be it a Private Corporation or even a Public Entity). Just laughable that you have morons on here saying, Franklin could have done this.... or Franklin could have done that..... blah, blah, blah..... when CJF was absolutely told precisely what to do if he was asked a question immediately following the SID telling the media NOT TO DO THIS (i.e., CJF was told that he should return the mic to the SID if the media asked him a question that they were just told literally moments earlier not to ask him and that he would not be permitted to answer - again, they were just told CJF would not be permitted to provide an answer of any kind if they asked this question....). Just laughable that idiots on here are saying, Franklin could have done this.... or Franklin could have done that.... bullshit. CJF did precisely what he was told to do by his employer - so these morons actually believe that the University anticipated this situation to the point that they led off the PC with a very specific and explicit statement by the University's Official Spokesperson (including the specific statement that Coach Franklin would not be permitted to provide a comment of any kind), but the University never thought to give very specific instruction to CJF if the question were asked??? Okee dokee.....
CJF does not have the option of following, or not following, the University's very specific instruction on the matter. He either does what they tell him to do, or it's a fireable offense under his contract. Pure bullshit that Franklin is at liberty to do as he chooses here.
That’s right. And the incident has nothing to do with Penn State. It’s like fingering Amazon because an employee sold drugs on his own after work. The media makes it about Penn State because that sells.
Always be Closing. Then they wonder why they are going away
Define saying too much...it was what he said not that he spoke
Just like all Franklin has to do is say "refer to our prior statement"
Again, Franklin got bad advice. I'm not blaming Franklin. That's not how any sane program would handle this
Franklin is 100% responsible for what happens with players on the program which is why every takeaway is "he walked away". That's not leadership. It's not his fault, but that of the PR depth
The media did nothing wrong here. They asked basic questions.
