ADVERTISEMENT

Jay Paterno's letter to Urban Meyer asking for a spot on his staff

Hired/fired --- same difference. The key point was whether the entity employed the person.

That "risk" was 0.0000001%.

People who say "I read the Freeh Report, and based on reading such, I think Jay Paterno and/or Tom Bradley are pedophile enablers" are, from my anecdotal experience, about 1 in a few hundred.

And that 1 person in a few hundred is an idiot --- all you have to do to refute it is say "those two guys aren't even mentioned in the report! What a ridiculous conclusion."

BTW --- my poll concerning the word "some" is in progress. I plan on releasing the results at the end of the week.


In the realm of the irrelevant......you are the clear cut leader of the pack.

th
 
  • Like
Reactions: simons96
The mindless hatred of Jay is eclipsed only by the ridiculousness of some of the posts.
 
Well, I don't mean he's been negative, but I follow him on twitter and he rarely posts about supporting Penn State football. I do see him support other sports (like Women's Volleyball) though. With regard to Franklin, I'm not sure I've seen any comment from him.

I can't imagine why he would not want to support Franklin. He supported The First New Guy. Why not the Next New Guy.
 
That fits my personal anecdotal evidence as well.

I think Jay was generally well-liked nationally from the November 2011 to February 2013 era. I think it was a tactical error to have Jay so front-and-center with media interviews and such when the "Paterno Report" was released that February.

Not that people began to "implicate" Jay in anything beginning in February 2013 --- but like it or not, Jay's father is a controversial figure and Jay became a public figure in said controversial discussion.

I think the better tactical decision would have been to let Scott take the lead regarding the media in February 2013, while Jay continued to focus on football and nothing but football.

Generally well liked - so you mean emails and social media posts where people told him to rot in hell for what "his father allowed to happen". Or that he could not send his kids to school for a few days because of the massive media onslaught after the "leaked" GJ presentment.

Seriously - you are just bad at logic. You are, however, very good and conjecture. I will credit you for that.
 
I don't understand all the hate directed at Jay, either. I was hardly ever his biggest fan, but this ongoing vitriol toward one of our own is absurd.
Urban may be who he is, but he, Herbie, and Luke Fickle all came to Joe's memorial ceremony at the BJC. Joe and Meyer had a friendship. The primary - maybe only - reason Urban now has such a distaste for PSU is because of the way PSU handled Joe and treated him so poorly while all this was going down. Same with Fitz of Northwestern People who knew Joe, as Meyer and Fitz did, know that he did not do anything to impede any investigation of JS.
Jay has a right to reach out to his network and look for a job in coaching. I'd like to see the response from Meyer. Could help solidify the Paternos' argument that all this trash thrown at them has greatly harmed future career opportunities. None of us on this board are in a position to say whether or not Jay should be or would be a realistic candidate for another Div. 1A, Power 5 opportunity as an assistant, as a coordinator, or even as a head coach.


Vitriol towards our own is something that became big time here post-9/11.

At first I could not believe the words coming off the fingers of Penn Staters. Then I learned to accept the stupidity and inanity of it.

This Jay hatred is a good sports-related example of it.
 
Well, I don't mean he's been negative, but I follow him on twitter and he rarely posts about supporting Penn State football. I do see him support other sports (like Women's Volleyball) though. With regard to Franklin, I'm not sure I've seen any comment from him.


I think Jay realizes anything he says/tweets regarding PSU football will be put under a microscope and has potential to be a distraction if taken the wrong way. It's Franklin's team and he certainly respects that...but also doesn't need to be a cheerleader on social media to prove it.

A lot of his support for other sports at PSU could just as easily be support for the coaches that he knows personally.
 
FYI:
Dec 2011: Jay applied for the HC job at Penn State
Feb 2012: Discussions with HBO about JVP documentary(also discussions with Showtime, ESPN, and Fox)
March/April 2012: Discussions with ESPN about commentator role
June 2012: Agreement with ESPN to produce documentary
July 2012: ESPN no longer interested in documentary
April 2013: Discussions with CBS about commentator and analyst role
Spring 2013-Spring 2015: Discussions with Fox about commentator and analyst role
Dec 2012: Applied for BC head coach
Dec 2012: Applied for Colorado head coach
Dec 2012: Was advised by Temple that they would not consider any former Penn State coaches for head coach job
Dec 2013: Applied for UConn head coach
Dec 2013: Applied for JMU head coach
Dec 2014: Applied for QB coach at Georgia
Dec 2014: Applied for QB coach at WVU
 
FYI:
Dec 2011: Jay applied for the HC job at Penn State
Feb 2012: Discussions with HBO about JVP documentary(also discussions with Showtime, ESPN, and Fox)
March/April 2012: Discussions with ESPN about commentator role
June 2012: Agreement with ESPN to produce documentary
July 2012: ESPN no longer interested in documentary
April 2013: Discussions with CBS about commentator and analyst role
Spring 2013-Spring 2015: Discussions with Fox about commentator and analyst role
Dec 2012: Applied for BC head coach
Dec 2012: Applied for Colorado head coach
Dec 2012: Was advised by Temple that they would not consider any former Penn State coaches for head coach job
Dec 2013: Applied for UConn head coach
Dec 2013: Applied for JMU head coach
Dec 2014: Applied for QB coach at Georgia
Dec 2014: Applied for QB coach at WVU

The HC applications are a bit shocking IMO. QB Coach at Georgia and WVU are about where he should be aiming. Temple arrogance is hilarious though.
 
Jay will never be hired anywhere, so long as he is in the news and pursuing lawsuits. No school will want the media distraction.

If he ever goes quiet and lays low for awhile like Bradley did, then he may get an opportunity based on coaching ability and experience. Will need to let go of Penn State first.

Most likely will have to start out with a lower target like Tom did as far as schools.
 
The HC applications are a bit shocking IMO. QB Coach at Georgia and WVU are about where he should be aiming. Temple arrogance is hilarious though.
Why?? Most ass't want to be a HFC. the offensive co-coordinator at a very successful B1G school, going to a couple of tough places to coach?? Seems reasonable to me.
 
Why?? Most ass't want to be a HFC. the offensive co-coordinator at a very successful B1G school, going to a couple of tough places to coach?? Seems reasonable to me.

Jay's resume, on paper, has him topping out at QB Coach. His next step is O Coordinator somewhere (and not de facto OC courtesy of his father). James Madison is about the level of HC he should have been aiming for. BC, Colorado, and even UConn are above his pay grade and experience IMO.
 
Jay's resume, on paper, has him topping out at QB Coach. His next step is O Coordinator somewhere (and not de facto OC courtesy of his father). James Madison is about the level of HC he should have been aiming for. BC, Colorado, and even UConn are above his pay grade and experience IMO.
well one of the bitches about coaching for JVP was he was not in to big titles for assistant coaches. It made it tough sometimes for guys to go elsewhere, because the media generally would conclude what you concluded. Heck I think tv media wanted JVP to name coordinators just so they knew who to blame.

Look at Galen resume, he was just the RB's coach as far as the official site is concerned. http://www.gopsusports.com/sports/m-footbl/mtt/hall_galen00.html

The Eagles hired Andy Reid from the Packers, and he was 'only' a QB coach. So you never know until you ask.
 
well one of the bitches about coaching for JVP was he was not in to big titles for assistant coaches. It made it tough sometimes for guys to go elsewhere, because the media generally would conclude what you concluded. Heck I think tv media wanted JVP to name coordinators just so they knew who to blame.

Look at Galen resume, he was just the RB's coach as far as the official site is concerned. http://www.gopsusports.com/sports/m-footbl/mtt/hall_galen00.html

The Eagles hired Andy Reid from the Packers, and he was 'only' a QB coach. So you never know until you ask.

I think Reid was also Assistant HC when the Eagles hired him, he had years of coaching at different levels, and worked with a HOF QB, possibly the best of all time. Big difference IMO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mn78psu83
I think Reid was also Assistant HC when the Eagles hired him, he had years of coaching at different levels, and worked with a HOF QB, possibly the best of all time. Big difference IMO.
no Andy was the QB coach. Besides the title 'Asst HC" just means that one has gotten a pretty big raise, and needed a title to justify the raise. That's why you see some teans have both an 'Assistant HC', and an 'Associate HC'.
We know Jay didn't get hired, but there is no reason for him not to seek HC positions. Why should he self determine if he's qualified?? That's someone else's job. To be clear, I am not saying Jay should have been hired for those positions, I am just saying, he had the qualifications to apply for those jobs.

here is part of AR Wiki- you'll have to show where he was AHC, as there is no mention of that title anywhere.

He was hired as an assistant coach by the Green Bay Packers in 1992, the same year quarterback Brett Favre became a member of that team. Reid was named the Packers' quarterbacks coach in 1997, the season after the Packers won Super Bowl XXXI.

Philadelphia Eagles[edit]
The quality of Reid's work with the Packers attracted considerable notice throughout the league, leading to his being hired as the head coach of the Eagles on January 11, 1999. At the time, many in the local media in Philadelphia criticized the hiring, citing the availability of other candidates who had past records of success as head coaches. It was noted that Reid had never been an offensive coordinator or defensive coordinator
 
Last edited:
FYI:
Dec 2011: Jay applied for the HC job at Penn State
Feb 2012: Discussions with HBO about JVP documentary(also discussions with Showtime, ESPN, and Fox)
March/April 2012: Discussions with ESPN about commentator role
June 2012: Agreement with ESPN to produce documentary
July 2012: ESPN no longer interested in documentary
April 2013: Discussions with CBS about commentator and analyst role
Spring 2013-Spring 2015: Discussions with Fox about commentator and analyst role
Dec 2012: Applied for BC head coach
Dec 2012: Applied for Colorado head coach
Dec 2012: Was advised by Temple that they would not consider any former Penn State coaches for head coach job
Dec 2013: Applied for UConn head coach
Dec 2013: Applied for JMU head coach
Dec 2014: Applied for QB coach at Georgia
Dec 2014: Applied for QB coach at WVU

Thanks Lundy thats some excellent info and maybe will make some posters at least admit they were wrong,(fat chance).
But hey we will be getting "poll" results shortly so there's that. o_O
 
The HC applications are a bit shocking IMO. QB Coach at Georgia and WVU are about where he should be aiming. Temple arrogance is hilarious though.

I don't think him applying for the HC position at Uconn or JMU is "shocking" especially since he coached at JMU before.
Yea the Temple thing I had no idea about and not sure how much more evidence the courts would need than that alone.
 
Thanks Lundy thats some excellent info and maybe will make some posters at least admit they were wrong,(fat chance).
But hey we will be getting "poll" results shortly so there's that. o_O

If Jay can prove that someone at Temple advised him that "no former Penn State coaches would be considered for the Temple Head Coach job" then Jay has something.

Key word -- again --- is "prove." I'll admit I'm wrong if/when Jay proves it.

FWIW, per yesterday's court documents, Jay himself doesn't use the "some means a number more than one" argument as regards his claim that "a reasonable person would believe that the statement "some coaches, administrators, and football staff members" in the Consent Decree was directed at you (Jay) personally." See page 150 of the longer PDF from yesterday.
 
Last edited:
If Jay can prove that someone at Temple advised him that "no former Penn State coaches would be considered for the Temple Head Coach job" then Jay has something.

Key word -- again --- is "prove." I'll admit I'm wrong if/when Jay proves it.

I highly doubt those are the words Temple used and even if it was, isn't it there prerogative to hire who they want and stay away from who they want, even if its dumb?
 
If Jay can prove that someone at Temple advised him that "no former Penn State coaches would be considered for the Temple Head Coach job" then Jay has something.

Key word -- again --- is "prove." I'll admit I'm wrong if/when Jay proves it.

Whether or not you admit that your are wrong is not at all relevant.
 
I highly doubt those are the words Temple used and even if it was, isn't it there prerogative to hire who they want and stay away from who they want, even if its dumb?

Those may not be the words Temple used --- but they ARE the words Jay Paterno used per the court documents released yesterday.
 
no Andy was the QB coach. Besides the title 'Asst HC" just means that one has gotten a pretty big raise, and needed a title to justify the raise. That's why you see some teans have both an 'Assistant HC', and an 'Associate HC'.
We know Jay didn't get hired, but there is no reason for him not to seek HC positions. Why should he self determine if he's qualified?? That's someone else's job. To be clear, I am not saying Jay should have been hired for those positions, I am just saying, he had the qualifications to apply for those jobs.

here is part of AR Wiki- you'll have to show where he was AHC, as there is no mention of that title anywhere.

He was hired as an assistant coach by the Green Bay Packers in 1992, the same year quarterback Brett Favre became a member of that team. Reid was named the Packers' quarterbacks coach in 1997, the season after the Packers won Super Bowl XXXI.

Philadelphia Eagles[edit]
The quality of Reid's work with the Packers attracted considerable notice throughout the league, leading to his being hired as the head coach of the Eagles on January 11, 1999. At the time, many in the local media in Philadelphia criticized the hiring, citing the availability of other candidates who had past records of success as head coaches. It was noted that Reid had never been an offensive coordinator or defensive coordinator

To be clear, I am not saying Jay should have been hired for those positions, I am just saying, he had the qualifications to apply for those jobs.

Yes. He did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BBrown
If Jay can prove that someone at Temple advised him that "no former Penn State coaches would be considered for the Temple Head Coach job" then Jay has something.

Key word -- again --- is "prove." I'll admit I'm wrong if/when Jay proves it.

FWIW, per yesterday's court documents, Jay himself doesn't use the "some means a number more than one" argument as regards his claim that "a reasonable person would believe that the statement "some coaches, administrators, and football staff members" in the Consent Decree was directed at you (Jay) personally." See page 150 of the longer PDF from yesterday.

Do you really think that will be that difficult? They just have to say it during deposition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BBrown
To be clear, I am not saying Jay should have been hired for those positions, I am just saying, he had the qualifications to apply for those jobs.

Yes. He did.

Name people who have been hired as a Head Coach at a FBS-level school with:

(1) No prior experience as a Head Coach at any level.
(2) No prior experience as an offensive or defensive coordinator at any level.
(3) Wasn't already on the staff at said school in the year before.

I honestly cannot think of one person who fits (1), (2), or (3). Pat Fitzgerald and Kyle Flood are B1G coaches who fit both (1) and (2).
 
It's relevant as regards BBrown's original post to me --- where he implies that I don't admit where I'm wrong.

I've admitted where I'm wrong a number of times before, and would do it again here.

Could you provide a link to those times please? Cause I don't remember them.
I think you've had the Paterno suit wrong from day 1.
 
Could you provide a link to those times please? Cause I don't remember them.
I think you've had the Paterno suit wrong from day 1.

See post #56 of this very thread. I admitted I was wrong, and someone else had a better point.

Another example: I was wrong in that I thought the NCAA would never restore the Paterno victories short of being ordered to do so by a court. Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong.
 
Name people who have been hired as a Head Coach at a FBS-level school with:

(1) No prior experience as a Head Coach at any level.
(2) No prior experience as an offensive or defensive coordinator at any level.
(3) Wasn't already on the staff at said school in the year before.

I honestly cannot think of one person who fits (1), (2), or (3). Pat Fitzgerald and Kyle Flood are B1G coaches who fit both (1) and (2).


Everyone knows that Jay was the OC and QB coach. Just stop trying to move the goal posts.
 
Name people who have been hired as a Head Coach at a FBS-level school with:

(1) No prior experience as a Head Coach at any level.
(2) No prior experience as an offensive or defensive coordinator at any level.
(3) Wasn't already on the staff at said school in the year before.

I honestly cannot think of one person who fits (1), (2), or (3). Pat Fitzgerald and Kyle Flood are B1G coaches who fit both (1) and (2).
Yes, and he was from PSU. Jim Caldwell.
LINK: Jim Caldwell

1977 Iowa
(graduate assistant)
1978–1980 Southern Illinois
(wide receivers coach)
1981 Northwestern
(assistant - offense)
1982–1984 Colorado
(wide receivers coach)
1985 Louisville
(wide receivers coach)
1986–1992 Penn State
(quarterbacks coach)

1993–2000 Wake Forest
(head coach)
 
See post #56 of this very thread. I admitted I was wrong, and someone else had a better point.

Another example: I was wrong in that I thought the NCAA would never restore the Paterno victories short of being ordered to do so by a court. Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong.

Thats it post #56? Sorry not impressed.
 
Yes, and he was from PSU. Jim Caldwell.
LINK: Jim Caldwell

1977 Iowa
(graduate assistant)
1978–1980 Southern Illinois
(wide receivers coach)
1981 Northwestern
(assistant - offense)
1982–1984 Colorado
(wide receivers coach)
1985 Louisville
(wide receivers coach)
1986–1992 Penn State
(quarterbacks coach)

1993–2000 Wake Forest
(head coach)

Good find, well done.
 
Then a lot of people, you included, need to apologize to Jay for his play calling.

Are you going to admit you were wrong then in arguing that Jay Paterno as an offensive coordinator? This "admit you were wrong" argument goes both ways .........

Most of my criticisms around Jay center not around play-calling (that is on Galen and Joe), but around reports over the years that he wasn't well-respected in the locker room. The most infamous example, of course, being the Drew Astorino incident in 2011.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT